4 ms·
The article is good but the title is false. Eyewitness testimony is, as a rule, always filtered through layers of perception contaminated by various unchecked
by teddyh 9y ago
The article is good but the title is false. Eyewitness testimony is, as a rule, always filtered through layers of perception contaminated by various unchecked influences, which is largely the point of the article. The fact that properly isolated witness testimony is surprisingly reliable has no practical benefit for anyone, since, in practice, no witness testimonies are properly isolated.
- MarkMc 9y ago> no witness testimonies are properly isolated. Can't we make them properly isolated? The article says you need 3 things for reliable witness testimony: 1. Do not repeat the lineup, 2. Ensure the suspect doesn't stand out, 3. Record the confidence of the witness when identifying the suspect. If law enforcement follow these 3 rules and the witness identifies the suspect with a high degree of confidence, it seems the identification is very reliable. That would be a practical benefit.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe witness is also susceptible to suggestion. If they are reached over the telephone, or have a conversation with a family member, or the police accidentally (or intentionally) suggest something in an interview, then they are tainted. If the defendant is resourceful, then the chance of any of these happening blows up.
- abecedarius 9y agoIn the last decade or two blinded lineups -- where the police officer with the witness doesn't know who is the suspect -- became the standard in a fair number of U.S. states. You can take this pessimistically: wtf, it took this long to introduce some basic epistemic hygiene? But it also shows progress does happen. "No practical benefit for anyone" is just giving up.