2 ms·
> Is this because the data being passed around is represented in binary form rather than text form None of my complaints relate to binary vs. text. Both have t
by falcolas 9y ago
> Is this because the data being passed around is represented in binary form rather than text form
None of my complaints relate to binary vs. text. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, and while binary data requires new set of tooling, I intentionally did not mention it because of how contentious it is to even bring up.
> Sure, but this doesn't strike me as neccessarily bad.
It's just not necessary. This all worked before. Not always perfectly, and sometimes even poorly... but it worked. And importantly, it worked without requiring the authentication system, message bus (tied into the kernel), custom logging, and init all to be tied together.
> What advantages do you gain from having a unified layer that provides the services that systemd provides?
Personally? None - no advantages. Consider where I'm coming from - I've run Linux on the desktop and server for years (perhaps even before systemd was a glimmer in Pottering's eye). I've written software which ran on startup (including the sysvinit scripts), done init troubleshooting... and it all just worked.
Without reasonable gains in speed, and without resolving the determinism problem, and given a world in which supervisord, daemontools, and LXC exist... systemd just doesn't bring anything to the table that I've been asking for. Instead, it's brought a whole new toolset I have to now learn, and a ton more complexity and opacity.