4 ms·
> All of which were announced as opportunities, all of which were simply shakedowns Shakedowns by the consulting firms? Can you expand bc isn't it the CEO or o
by hammock 9y ago
> All of which were announced as opportunities, all of which were simply shakedowns
Shakedowns by the consulting firms? Can you expand bc isn't it the CEO or other exec who hire these guys in the first place
- michaelt 9y agoAt least in the UK, publicly traded companies must have their accounts independently audited. But they're also allowed to hire those independent auditors to provide consulting services. This presents a pretty big conflict of interests - a company making £££ in consulting fees isn't going to want to sour the business relationship by being a hardass during the audit. Essentially every time there's a major fraud or accounting scandal, it'll turn out the auditors were also retained as consultants.
- hammock 9y agoSo the consulting firms are the ones being shaken down? Or what? I don't see how that's a "shakedown" for the company as if they are in compliance there's no need for them to pay for the "consulting shakedown" for better treatment. Unless you are talking at a systemic level where, in order to compete, companies HAVE to operate out-of-compliance and use these consulting arrangements in order to prevent being exposed.
- elefanten 9y agoI think op just meant that they do bad work for exorbitant prices. And gp showed some of the pressures that can drive firms to buy optional services from consulting firms: desire to maintain a "good relationship" or possibly just discounting and bundling. Also, the big consulting firms are generally known for aggressive upselling. It's often a core part of their business model. Once you've got em on the hook... So, TLDR: Not shakedown as in extortion, shakedown as in bad service for a bad price.
- sgt101 9y agoYes - this.
- jessaustin 9y agoIs being "in compliance" a guarantee of a clean audit? If so, is the suggestion that apparently corrupt audit firms are only corrupt in one direction? That seems unlikely.
- chongli 9y agoSo why is this allowed? Why hasn't there been a law passed barring this sort of incestuous relationship?
- gautamdivgi 9y agoThis used to happen in the US as well. Remember Arthur Andersen? They provided auditing as well as consultancy - and the scandals (not sure if it was Enron) broke them. Memory fails me at the moment to recollect if a law was passed to keep those functions separate.
- khuey 9y agoSarbanes Oxley (the post-Enron law) put a lot of restrictions on what non-auditing services an auditor can provide a client.
- analog31 9y agoAsk HN: Isn't this what Arthur Andersen was doing?
- sgt101 9y agoYup, these exercises come about because of pressure from internal politics (as a way to settle a battle between execs) or investor pressure. The consultants are selling machines, the long term outcome of their advice is not relevant. They seek to create evidence of interest and adoption of the latest trend. A great example would be organizational health vs rigorous performance management cultures. The outcomes of both are contestable and contested, they are polar opposites in terms of philosophy and culture, and yet both are touted and sold by the same people. For the consultant what matters is the booking now, the political reception preparing the way for next time in this company, and the reference and referral opportunities to generate more business. The value of what they sell and the impact of it on business success just doesn't matter - they're out here!