4 ms·
Discovering an Equation for Altruism Cost George Price Everything (2016)
- unholiness 9y agoThe article is interesting and biographical, but for those not interested in biography: The Price Equation[1] simply states that the change in a trait due to natural selection is proportional to the covariance between that trait and it's impact on "fitness" (survivability). The link to altruism is that the equation applies to a whole population, not just an individual. So, spending time and energy to help your kin can increase evolutionary pressure for your traits, so long as the gain in utility from the resource transfer is larger than the genetic difference between you. The equation is useful and accurate, though not incredibly insightful. From the article: It is like a footballer who, when asked how their team will win the next match, says they will score more goals than the other team. By trying to explain the game at its most fundamental level, say the critics, the equation explains and predicts nothing about why certain traits should increase or decrease fitness. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_equation
- smrtinsert 9y agoInteresting story but I feel sad for the daughters.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoAs stated by the article, his daughters were happy and thought he did a fine job as a parent.
- FrozenVoid 9y agoSounds like the reverse of Anti-Life Equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Life_Equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Life_Equation "", the Anti-Life Equation is a formula for total control over the minds of sentient beings, that is sought by Darkseid, who, for this reason, sends his forces to Earth, as he believes part of the equation exists in the subconscious. Various comics have defined the equation in different ways, but a common interpretation is that the equation is a mathematical proof of the futility of living.""
- solidsnack9000 9y ago"It was altruistic ants that posed a particular problem for Charles Darwin." Darwin offers a thorough and well-thought out explanation of the sterility of worker ants in The Origin of Species, chapter 8 (where he discusses this and other instincts that are "so wonderful").
- gerdesj 9y agoBeautifully written article with a rather sad and sympathetically handled ending. On the Price Equation, I think this is rather telling - "In her own quest to crack its meaning": * quite simple, really * Another jumped up and started scribbling diagrams and equations on the whiteboard in his office * None of us understands it really ... which leads to: "For its supporters, the Price equation is the closest thing biology has to E=mc2" No it isn't. E=mc^2 stands up to experiment after experiment and observation after observation. The Price Equation is at best a conjecture that looks right. Looking right is not generally considered rigorous.