3 ms·
>A careful reading of Intel patents suggests that SGX >instructions are implemented entirely in microcode. If new >ISA features are new microcode, that opens up
by anon6353 9y ago
>A careful reading of Intel patents suggests that SGX >instructions are implemented entirely in microcode. If new >ISA features are new microcode, that opens up the >possibility of supporting them on existing CPUs.
The SGX instructions are essentially key management for full memory encryption. Does he really think memory encryption could be implemented in microcode?
That's an obvious flaw of his proposal.
I'm really surprised no paper reviewer caught that. What happened to peer review?
- pjc50 9y ago> Does he really think memory encryption could be implemented in microcode? Yes? Why not? This argument rather relies on knowing what the (trade secret) capabilities of the microcode are. I don't see why this warrants a smear on peer review.
- locacorten 9y agoThe argument the paper makes does not rest on whether memory encryption is implemented solely in microcode. All the problems with SGX lie with its management part not with the encryption part. I'm referring to side-channel attacks and lack of secure counters. If you read the paper carefully, there are many other arguments one can make against it. However, it is an interesting paper and its message is worth considering. Peer-review is not a perfect process. I think the research community is better off with publishing such a paper.