4 ms·
Breakage is a big part of cost of ownership, especially for very expensive tools. IMHO in the context of maker spaces, it's wrong to structure it so that peopl
by PeterisP 9y ago
Breakage is a big part of cost of ownership, especially for very expensive tools.
IMHO in the context of maker spaces, it's wrong to structure it so that people could unexpectedly be on the hook for large amounts of money if they happen to be the ones who break a machine, it would work much better if such expenses would be like insurance, made small, distributed and predictable, priced in the usage or membership.
- inetknght 9y agoThat, on the other hand, can encourage people to be careless in what they do. It's not their own equipment, they don't pay for it, so why worry about whether it will break? Someone else will have to fix it.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoMaker/hacker spaces are communities, not companies - a well-run space will try to identify and filter out people with such a mindset. Not that these problems don't happen - but the whole benefit of such spaces is that they remove inefficiency in sharing stuff by assuming (and hopefully ensuring) that people will play nice.
- sooheon 9y agoCan you truly not imagine any policies or cultural/social engineering efforts to mitigate this? Humans are social animals, money is not the only thing that drives behavior, a culture of respect and social accountability goes a long way.
- skookumchuck 9y agoSure I can. It's called communism, where nobody owns everything and everybody shares. We all know how well that works.
- bromuro 9y agowe should give another chance to communism then, as those are wonderful ideas. we should learn from the past instead.
- skookumchuck 9y agoCommunism has had no lack of second chances.
- Jarwain 9y agoSome would say Communism lacks even a real first chance.
- skookumchuck 9y agoThere's no law against forming a commune in the US. Lots of groups have. Feel free to found your own. The problem with communes in the US, however, is you cannot make anyone join or stay. Accomplishing that requires a government, and has been tried lots of times, most recently in Venezuela. Given the historical results of government imposed communism, I'll pass on giving it another chance.
- ReverseCold 9y agoCommunism doesn't work, for one major reason... If everything is shared, who ensures how everything is shared? A: The government. What does any entity do when given absolute power? Hmm..... How to get totalitarian regimes 101
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 9y agoCommunism works reasonably well for commune sized societies where everyone knows each other well and have joined because of common interests. The issue with communism is that it (or, more accurately, the behavior/attitude needed for it) doesn't work at scale for larger societies that include strangers, but for smaller communes, including the people that would form a local maker space, those principles can work reasonably well.
- ams6110 9y agoOne option might be you don't pay for it, but you are banned from using it, or banned from the whole space for some period of time. Shunned, in other words.
- gwright 9y agoDeductibles. Set them per/person and increase them per incident.
- chongli 9y agoIt doesn't have to be all or nothing. Purchase insurance with a small but not insignificant deductible. Everybody who participates then puts down a deposit to cover the deductible. This way insurance is cheaper, if somebody breaks something it won't cost them too much money, but there's still a disincentive to break things so people will be careful.