3 ms·

And a fear to introduce accountability for reviews: what if the review is technically wrong? With the anonymous system we have today, there are no wrong review

by sddfd 9y ago

And a fear to introduce accountability for reviews: what if the review is technically wrong? With the anonymous system we have today, there are no wrong reviews.

pfortuny 9y ago
Ouch, you would be amazed at the trickery involved in refereeing. Drop a couple of citations and you end up with a 90% probability of getting your desired reviewer... And many more.
- sddfd 9y ago
  Ok my statement wasn't completely clear: in the current system there are by definition no wrong reviews
  - pfortuny 9y ago
    OK: I thought you night mean this, and that is right, and a problem, a big one.