3 ms·
So what? Upgradeable or replaceable devices prevent a LOAD of electronic waste. Common stuff that breaks on phones: screens, USB jack (hi Samsung, I managed to
by mschuster91 9y ago
So what? Upgradeable or replaceable devices prevent a LOAD of electronic waste.
Common stuff that breaks on phones: screens, USB jack (hi Samsung, I managed to break EVERY USB port on my 5 Samsung phones so far), 3.5mm jack (hello pants dirt, my old friend). Worst phones are these where the USB port is soldered directly to the motherboard and not a cheap daughter board - next to zero repair shops have a solder reflow oven or the necessary skill to operate one, and it certainly doesn't help that there seem to be thousands of different versions of a micro USB jack.
Common stuff that breaks on laptops: keyboard (hi coffee, hi fat cat), HDMI jack and especially power jacks.
Both get hit by batteries going bonkers - I had a couple of laptops with swollen batteries, and I'm happy I still have a phone with a replaceable battery, been through two batteries now.
Having to throw away a (possibly) 1500+ € device because COMMON parts, that cost CENTS, cannot be serviced, is beyond ridiculous.
- npunt 9y agoPerhaps you missed this part in my comment: > That said, during this march we need to allow certain frequent repairs (like screens and buttons) to be easily accessible, because that is fair. Keyboards and buttons make sense, as those are mechanical parts users interact with a lot. Ports are a different story. Is over-use of ports really going to be as much an issue in in 5-10 years? We're fast trending away from lots of ports, favoring wireless for networking, audio/video streaming, and charging. And as far as standards go, USB-C and Lightning are better designed to break at the cable without breaking the device - a much better (engineering) approach to solving this problem. Also, at some point if you break USB jacks on 5 of your Samsung phones, perhaps you should buy from a different vendor that can make something more durable. I think that goes for a lot of cheap products - they break more often because they're not built as well. Introducing legislation to reduce the frustration of cheap products today would come at the expense of forward progress and finding engineering solutions to these in the years to come.
- sliken 9y agoBreaking USB ports is exactly why I buy phones with wireless charging whenever possible. Mini-usb was pretty durable, never lost a cable, device, or phone. Micro-usb, despite the marketing, seems radically less durable. I've lost many chargers, cables, and phones. It's just not up to the task of daily use. I had to give up on a replaceable battery (I normally end up using a phone well after the first battery dies), but I was able to put a wireless charging pad inside the case of my Pixel Xl. So now my usb port is mostly unused and will hopefully last longer than the rest of the phone. If governments wants to decrease waste the should require replaceable batteries. Sad that just as decent quality materials are becoming quite common and CPU/ram are not limiting factors that devices could last 5-10 years... if not for the epoxied batteries.