2 ms·
> I'm not claiming ownership on my ideas. I'm claiming the right to prevent copying of my software and writing! How are you going to do that, though? It just s
by _delirium 16y ago
> I'm not claiming ownership on my ideas. I'm claiming the right to prevent copying of my software and writing!
How are you going to do that, though? It just so happens that the natural world does not provide you with an obvious way to do that. If you physically occupy a house, someone has to violently eject you to take it. But if you voluntarily put your software out into the public sphere, someone can copy it entirely in the privacy of their own home, using 100% materials they own! Now it's you who'd have to engage in the violence to stop them: you, or a state acting on your behalf, would have to intrude into their private house, and tell them they can't use the materials they physically own in the way they're doing. That, to me, seems a much worse intrusion on actual property rights than any "intellectual property" defense could justify.
- nailer 16y ago> How are you going to do that, though? This bill is a good start. > That, to me, seems a much worse intrusion on actual property rights than any "intellectual property" defense could justify. We already raid houses in relation to fraud, embezzlement, and other crimes based around intellectual values. Would I support raiding a house for piracy? I don't think anyone's proposing raiding houses for casual downloaders. If they were an organized piracy network ALA TPB, who have inflicted massive amounts of damage on authors, artists, game makers, and app developers, big and small, then as a writer, a software maker, and an ethical human being I'd certainly support that.