3 ms·
Self-driving cars' marketing pitch is that they could reduce road accidents, but if we really want to reduce road accidents, might we not have a better chance a
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Self-driving cars' marketing pitch is that they could reduce road accidents,
but if we really want to reduce road accidents, might we not have a better
chance at it if we removed cars from roads altogether? We could replace them
with, I don't know, some kind of overground system of personal pods on rails,
or something like that.
I think one big selling point of cars has always been that they grant the user
a great amount of autonomy (unprecedented, in their time, taken for granted
nowadays). You can ride your car and go anywhere you like! The cost of that
autonomy of course is that some of us will be killed or maimed in road
accidents, because you can't give silly little monkeys autonomy behind the
controls of big powerful machines without death and carnage ensuing.
Self-driving cars propose to reduce this risk of death and injury by taking
away the autonomy we traded it for in the first place. What remains would be
just a mindless automatic system carting the user to and fro. Well, in that
case- we don't need to wait around for full level-5 autonomy. We already have
dumb machines that can do that: trains, trams, all sorts of vehicles-on-rails.
Why do we need self-driving cars, then?
Answer: we don't. And I haven't for a moment believed that any of this is
anything to do with road safety. Note that nobody even discusses the other 900
pound gorilla in the room: pollution.
Guess what? Taking cars off roads completely would also reduce air and noise
pollution tremendously.
- IanCal 9y ago> Self-driving cars propose to reduce this risk of death and injury by taking away the autonomy we traded it for in the first place. A car that can drive itself does not remove the autonomy having a car gives you. The key part of the autonomy is going where you want, when you want. Not that you get to push the pedals and turn the wheel. > We already have dumb machines that can do that: trains, trams, all sorts of vehicles-on-rails. Which travel only from and to certain places, at certain times. It's why what would be a three hour drive is likely to take me closer to five hours tomorrow, for example. For another example: the train station near my friends house stops running trains at 7pm, the roads are open all night. > We could replace them with, I don't know, some kind of overground system of personal pods on rails, or something like that. Building an entirely new, country wide, overhead rail system that goes to or extremely close to every house? That sounds incredibly expensive. > Why do we need self-driving cars, then? They're an incremental improvement which requires no new major infrastructure.
- gkya 9y agoMy observation is that generally Americans can't imagine a carless life as they have very bad public transport networks, according to what I see 8n movies etc. and read here on the HN. Whenever I made a similar comment it backfired. Improving the network is never an option for them and the reason is usually sth. like "I can't stand the people in the busses". And thus they look into complex options like this. I live in Istanbul and while the amount of construction work and all the economy and rant around is ugly, the metro especially is a joy most of the time. No way I'm getting a car as they are so costly and such a liability. Different life styles, different mindsets, I guess.