16 ms·
Inside the Largest US Voter Data Leak
- rootsudo 9y agoIn other news, already known information. Every USA states has clear laws on releasing whose registered with which party, past affiliation and address. Clickbait.
- yincrash 9y agoAre you sure it's all public known information? ---- The data was amassed from a variety of sources—from the banned subreddit r/fatpeoplehate to American Crossroads, the super PAC co-founded by former White House strategist Karl Rove.
- msumpter 9y agoHere is the direct link to Upguard's write up (most of the Gizmodo details are here): https://www.upguard.com/breaches/the-rnc-files https://www.upguard.com/breaches/the-rnc-files It is mostly publicly available data, but not always easily accessible (states have varying requirements and methods of acquisition), firms go through quite a bit to get aggregate files in all 50 states. For them to be put up with no protection is jarring. But not surprising with other recent disclosures. I only wish we had access to the files to do some queries across them!
- 317070 9y agoFrom the article: > Along with home addresses, birthdates, and phone numbers, the records include advanced sentiment analyses used by political groups to predict where individual voters fall on hot-button issues such as gun ownership, stem cell research, and the right to abortion, as well as suspected religious affiliation and ethnicity. In some Western countries, the mere existence of such a database would be illegal. Especially relating to religion and ethnicity. http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/can-the-french-talk-about-race http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/can-the-french-talk-... In the US, it is leaked online.
- ryanlol 9y ago>In the US, it is leaked online. It's not a "leak" when the data is entirely public already...
- kakarot 9y agoIt is a "leak" when additional data that was previously private, such as modeling and analytic information, gets published against the will of its owners. However, it isn't a "leak" in the traditional colloquial sense that someone stole the data and released it to the public. It's just a security leak.
- matthewbauer 9y agoFrance is the only country I'm aware of where that's the case.
- lol214365 9y agoFrance sure is a model for the US to follow...
- PeterisP 9y agoAs far as I understand, the religion/ethnicity columns are not a fact, not a record and not something private provided by the person themselves or some agency - it's a modelling guess that they've made based on other publicly available data. So, if I look at your post history and make a guess about what religion and ethnicity you might have, and write that down, am I in possession of an illegal database if I lived in e.g. France? I did take a quick look, and it seems that I have a good idea about your full name, face, hair color, political views and party affiliation, your employer, etc. All this data (together with demographics of others) would also allow to make some guess about your religious preferences. All of that might be wrong, but it might also be right, so let's assume for the sake of argument that I write my guesses down and happen to have an entry that contains your full name, ethnicity and religion, just like the leaked data has. Should this be considered a crime? Does this change depending on how many people I look at? Does this change depending on how accurate my guesses are?
- chillingeffect 9y ago> already known information. No. Records released include "names, dates of birth, home addresses, phone numbers, and voter registration details, as well as data described as “modeled” voter ethnicities and religions." [0] Dates of Birth, Phone Numbers, Email Addresses are not public information. [1] [2] [0] OP [1] http://www.michigan.gov/sos/0,4670,7-127-29836-88651--F,00.html http://www.michigan.gov/sos/0,4670,7-127-29836-88651--F,00.h... [2] http://www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/elections/FAQs/GeneralRegistrationData.html http://www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/elections/FAQs/GeneralRegist...
- DannyBee 9y agoYou can get the other info trivially from other public sources.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- _jal 9y agoThere is a significant amount of data here that is not public or covered by the laws. > Clickbait. Even if no laws were broken, it may be news to those who are unaware that carveouts to PII disclosure laws have been made and their PII (along with polling data indicating preferences on lots of topics[1]) has been leaked. Also, "politicians are at the very best so indifferent to citizen-unit privacy concerns that they can't be arsed to hire competent admins" may not exactly be news, but additional data points illustrative of that fact are. [1] What can be done with that? Well, at the very least, a PI/con-artist/other party with a motivation to approach you cold would certainly love this sort of profile for anyone they're interested in. Think about it for a minute.
- sschueller 9y agoWow, not good: "State", "Juriscode", "Jurisname", "CountyFIPS", "MCD", "CNTY", "Town", "Ward", "Precinct", "Ballotbox", "PrecinctName", "NamePrefix", "FirstName", "MiddleName", "LastName", "NameSuffix", "Sex", "BirthYear", "BirthMonth", "BirthDay", "OfficialParty", "StateCalcParty", "RNCCalcParty", "StateVoterID", "JurisdictionVoterID", "LastActiveDate", "RegistrationDate", "VoterStatus", "SelfReportedDemographic", "ModeledEthnicity", "ModeledReligion", "ModeledEthnicGroup", "RegistrationAddr1", "RegistrationAddr2", "RegHouseNum", "RegHouseSfx", "RegStPrefix", "RegStName", "RegStType", "RegstPost", "RegUnitType", "RegUnitNumber", "RegCity", "RegSta", "RegZip5", "RegZip4", "RegLatitude", "RegLongitude", "RegGeocodeLevel", "ChangeOfAddress", "COADate", "COAType", "MailingAddr1", "MailingAddr2", "MailHouseNum", "MailHouseSfx", "MailStPrefix", "MailStName", "MailStType", "MailStPost", "MailUnitType", "MailUnitNumber", "MailCity", "MailSta", "MailZip5", "MailZip4", "MailSortCodeRoute", "MailDeliveryPt", "MailDeliveryPtChkDigit", "MailLineOfTravel", "MailLineOfTravelOrder", "MailDPVStatus", "MADR_LastCleanse", "MADR_LastCOA", "AreaCode", "TelephoneNUm", "TelSourceCode", "TelMatchLevel", "TelReliability", "FTC_DoNotCall"
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoThat does not even nearly fit on one line, so I broke it up. Yeah, it looks pretty bad. Here's hoping it's only sparsely filled out. State Juriscode Jurisname CountyFIPS MCD CNTY Town Ward Precinct Ballotbox PrecinctName NamePrefix FirstName MiddleName LastName NameSuffix Sex BirthYear BirthMonth BirthDay OfficialParty StateCalcParty RNCCalcParty StateVoterID JurisdictionVoterID LastActiveDate RegistrationDate VoterStatus SelfReportedDemographic ModeledEthnicity ModeledReligion ModeledEthnicGroup RegistrationAddr1 RegistrationAddr2 RegHouseNum RegHouseSfx RegStPrefix RegStName RegStType RegstPost RegUnitType RegUnitNumber RegCity RegSta RegZip5 RegZip4 RegLatitude RegLongitude RegGeocodeLevel ChangeOfAddress COADate COAType MailingAddr1 MailingAddr2 MailHouseNum MailHouseSfx MailStPrefix MailStName MailStType MailStPost MailUnitType MailUnitNumber MailCity MailSta MailZip5 MailZip4 MailSortCodeRoute MailDeliveryPt MailDeliveryPtChkDigit MailLineOfTravel MailLineOfTravelOrder MailDPVStatus MADR_LastCleanse MADR_LastCOA AreaCode TelephoneNUm TelSourceCode TelMatchLevel TelReliability FTC_DoNotCall
- 9y ago
- kjhughes 9y agoBeing discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14586920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14586920
- wyldfire 9y agoI hate to be in the position of defending a leak such as this. But if what they've done is "merely" compiling data that was available from our public profiles, are they obligated to secure that compilation? I'm asking -- I don't know for sure how the data was gathered, it just sounds like it was from scraping public records + public web sites. Also, can someone ask Troy Hunt whether he has or can get access to this data so he can let us all know if we're on it? (But will it even matter if they don't have an email address field?)
- wang_li 9y agoVoter registration information is public. It doesn't seem like any of the information "leaked" is actually private.
- mattnewton 9y agoI missed where it was all public; couldn't you share information with your political party you wouldn't want shared with others? And wouldn't the accumulation of all that data be valuable?
- ryanworl 9y agoMany states have very loose control over their voter database. The control is mostly exerted through the force of the law prohibiting certain uses of the data. For example, I can order the voter database for the state of New York and receive it on a CD in a few weeks. Other states will simply email you a link to a big bundle of CSV files. There is other information besides what is on the voter database in this disclosure, it appears, but the voter data itself is mostly not a secret and can be trivially accessed by any citizen. They just have to promise not to break the law around what they do with it.
- yahelc 9y agoVoter files being public data depends on which state you're talking about -- you're looking at ~50 different sets of laws and regulations. Some states restrict access to only political parties using it for political uses and prohibit distribution to non-parties/candidates. Some states (Florida, for example) will let anyone just apply to get it. To your latter question, some states, like California, do include email addresses on their voter file, but the coverage tends to be poor. You can probably assume that, if you're a registered voter in the United States, you're on this dataset, as is your age, gender, party affiliation if applicable, and race/ethnicity info if your state collects that, as well as modeled information projecting things like party support, race, age, and likelihood to turnout.
- HCyber 9y agoYou can see if you have been breached in other similar breaches and leaks at https://HEROIC.com https://HEROIC.com
- umanwizard 9y agoThis is spam.
- HCyber 9y agoThis is not spam, it is a public service to help those who have been compromised as Upguard is not providing the data for those that want to see if they have been breached. There are multiple sites you can check for free if you have been breached including haveibeenpwned which will inevitably be posted also.
- pyre 9y agoTotally. I entered an address I don't care about, and it just kept asking me for what is essentially a marketing profile: - Is this a personal email address? - Please enter 10 more email addresses that you use (i.e. are associated with this email address) so that we can "narrow down the search results." Really. How is whether or not this is a personal email address meaningful in searching hacked data for the email address? I'm literally providing you with text to search against a database. You don't need other information.
- simias 9y ago
- HCyber 9y agoYou can check if you have been breached in other similar breaches and leaks at https://HEROIC.com https://HEROIC.com
- ryanlol 9y agoHey, I see that you claim to have 4 billion records. Could you talk a bit about your verification process for said records? My private collection has a bit over 5B records atm (and presumably largely the same data) but I would never advertise a service with that number as I know for a fact that various databases contain millions of generated entries. The results for queries like "00000000000000000000023@inbox.ru" seem to indicate that you have large amounts of bullshit data included in that figure.
- arianvanp 9y agoSo you think it is okay to model ethnicity and religion of 200 milion citizens? This is how my country got all their jews killed in WWII [0]. The mere thought of compiling such information here would lead to some hefty jail time these days. I really cannot believe you can even defend such a thing. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_registration#Netherlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_registration#Netherlands
- protomyth 9y agoFor a US example look at NAACP v. Alabama (1958). If you are on the side of revealing this information, you are on the same side as some pretty unpleasant folks.
- Gargoyle 9y agoYou're also on the side of every political campaign in America. Collecting and/or modeling this information is standard practice in the industry.
- stdgy 9y agoLikely still covered by the aforementioned 'on the side of some pretty unpleasant folks.' ;)
- protomyth 9y agoWell, the KKK and Jim Crow supporters were a bit farther up the ladder of 'unpleasant'. 'Unpleasant' being used in the same meaning and tone as a southern lady saying "aren't you special".
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIn their day they were only mildly unpleasant. Furthermore, those groups they believed they were acting to promote policy that believed was in the best interest of the nation, regardless of how we see them in hindsight. Imagine if there existed similar databases then. Would you hire someone if you knew they were firmly pro-segregation at age 20-something in 1950-something?
- DannyBee 9y agoSpeaking as a guy with a lot of experience with voter data ( I built the first "where do I vote" apps for Google and helped found the voting information project): This is actually almost entirely public data. Yes, including addresses and phone numbers and political affiliation. There are some states that is not public as part of the voter file, but you can still get it other ways publicly. For example: USPS, etc. Some states/players would make you sign agreements not to use it for commercial purposes. The modeling info included is not public. Acquiring 50 state data can be a bit of a pain, but there are at least two major players that will sell it to you. (I remember one of them literally laughed when I told them we would want the databases without any personal info included, because we just wanted the address to various political precinct mapping.)
- unityByFreedom 9y ago> This is actually almost entirely public data Birthday is an included item. That's definitely private as it is often used to confirm identity. "almost public" is meaningless. One data item, like credit card number, or birthday, can make this a dangerous leak.
- fav_collector 9y ago> Birthday is an included item. That's definitely private as it is often used to confirm identity. mylife.com publicly posts birthdays so apparently not
- unityByFreedom 9y agoNo kidding, but I don't want that information out there, and I imagine most people don't. Just because some skeezy website shares all my personal information does not make it public information. It's private to me and I'd rather it remain undistributed, where possible. Overall point being, this US voter data leak is bad. That appears to have released information on all of us that we consider private.
- 9y ago
- pdog 9y agoThis raises so many questions... Why is U.S. voter registration made public at the individual name/address level? Why do the states publish their voter registrations in the first place? Why should private campaign operations (or anyone else) have access to this data? Shouldn't voters' privacy be protected by the states? Is there a privacy policy you can review when you register to vote?
- VonGuard 9y agoSo that the two parties who voted for this to be the case can have unfettered access to their potential voters, go to their houses, send them things, and know for sure they're only hitting up people in their party, so as not to mobilize the other side. Nothing that would harm the 2-party system ever changes in the US, and nothing ever will.
- kevindqc 9y agoBut why does it need to be public? In the US, you register with the party no? So the party you register with your information, and they can do what you said > go to their houses, send them things, and know for sure they're only hitting up people in their party, so as not to mobilize the other side.
- nostrademons 9y agoDepends on the state, but in general, no. You register as a member of the party. You register with the state. Voter registration information is used to determine who's eligible to vote, and you don't necessarily need to have a party affiliation to be able to vote (I don't, for example). My guess is that it's public to avoid unfairly preferencing the major parties, so that they give at least lip service to the idea that "anyone can run for office". The U.S. is pretty sensitive about seeming like it has a fair and open political system, even if other aspects of the system mean that in practice a third party doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell.
- kevindqc 9y ago
- gruez 9y agoAre the leaked files floating aroubd on the internet, or were they able to shut it down before anyone else got to it?
- strictnein 9y agoI've seen no evidence that anyone but the security researcher found this, but maybe that'll change.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf you're a glass half full person at least they care about the do not call list enough to give it its own column.
- treehau5 9y agoThey take the DNC list and subsequent enforcement very seriously. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/media-resources/do-not-call-registry/enforcement https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/media-resources/do-not-call-... source: work at place with large call center. Avoiding DNC fines is among one of our top priorities. secondary source: S.O. works at place with call center for a large bank. Same thing. Also anecdotally: If you file a complaint with the FTC for an unknown number that keeps calling you back without them giving you a chance to "opt out" (this is most scammer numbers), you file a ticket with the FTC, and they usually respond to the ticket within 2-3 days. (Another funny thing -- they use Zendesk.). I stopped receiving the calls since filing the report. As to why they take it so seriously? My guess is it's easy money for them. Kind of like traffic tickets for cops.
- maxerickson 9y agoPolitical calls are exempt from the DNC list: https://www.donotcall.gov/faq/faqbusiness.aspx#who https://www.donotcall.gov/faq/faqbusiness.aspx#who The parties take it seriously because they don't want to lose a vote by pissing someone off.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoAs long as the CEO of an company (RNC) that gives data to an outsourcer (Deep Root Analytics) is not going to jail to give data to an unqualified company, nothing will change. If the CEO goes to jail, things will change very rapidly (CEO will manage his CMO much tighter who will first want to see an security audit not older than 6 months). At least CEOs I have reported to as CTO were very sensitive for implemention issues in areas that could land them in jail. Same for every other hacking (e.g. Sony) or IT failure (e.g. British Airlines crashed DC).
- strictnein 9y agoWhat law did they break, exactly? These aren't medical or financial records. A careless programmer makes a bad choice and the CEO has to go to jail? Come on.
- djtriptych 9y agoCareless programmers can also mishandle health/credit card/minor information. We have laws protecting all of that data in particular. I'm not sure the expansion of data privacy laws to include all PII is so farfetched.
- 794CD01 9y agoIt's a slippery slope. Analysis of writing style, patterns of use, etc can deanonymize data to the point where basically everything becomes PII.
- Frondo 9y agoLet's slide a little more down that slope, then. Where personal data and privacy is concerned, I'd rather err on the side of caution, than the world we live in now.
- InitialLastName 9y agoDunno about anybody else, but I'd like to find a convenient canyon.
- SunnyCanuck 9y agoHas this been re-leaked onto the torrents yet?
- reallydattrue 9y agoCan you clarify, re-leaked? I've never seen this online. Can you post some names, links? Thanks Looking for research purposes.
- apeace 9y ago> Spreadsheets containing this accumulated data—last updated around the January 2017 presidential inauguration—constitute a treasure trove of political data and modeled preferences used by the Trump campaign Genuinely curious: can you really have 198 million rows in a spreadsheet?
- creepydata 9y agoIt's plural, spreadsheets. It could be thousands of separate files.
- apeace 9y agoGood catch. According to Microsoft[0], the max number of rows is 1,048,576. So I guess there must have been a couple hundred! [0] https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Excel-specifications-and-limits-1672b34d-7043-467e-8e27-269d656771c3 https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Excel-specification...
- sp332 9y agoExcel limits each "sheet" to 1,048,576 rows, but there's no limit to how many sheets you can have in a single file. https://support.office.com/en-us/article/excel-specifications-and-limits-1672b34d-7043-467e-8e27-269d656771c3?ui=en-US&rs=en-US&ad=US&fromAR=1 https://support.office.com/en-us/article/excel-specification...
- pc86 9y agoI used to work in this field (political consulting, the data around it, nothing terrible interesting on the tech front at the time though). It was most likely broken down by Congressional district.
- azinman2 9y agoIt’s provably a CSV not meant to be used by excel.
- nothis 9y agoCorrect: >Each file, formatted as a comma separated value (.csv), lists an internal, 32-character alphanumeric “RNC ID”—such as, for example, 530C2598-6EF4-4A56-9A7X-2FCA466FX2E2—used to uniquely identify every potential voter in the database.
- vinhboy 9y ago> It would ultimately take days, from June 12th to June 14th, for Vickery to download 1.1 TB of publicly accessible files Do security firms have special permission to do this? Because as a private citizen, I am pretty sure I would go to jail if I tried this.
- mrpoptart 9y agoIANAL, but I'm pretty sure if someone leaves a Top-Secret document on the ground, and you pick it up, you don't go to jail for that. The data is accessible to the public -- this isn't a hack, this is just downloading.
- creepydata 9y agoThe only people who can go to jail for mishandling classified information are people with security clearances.
- Phlarp 9y agoDidn't weev end up on the wrong side of this relatively blurry line?
- colemannugent 9y agoIANAL, but not as far as I'm aware. You could make the argument that since the information was not protected in any way that you were allowed to download it, but try explaining that to a 65 year old judge who doesn't even comprehend the basic structure of the internet.
- PeterisP 9y agoThey don't have a special permission, but each case is treated individually - what exactly technically you did matters just a little, the intent (not claimed intent, but the intent that the judge/jury would imply), circumstances and what you do afterwards with the data matter much more. I.e., if a respected company downloads the data, reviews what horrible things it has and reports it to proper authorities (and gets legal advice before that on how best do it), then they're very likely to be treated as not done anything bad; If I'd do the same, contact them asking to fix the vulnerability "or else", and then download the data and publish an angry video rant on youtube, that might land me in trouble, as (expected) intent matters a lot for prosecuting crimes.
- ploggingdev 9y agoI have this theory that the only way regular people will start caring about privacy breaches such as this one is to use that data against them in a malicious way. Tell the average Joe that the data of all US voters has been leaked, "Hmmm. That's bad." and they move on with their lives as if nothing happened. Instead, if this data is used to impersonate the average Joe on social media or if it's used to trick their mobile carrier into porting out their number, then they'll take notice. (I am not suggesting people do this, it was just part of a thought experiment) Unless the company involved is sued to bankruptcy and the people involved are prosecuted, sending a strong message to companies dealing with user data, nothing will change. But that's unlikely to happen as this company is backed by the RNC. While we're on the topic of collecting personal data of people, there's a simple solution : just don't collect it unless it's absolutely necessary. Stop asking me to broadcast my address in my newsletter. Stop asking me to submit my billing address when I make payments online. Stop asking me for my mobile number when I visit a fast food restaurant. Most of the companies that collect this data are not competent enough to keep it secure. The reason companies ask for an address to broadcast in users' newsletters is some anti-spam act which does not prevent the spammers from doing their job. I imagine it's also a requirement for companies to collect a billing address for certain types of online payments. Change the law to remove these poorly thought out legislature. More generally, we need regulations on how user data is used by companies. They should not be allowed to store user data indefinitely. If a user closes an account with a company, retain the data for a short period (eg- 1 year) and then delete the data automatically. Companies should not be allowed to build shadow profiles of users.
- ksk 9y ago>I have this theory that the only way regular people will start caring about privacy breaches such as this one is to use that data against them in a malicious way The other thought experiment is to adopt the opposite point of view that privacy is overrated. You can adopt various worldviews from 'everything is grey' to 'this is good, that is bad" but punishing someone to care about same things you care about is a pretty terrible approach. If you can't convince someone, it doesn't mean they're stupid, it could also mean you just aren't that good at communicating, or that perhaps what you think is important isn't all that important. >Unless the company involved is sued to bankruptcy and the people involved are prosecuted, sending a strong message to companies dealing with user data, nothing will change. Or we can give them tools that make it easier to secure data. I've always found that if you make it easy for someone, they almost always end up doing the right thing. As it stands the security products/services domain is a complicated maze where you have to be an expert to evaluate how various products work internally and which services, if any are worth purchasing.
- mgleason_3 9y agoIs StateVoterID the same thing as your Social Security Number (SSN)?
- ericcumbee 9y agoNot in Georgia, and I seriously doubt anywhere else either.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rwc 9y agoNo, it is not.
- nothis 9y agoDoesn't this kinda make many (flawed but still in use) "security measures" incredibly vulnerable to social engineering? That's all the birth dates and phone numbers. That's crazy!
- azinman2 9y agoIs this available online in a searchable way? I want to see what it has on me...
- Lagged2Death 9y ago“‘Microtargeting is trying to unravel your political DNA,’ [Gage] said. ‘The more information I have about you, the better.’ The more information [Gage] has, the better he can group people into "target clusters" with names such as ‘Flag and Family Republicans’ or ‘Tax and Terrorism Moderates.’ Once a person is defined, finding the right message from the campaign becomes fairly simple.” Neal Stephenson wrote a book called Interface which predicted a form of tech-enabled micro-targeted politics over 20 years ago. It was disturbing at the time; it's almost considered business-as-usual now. I believe American democracy would benefit from including the study of such techniques in our educational curriculum. When I was in school, we studied advertising techniques to help us be skeptical. We need the same for targeted political messages now.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI agree, but citizen education should not imho be the only approach here. I'm for much more muscular privacy laws and a slightly narrower tolerance on what's acceptable political speech. Of course education is great, but look at the vast financial and operational asymmetries between even the most informed individual and well-resourced corporate actors like political parties. I have a super-strong political immune system but being politically engaged and navigating social media is exhausting. For the sake of objectivity I have to systematically expose myself to opinions I find disagreeable lest I retreat into a bubble and be surrounded by confirmation bias, but continuous exposure to countervailing political ideologies is intellectually and morally tiring, given the intense polarization and visceral rhetoric that prevails in today's political discourse. Despite not liking programming, I've been seriously thinking about building a virtual assistant that I can train to pre-emptively tag people using my peculiar ideological criteria so that I can avoid or at least prepare for certain interactions that I know are going to be psychically difficult. By my value calculus, tuning out of politics is irresponsible at best and suicidal at worst; only communicating with people whose values you share exposes you to confirmation bias, and and inevitably exposes one to manipulation; observation of and argumentation with antagonists is psychically expensive and potentially dangerous. so much as I agree with you on education, it's not something we can just put on the to-do list and wait a generation to benefit from. And that would be true even if we had a well-functioning educational sector rather than one that fails a large number of children and adults by leaving them only semi-literate and -numerate. People who can't read or reckon well are poorly positioned to identify fallacious political discourse.
- rattray 9y agoI don't typically don hats with this much tin foil, and I don't think this is likely, but... The real danger of data like this, in my opinion, illegal usage for voter fraud. Find people who are likely to vote against you and likely to have poor voter registration documents, and remove them from the polls so they can't vote. Find people who aren't likely to vote at all and vote on their behalf. In-person, the only verification required is name & address. By mail, the only requirement is a signature, which can be obtained from receipts (I assume this is available on black hat markets). Leaving this S3 bucket as public-read allows for deniable coordination with illegal actors. I can't imagine they did this on purpose but that could be an explanation. I don't know if it's possible, but I hope the FBI / Mueller team is able to get access logs.
- rwc 9y agoNo. The data that would be useful for wide-scale voter fraud is already widely available from public/free sources, including state Secretaries of State or Departments of Elections. The loss here is all the very expensive extra modeling and demographic work that isn't included on those files. But having that doesn't massively alter the mechanics of the voter fraud effort you're describing.
- rattray 9y agoThe expensive modeling (and data collection) makes it much cheaper and more feasible. I agree that it doesn't change the fundamental mechanics, or enable otherwise impossible attacks.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThe real danger of data like this is concentration camps and death squads. I don't like stating things so dramatically but that's the sort of thing that actually happens, not just in WW2 but also under the USSR, in many dictatorships in the developing world, when countries like the former Yugoslavia experience political collapse, and so on. Just a couple of months ago there was a systematic effort in the Russian federation of Chechnya to round up and incarcerate homosexuals. Don't make the mistake of thinking that atrocities couldn't possibly happen here just because you're used to thinking of them as something that only happens in other places.
- DelaneyM 9y agoSounds like one heck of an AI training set. DeepTrump?
- mlindner 9y agoExcept this isn't a leak. This is publicly searchable information. I don't know why people are blowing this out of proportion.
- lr4444lr 9y agoBecause technologists don't know everything about laws and society, even though they like to think they do. You might add that not only is it searchable, but the Freedom of Information Act and its derivative implementations in state laws mandate that it be made accessible in this way for no cost other than the expense in compiling the records. People getting angry when "government transparency" is supposedly such a good thing no one questions? Go figure...
- bjoernw 9y agoBecause they feel it's wrong, legality aside.
- jurry289 9y agoRelated: This legally mandated "leak" happened years ago, and it even included signatures. Most of the citizens pushing for the recall of a sitting republican governor were democrats, so it seemed like punishment for a Republican state assembly to pass this one-off policy. Especially for those who have zero internet-presence. The first thing many employers see when they search for politically active democrats is this information, paired with "quick searches" of their names on criminal, pedophile and dangerous persons databases. If you want to disinsentivize political action, this is how you do it. I won't link to that site, but can confirm it's still up. http://www.cnn.com/2012/02/01/politics/wisconsin-recall-petition/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2012/02/01/politics/wisconsin-recall-peti...
- LinuxBender 9y agoIf I jokingly suggested to the gov that AWS S3 be categorized by all firewall vendors as "Anonymous File Sharing", would I get a yuge response?
- Taniwha 9y agoI think people are missing the big legal liability .... this information has been published to the world, it contains estimates of people's deeply held political beliefs - some of it will be wildly wrong and those people might consider that they have been libeled .... roll on the lawsuits
- political_tech 9y agoThe liability wouldn't be with the RNC or Deep Root; the liability would be on the entity that actually published the information. That's if you consider this to meet the legal definition of publishing (the legal definition of libel, as I understand it, is "to publish in print (including pictures), writing or broadcast through radio, television or film...").
- dragonwriter 9y agoLibel, in the US, requires the publisher to either known the claim is false ormto publish it with reckless disregard for the truth when it is, in fact, false; I don't think that there is anyway that this could be construed to meet that, no matter what legal theory as to who the liable publisher is you use.
- MR4D 9y agoI'm just waiting to hear Trump tell Deep Root Analytics, "You're Fired!" It would be good to see him make this a clear case of responsibility. Also, someone on the RNC side needs to get fired, too. I'm not sure who, but errors this big demand it.
- political_tech 9y agoTrump only has "signaling authority" over the entities with whom the RNC contracts; he can't actually force a contract termination, but he can express distrust in an entity and encourage the RNC to terminate a contract. I don't see that happening, for a myriad of reasons. The people involved with the decision to start working with Deep Root are mostly not with the RNC anymore. Even if they were, that's simply not how the industry works.
- fulldecent 9y agoTLDR. Was any of the information non-public?
- political_tech 9y agoThe results of data science models are contained in the data dump, and those are non-public. The rest of the information is accessible via public records or registries maintained by states.
- elihu 9y agoWhat are the legal implications of a campaign using this leaked modelling data? Would it be breaking any existing laws to use data that was leaked to the public without the permission of the original company that did the modelling? (If nothing else, I suppose it's probably a copyright violation.) Hypothetically, could one deliberately leak a trove of modelling data with some fake voters inserted, and then monitor the mailbox associated with that fake voter and sue any organization you don't like that sends campaign flyers for using the data without permission?
- 80211 9y agoThe reddit posts are odd. What value do they have? And why/how did they leak? Fortunately, they don't hold much personal data, but given that they're looking to raise $$$, the fact that they had a security breach is interesting. Especially if they haven't disclosed it.
- opensourcenews 9y agoI still don't understand the concern. Want the name, age, gender, home address, mailing address, party of registration, and voter history from every registered voter in North Carolina? Here is the "leak" on Amazon S3. http://dl.ncsbe.gov/index.html?prefix=data/ http://dl.ncsbe.gov/index.html?prefix=data/ Except, by leak, I mean, link I got from my state board of elections' homepage.
- goffchris 9y agoIs there any way to access the Deep Root data to see what it says about me? Has anybody posted it online in a searchable format?