11 ms·
We all deserved to be treated with that kind of dignity. I'm not sure where our industry went wrong. You'd never ask a doctor medical school trivia during an i
by mrfusion 9y ago
We all deserved to be treated with that kind of dignity.
I'm not sure where our industry went wrong. You'd never ask a doctor medical school trivia during an interview.
- dagw 9y agoI don't know. If I was to get a new co-worker tomorrow I would hope that someone had checked that he had relevant skills beyond knowing that 'python' was a programming language and knowing how to sound overconfident in interviews. And in the case of the doctor he'll have to have a verifiable degree from a verifiable university as well a verifiable several year long 'internship' from a reputable 'company' before you would even consider interviewing him.
- WorldMaker 9y agoThe software industry has a lot of equivalents: we just mostly ignore them. You can have a verifiable degree from a verifiable university with several years of experience in reputable companies and still have to sit down and answer trivia questions and try to program a basic algorithm on whiteboard, none of which you'd need in the day-to-day job. I think "dignity" is a spot on word for it: professionals like doctors and civil engineers are generally assumed to have the qualifying skills that their resume says they have; software developers are assumed to have no skills unless proven otherwise and your resume barely gets your foot in the door.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoDoctors take a test and go through a verifiable apprenticeship period. If Dr. Nidal got his MD from Johns Hopkins and did his residency in pediatric oncology at Sloan Kettering where he is a fellow and has published 2 papers on Nueroblastoma you can safely assume he knows a thing or two about high risk pediatric solid tumor cancers. What do we have for programmers?
- rootsudo 9y agoGithub, and the number of stars on their repo.
- collyw 9y agoMost programmers work will be in house.
- xenihn 9y agoHN comment history
- oega98 9y agoI have a shipping product I worked on for 12 years and that is used all over the industry. I have a public mailing list you can search where I answered questions from developers about the product during that entire time. I have a profile on some well-known programming web sites (like Stack Overflow, etc.). I have a degree from a well-known university and actually have at least 1 paper listed on Google Scholar. I still have had to do stupid whiteboard programming exercises of 1st year data structure and algorithm nonsense.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoYes I'd say you deserve more respect than someone with an unknown background, which is to say most candidates.
- ryandrake 9y agoFurther, when I hire someone to fix my roof, I don't make him build me a doghouse first to scrutinize whether he's any good. On the other hand, if you don't ask at least some basic questions, you risk hiring the Brillant Paula Bean [1]. 1: http://thedailywtf.com/articles/The_Brillant_Paula_Bean http://thedailywtf.com/articles/The_Brillant_Paula_Bean
- dagw 9y agoI kind of wish I'd gotten the people I hired to build our terrace to first build something small, like a doghouse, before hiring them.
- cr0sh 9y agoThis is why you ask any contractors for references you can check. Good contractors will provide them willingly. Another way to get a good contractor (in the first place) is to ask around via a somewhat orthogonal method. For instance, we needed to get a new block fence installed around our house. This wasn't going to be cheap, and we wanted it done right. My wife interviewed several contractors, and half of them were drunk, and the other half couldn't figure out which end of a tape measure to use. So we got creative: "Who should we call that might know who is a good contractor for block fence construction, and who isn't?" Well - that's the kind of thing you have to go "inside" the industry; so we figured, well let's call some suppliers of concrete block. A few calls around to these places, asking the people "who would you hire to build a fence" produced a list of candidates from each vendor - and where there were matches, that boosted them on the list. Narrowed it down to three, had them come out and bid, then we went with the guy who struck our fancy best (not with the cheapest - never go with the cheapest, unless they seem the most competent). We've used this kind of system since (along with checking references and such), and haven't had a problem finding a capable contractor for construction and maintenance work.
- ryandrake 9y agoWow, must be nice to be able to pick and choose. Where I am, if you want someone to do roof repair, appliance repair, HVAC work, etc. you basically go with whoever actually manages to pick up their phone. Everyone seems to have so much business that you often go straight to voicemail, and sometimes the voicemail box is full so you can't even leave a message. When you do get a callback, they're all booked months in advance. Man, why didn't I went into a trade?
- AndyMcConachie 9y agoIn this hospital we use scalpels. Are you familiar with scalpels? How would you rate your experience in scalpels?
- ryandrake 9y agoI'd like to hire you as my lawyer to review my contracts. Lawyers need good reading skills. Can you please read this fax to me and tell me what it's about? I'm looking for someone to cut my hair. Can you tell me how many hairs are in a typical human head? Can you show me how you hold a scissors? I'm only looking for people with the best scissors skills. Oh, you're here to fix my microwave? Great. Before we start though, can you show me the contents of your toolbox? I want to make sure you are familiar with all the latest brands of screwdrivers and wrenches. Come over to this whiteboard and draw a typical microwave, labeling the major parts.
- metaphorm 9y agoon the other hand doctors are credentialed and software developers aren't. you don't get invited to interview for a position as a doctor unless you have your medical school degree, and all of the associated training that goes with that (residencies, etc.). there is nothing equivalent to that for software development, and in fact a computer science degree is sufficiently abstract/mathy that it's possibly to graduate with one and still not really know how to do practical software development.
- WorldMaker 9y agoThere are things that are equivalent. The issue isn't that there aren't credentials that could be trusted for software developers, so much as no one interviewing for software developers cares. My degree was an ABET accredited engineering degree that required practical software development skills (including soft skills). Outside of interviewing in my hometown, no one knows that or cares. The software industry tomorrow could easily adopt the internships and test/certification requirements of a profession like medicine or engineering. The industry doesn't seem inclined to do so, however, for a weird variety of reasons and excuses, and seems for the most part overly satisfied with trivia questions and whiteboard problems.
- metaphorm 9y ago> seems for the most part overly satisfied with trivia questions and whiteboard problems. I agree and it is puzzling to me as well. My own CompSci degree as ABET accredited and I did two years worth of internships before working full time. It doesn't translate into a strong credential though. I still get asked to do whiteboard shit, just like everyone else. I think it's a complicated issue and is in some sense due to the immaturity of the industry (only a couple of decades old, whereas some other professional disciplines are centuries old). In any case I'm glad it's a topic of frequent discussion in the community. It's important and the discussions are usually good ones.
- PeterisP 9y agoI believe that it started during the dotcom boom, when a lot of unqualified people tried to join the industry despite having no skills - once you get bit by hiring people who claim (and have) job experience but turns out can't code at all, not even on a basic junior level; you need some process to filter them out.
- oega98 9y agoNo, it started way before that. I interviewed with Microsoft in 1993 and had to answer questions like "Why are manhole covers round," and "Reverse this linked list." This has been going on for decades.
- beobab 9y agoMy favourite answer to that is: because the hole they are covering is round.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoI'd say it mattered less then. This was all new. Nobody knew what they were doing so it was easy for imposters to come in and fake it till they made it. Things are more transparent and aggressive now. The industry I entered in the late 90's is very different than it is today. It grew up.
- aidenn0 9y agoI think it's at least partly because how averse many shops are to hiring people; even people who clearly lied on their interview/resume. At one point in the past I worked with someone who was incapable of understanding pass-by-reference; something like: int getFoo(foo *out); A colleague spent multiple hours per day for a week trying to explain this to them. After a week they still were unable to successfully make use of this interface. Their resume claimed 5 years experience in C.
- poikniok 9y agoIsn't this passing by pointer and not passing by reference?
- cema 9y agoI guess technically in C everything is passed by value but you can pass a pointer to something and call it, naturally, a pass-by-pointer. Since in C you can typically get the pointer value by providing the reference (I don't remember if it is called the reference in pure C, but we are clearly talking about the same thing here) it can also be called a pass-by-reference, consistent with some other programming languages.
- aidenn0 9y agoPointers are a specific type reference. As they are the only type of reference built-in to the language, it is common to use the more general term "pass by reference" to mean "pass by pointer" when discussing C.