2 ms·
It wasn't "mere suggestion". She told this guy to kill himself repeatedly. She encouraged him to do it. She badgered him about it. After he did it, she didn't
by smt88 9y ago
It wasn't "mere suggestion".
She told this guy to kill himself repeatedly. She encouraged him to do it. She badgered him about it. After he did it, she didn't call the police to ask them to try to save him. She wanted him dead.
The judge did not tell this woman to kill herself, so your hypothetical situation isn't the same thing. There is no slippery slope here. Freedom of speech does not extend to harmful speech. It is similarly not legal to tell people to go out and commit acts of violence.