3 ms·
The other side: http://www.newsweek.com/wikileaks-attorneys-blast-citizenfour-maker-poitras-610362 http://www.newsweek.com/wikileaks-attorneys-blast-citizenfou.
by nailer 9y ago
The other side: http://www.newsweek.com/wikileaks-attorneys-blast-citizenfour-maker-poitras-610362 http://www.newsweek.com/wikileaks-attorneys-blast-citizenfou...
"To be clear: our objections are not about censorship. WikiLeaks remains an unwavering advocate for freedom of expression. This is about safety. It is about protecting journalistic sources. It is about personal and professional integrity, and honoring contractual obligations.
Our second major concern about Risk is the way the focus of the film has been radically altered from a broadly sympathetic portrayal of WikiLeaks’ work and the attacks against its staff by the U.S. government to an ill-defined indictment of the "culture of sexism" online."
- mirimir 9y agoThis is an interesting argument: > Poitras has also violated her unambiguous promise to the subjects of the film that they would have an opportunity to review the film in advance and request changes, and that they could decline to appear if they or their lawyers felt that the movie put them at risk. So I'm wondering whether Assange declined to appear, and she refused. That'd be funny, in a sad way. Still, I've followed Assange's work for decades. Maybe he's been a sexist asshole at times. The flesh is weak, no doubt. But I don't get how that can be a criticism of Wikileaks. Edit: In the parent article, Poitras says: > There were individuals who requested from the beginning not to appear in the film, and those requests were respected. I wonder what the contract actually says about the right of subjects to decline to appear.
- loup-vaillant 9y ago> Maybe he's been a sexist asshole at times. The flesh is weak, no doubt. But I don't get how that can be a criticism of Wikileaks. That's the halo effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect Any quality, good or bad, will affect the perception of other qualities. If people come to believe Assange is a sexist asshole, they will trust Wikileaks less, even if the two have little to do with each other. Another example would be Hans Reiser. Does killing one's wife makes one a worse programmer? Probably not. Still, I bet many people would be reluctant to trust him on file systems stuff, because, well, he killed his wife!
- scoggs 9y agoFor some reason my mind immediately went to the fact that Wikileaks has to honor protecting its sources. I know it should be real obvious that the task of protecting sources itself is most paramount in their operation, but for some reason I get the feeling that "full disclosure" includes "how do you get the info / who do you get the info from / tell us juicy secrets / tell us the truth about your legal cases". I don't know why, it's not that I do or don't fully trust Wikileaks, I think they can do both good and bad for the world -- not very different from any government, but I don't expect Wikileaks to get a fair shake from many people. Everyone is looking to get the best information these days to get ahead. Information and data is the name of the game so the possibilities are really endless when it comes to the lengths people would go to get that information.
- mirimir 9y agoSure. But prudent leakers handle that themselves. So there really isn't anything to protect. Leaking is different from journalism. In journalism, identities of sources matter. In leaking, only the leaks matter. And, by the way, I don't believe that Snowden needed to dox himself. He left the decision to Poitras and Greenwald, and I think that they unnecessarily trashed his life.
- qb45 9y agoI thought it was because both Snowden and Greenwald believed that the US would identify him sooner or later and if his identity wasn't public the CIA would quietly arrest him illegally abroad, like they did to others before, and nobody would even know. http://www.businessinsider.com/the-day-we-revealed-snowdens-identity-2014-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/the-day-we-revealed-snowdens-...
- foldr 9y ago> This is about safety. It is about protecting journalistic sources. Shameless hypocrisy. They had few concerns about safety when they released classified information.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]