5 ms·
I wish the EU would come up with some law that forces all computers to be upgradeable. At least RAM, storage, and batteries should be easily exchangeable by a n
by adrianN 9y ago
I wish the EU would come up with some law that forces all computers to be upgradeable. At least RAM, storage, and batteries should be easily exchangeable by a normal user.
- npunt 9y agoThis would be such a double-edged sword, essentially freezing development to where we are today (or were several years ago), rather than pursuing more compact and more highly integrated form factors. I'd rather we continue the march toward making the physical form factor of computers slowly disappear, which will be a much bigger win for everyone. That said, during this march we need to allow certain frequent repairs (like screens and buttons) to be easily accessible, because that is fair. Mandating upgradability means bulking things up with upgrade slots, rather than integrating things onto a lower power, more compact SoC. The other benefit of this is environmental, since you're making a smaller system with fewer components over time.
- mschuster91 9y agoSo what? Upgradeable or replaceable devices prevent a LOAD of electronic waste. Common stuff that breaks on phones: screens, USB jack (hi Samsung, I managed to break EVERY USB port on my 5 Samsung phones so far), 3.5mm jack (hello pants dirt, my old friend). Worst phones are these where the USB port is soldered directly to the motherboard and not a cheap daughter board - next to zero repair shops have a solder reflow oven or the necessary skill to operate one, and it certainly doesn't help that there seem to be thousands of different versions of a micro USB jack. Common stuff that breaks on laptops: keyboard (hi coffee, hi fat cat), HDMI jack and especially power jacks. Both get hit by batteries going bonkers - I had a couple of laptops with swollen batteries, and I'm happy I still have a phone with a replaceable battery, been through two batteries now. Having to throw away a (possibly) 1500+ € device because COMMON parts, that cost CENTS, cannot be serviced, is beyond ridiculous.
- npunt 9y agoPerhaps you missed this part in my comment: > That said, during this march we need to allow certain frequent repairs (like screens and buttons) to be easily accessible, because that is fair. Keyboards and buttons make sense, as those are mechanical parts users interact with a lot. Ports are a different story. Is over-use of ports really going to be as much an issue in in 5-10 years? We're fast trending away from lots of ports, favoring wireless for networking, audio/video streaming, and charging. And as far as standards go, USB-C and Lightning are better designed to break at the cable without breaking the device - a much better (engineering) approach to solving this problem. Also, at some point if you break USB jacks on 5 of your Samsung phones, perhaps you should buy from a different vendor that can make something more durable. I think that goes for a lot of cheap products - they break more often because they're not built as well. Introducing legislation to reduce the frustration of cheap products today would come at the expense of forward progress and finding engineering solutions to these in the years to come.
- sliken 9y agoBreaking USB ports is exactly why I buy phones with wireless charging whenever possible. Mini-usb was pretty durable, never lost a cable, device, or phone. Micro-usb, despite the marketing, seems radically less durable. I've lost many chargers, cables, and phones. It's just not up to the task of daily use. I had to give up on a replaceable battery (I normally end up using a phone well after the first battery dies), but I was able to put a wireless charging pad inside the case of my Pixel Xl. So now my usb port is mostly unused and will hopefully last longer than the rest of the phone. If governments wants to decrease waste the should require replaceable batteries. Sad that just as decent quality materials are becoming quite common and CPU/ram are not limiting factors that devices could last 5-10 years... if not for the epoxied batteries.
- khedoros1 9y ago> I'd rather we continue the march toward making the physical form factor of computers slowly disappear I'm not sure what this means. Can you clarify what you were thinking?
- npunt 9y agoSmaller / thinner / lighter / more ubiquitous / more unbundled. Historically you sit down in front of a computer which bundles compute, display, and kb/mouse input all together. Laptops are variants on that. The last decade's growth in new form factors (phone, tablets, watch, AR/VR, voice, even cloud) are on a path to take over many of the jobs traditionally handled by a 'computer', so my point was just that we shouldn't be too wedded to our existing idea of form factors. I love my big monitors but I'd actually prefer a VR headset, something 1/10th the size or less.
- khedoros1 9y agoThat's an interesting perspective. I can see myself going to an AR display at some point, for some things. I can see a lot of other people moving away from what we've traditionally called "computers". For my own part, there isn't anything around yet that does what I want to do as well as they do.
- kazinator 9y agoI would be satisfied with non-serviceability being treated as harmful, like tobacco or food additives. That is to say, subject it to mandatory labeling: Warning: this technological product is not serviceable or upgradeable in any way. If people still buy it, then that's the free market.
- khedoros1 9y ago> Warning: this technological product is not serviceable or upgradeable in any way. Isn't that what the label "No user-serviceable parts inside" is supposed to convey?
- thrill 9y agoDefine computer. Should Apple be required to make their phones with user replaceable RAM, storage, and power? How about their wristwatches?
- npunt 9y agoYep, there's a lot of category error that gets introduced when using words like 'computer', likely far too much for legislation to handle correctly. We've got more form factors than ever, there's a lot of fluidity between them, and the traditional 'computer' market is stagnating anyways.
- tracker1 9y agoI would say any battery powered electronic device should be required to allow user replacement of said batteries. I would extend to say that any computing device costing over X amount (say $1000 USD) have user replacement ability to also include input device(s), memory and storage. Too many laptops are tossed because the keyboard wears out, or the drive dies.
- dogma1138 9y agoI'll take water resistance over replaceable battery any day of the week.
- tracker1 9y agoHave you never heard of a gasket?
- com2kid 9y agoGaskets are thick. With wrist worn devices, people are very sensitive to thickness. While those with larger hands don't care so much, people with smaller hands start caring about individual millimeters. I have seen consumer studies done where a 2mm difference in thickness results in a product having dramatically more negative customer response.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoIt's not like you can't still buy PCs that are upgradable. I don't think it's unreasonable for extremely thin and light computers to be difficult or impossible to service.
- tracker1 9y agoAll electronic devices designed to operate via battery should be able to have them replaced by a typical owner. If that requires a spudger or standard screwdriver, so be it, but it should be able to be done by most users.
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoI don't think the typical user is willing to even do trivial things like replace the RAM in a desktop PC. I could replace the oil in my car, I'm positive I could figure it out. But I would much rather forgo the money I would save doing so and have it done by an auto shop.
- tracker1 9y agoI do think that most users might be willing to replace a battery every couple of years. Maybe not, we've become a throwaway culture mostly. That doesn't mean it shouldn't be an option or possible.
- Matt3o12_ 9y agoUnfortunately, most consumers are making this harder and harder to do. They now demand thiner and lighter PCs, phones and tables, which make upgrading them increasingly more difficult. What really pisses me off, though, is that specifically Apple is making upgrading all their PCs and laptops impossible (there is currently no Apple laptop that you can easily open with a screw driver without risking damaging the whole laptop). I currently have a 6 year old macbook pro and I love it. I was able to upgrade it a few times (RAM to 16GB and a 650GB SSD) but I am not sure if I will buy another mac if apple has no laptop that is upgradeable and servicable to a certain degree. While my mac is still fine, the CPU is getting slow (compiling bigger programs takes 5 to 10 times as long as they do on newer machines) and I am worried that my mac might not get security upgrades any time now. What the EU would have to do is strike a good compromise, which makes it realistic to upgrade/service devices without pissing off customers because "EU device are so much bigger". Maybe they should force manufactures to sell a bulkier device which is serviceable alongside a non-serviceable device for the same price if a company insists on having a non-serviceable device. But that would increase the costs significantly because now suddenly Apple/Microsoft has to design two devices and offer them for the same price even though one device might only be bought by 1% of the customers. I would really like a bigger MacBook Pro with upgradable components. I use my MacBook as a desktop computer 99% of the time (lit closed with an external screen) but I also need to be able to take it anywhere the 1% and not have to send a large amount of time to upgrade the software, install the new tools just to realize I have forgotten something and use all my mobile just to download that one thing. But maybe I am just a minority.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> They now demand thiner and lighter PCs Do they, though? Like the latest MBP, less battery life, no 32GB option - I don't see many people complaining, "Sorry, the Early 2016 MBP is too thick, need it thinner".
- Matt3o12_ 9y agoYes they do. A lot of people are really excited about the MacBook and MacBook Pro because they are so thin. I even know somebody with the new MacBook Pro who loves its speed and power while being extremely thin. He said he could not image using his older MacBook Pro (I think it was one from 2013) because it was "too thick and heavy". He didn't really need all the power nevertheless he bought one of the more expensive ones because he thought he did. There are a lot of people who buy powerful MacBooks because it makes them feel important. Some of them tend to be sales people who travel to customers to show off some software on their $2k Hardware although this software runs just fine on a MacBook Air. We are a small bubble who can actually take advantage of much ram (I for one need a lot for VMs and google chrome) but most people do not need more ram. fortunately, this year developers and media professionals were finally fed up with the under specced MacBooks and cried loud enough so that the media heard them. And suddenly a lot of people who already had the MacBooks also thought 8/16GB was not enough and started complaining.
- thatswrong0 9y agoPrecisely what this world needs more of is innovation killing regulations.
- rvense 9y agoThe world needs less waste far more than it needs thinner laptops that don't really do more than the five year old one (that still works fine). No sarcasm.
- thatswrong0 9y agoThere are far, far bigger fish to fry in the environmental world than ensuring that the small percentage of users who actually know how to and want to do so can replace their RAM / storage / battery themselves.
- adrianN 9y agoRepair shops and second hand markets exists. Users don't have to be able to replace things themselves. I wouldn't service my washing machine myself either, but I'd like the guy whom I call to be able to replace a small part instead of telling me that the whole thing is junk.
- thatswrong0 9y ago> Users don't have to be able to replace things themselves. But you said above: > At least RAM, storage, and batteries should be easily exchangeable by a normal user. I think the difficulty you're having in specifying what exactly you would want to see out of such a law is indicative that such a law would be ridiculous. Who decides what a "normal" user is? What does "easily exchangeable" mean? How do they enforce this law? The fact that the iPhone is successful is proof that people don't want what you want. I don't see why you feel like your preferences somehow are more important than those of others such that that they warrant a law.