3 ms·
> There are a whole host of alternative Ruby language implementations out there, but I only see MRI and sometimes JRuby in the wild. Well I think those are the
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> There are a whole host of alternative Ruby language implementations out there, but I only see MRI and sometimes JRuby in the wild.
Well I think those are the only ones actively maintained, aren't they? As a language community we're pretty lucky to have even two production-ready implementations.
Rubinius seems to lost all their contributors and to have deleted their JIT and ground to a halt. Topaz was just an experiment. I don't think Maglev or IronRuby have been maintained for a few years. Opal is still going but it's not quite what you mean when you talk about Ruby implementations.
> Why don't we see more adoption of alternative runtimes?
Because it's a huge volume of work that needs very specialised skills that few people have, so they often aren't maintained very long. Starting one is fun, finishing and maintaining is more of a slog.
- twelvechairs 9y agoJRuby spent years to get to the point where they could run Rails. If you cant do that in ruby you are not capturing the biggest use case of the language. Im not sure any of the alternatives got there Theres a good list of problems making a proper ruby implementation here http://blog.headius.com/2012/10/so-you-want-to-optimize-ruby.html?m=1 http://blog.headius.com/2012/10/so-you-want-to-optimize-ruby... And a list of what remains different in jruby here (mostly c extensions and threads) https://github.com/jruby/jruby/wiki/DifferencesBetweenMriAndJruby https://github.com/jruby/jruby/wiki/DifferencesBetweenMriAnd...
- koolba 9y agoAnd on the flip side once you get to that point the critical mass is with you. I know plenty of enterprises that run JRuby because technically it's "just Java". Being able to run Rails apps on the sly is huge. Nobody is going to use a new Ruby or Python unless it brings something new to the table. Pypy has it with speed. JRuby has Java compability. Without an X factor it's hard to get people excited to try it, let alone contribute.