8 ms·
They say they are fighting "violent extremism online" but how can you be violent online? That's a physical thing. Instead, they outline four points for greater
by hammock 9y ago
They say they are fighting "violent extremism online" but how can you be violent online? That's a physical thing. Instead, they outline four points for greater censorship of videos.
- mythrwy 9y agoWhich is Google's right to do. Let ISIS or White Nazi rebirth club set their own video hosting services up instead of piggybacking on something they are ultimately trying to destroy.
- krapp 9y agoOk, fair enough. It's Google's sandbox, they can do what they like. So let's say ISIS and the Neo-Nazis get their own video hosting services, since there probably aren't enough of either to make that infeasible, and they already have plenty of venues for hosting their own material. Then what? What problem does removing that content from Google actually solve? The internet detects censorship as damage and routes around it, remember - stopping the propagation of anything people want to publish is impossible by design.
- mythrwy 9y agoI'm surprised that would be asked. Google removing or otherwise taking steps to suppress this content very obviously (partially) solves the "most important" problem. And that "most important" problem is Google being accessory or providing platform which is a legal and public relations liability. Notice who the author of the article is. Not some engineer. Not a public relations person. Nope. It's Kent Walker, General Council. And that tells you a lot about the "why".
- hacker_9 9y agoIt is the video content that is violent of course..
- ben_w 9y agoCensorship is a firewall for your brain: crude, obvious, flawed, often in the way, yet still better than nothing. Which is rather a pitty, given this metaphor makes most of our cultural baggage into unwanted and unremovable bloatware that has its own set of problems.
- codedokode 9y agoYou cannot be violent online but you can spread lie and propaganda and some people could believe it. Governments have a long history of doing it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]