3 ms·
How do you think a ship is going to power a continuous acceleration? 1G for 4 years is... I don't really know, but it's a heck of a lot of energy even if you've
by andrewflnr 9y ago
How do you think a ship is going to power a continuous acceleration? 1G for 4 years is... I don't really know, but it's a heck of a lot of energy even if you've somehow beaten Tsiolkovsy's rocket equation. You don't get to hand-wave this away in a remotely serious conversation. There's also the small problem of the interstellar medium wrecking your hull at high velocity, if you ever get there.
- Teever 9y agoYou can cheat a bit by making use of laser propulsion[0] to propel a rocket that contains the necessary fuel for deceleration. To almost completely eliminate fuel requirements in subsequent trips you would bring the self-replicating equipment necessary to scale up the industrial capacity to build an complimentary laser system in the destination star system. This would allow you to propel ships on return voyages and slow down ships coming to the planet. The downside of course is that you've now built a death laser in each star system that could be used to wreak havoc. But then again in this scenario you've also built self-replicating space bots that can turn asteroids into stuff or planets into asteroids into stuff. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_propulsion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_propulsion
- rl3 9y ago>... that contains the necessary fuel for deceleration. Is it not possible to plot an interstellar course that utilizes gravity for deceleration?
- Eupolemos 9y agoWell, the hull problem is there at 1% or 15% of c or whatever is reached. You don't get to wave how you get to the 1% of c speed away either, so let's not set double standards; interstellar transport for humans _is_ all scifi-land. IMO, we simply can't get there with chemical rockets as we know them. Continuous acceleration in space is just any kind of engine that keeps running and provides thrust. We're not talking cars here. The estimation of the energy needed is easy to make sense of - what does it take to have a rocket (or more likely, some other engine) hover over the ground for 4 years using some kind of thrust? When we have that capability, we can pretty much do non-suicidal interstellar transport. But it requires new technology and for me, that constitutes sci-fi. Doesn't mean a conversation can't be remotely serious though, IMHO. But the point I actually wanted to make was, that whenever people talk of cruise-speed in interstellar transport, it seems to me like they haven't grasped the scope of interstellar travel with an intent of conquering it. Rather, they are implying it just can't be done - without arguing for it. The term 'cruise-speed' itself becomes an annoying passive-aggressive attack on the notion of interstellar transport. That was my original reason for posting.
- andrewflnr 9y agoMaybe replace it with "coasting speed" and see if that feels better? It's a valid strategy. We have proposals for drive systems that get to .01c where the physics sort of works. I'm not aware of any realistic proposals that can supply 1g for any length of time. Maybe a ramjet, but last I heard those work better as brakes because, again, interstellar medium. Drag is another reason "cruising speed" might be a coherent concept even under thrust.