4 ms·
"The threshold for a self-sustaining city on Mars or a civilization would be a million people. " That number seems highly speculative ... But afaik, there is n
by hutzlibu 9y ago
"The threshold for a self-sustaining city on Mars or a civilization would be a million people. "
That number seems highly speculative ...
But afaik, there is no self-sustaining city on earth, so I doubt there are more solid numbers on that topic. Economic cycles are quite complex, thats for fure.
But aside from that, I think the much more realistic plan, than building and leaving in a huge fleet at once and then see how it goes, would be sending robots first and let them build at least a rudimentary base first and mine resources and teleoperate the whole thing from a save distance ... if that works, we might be ready for colonisation.
And the needed technology is evolving right now on earth.
Maybe less spectacular, but more realistic in my opinion.
- grondilu 9y ago> there is no self-sustaining city on earth Indeed. That's an other concept that I'm not sure Musk is fully aware of. Economies, industrial production systems are highly inter-dependent on Earth. In our "technological civilization", even to build something as simple as a pencil, you need lots of people collaborating from all over the planet [1]. So to me the idea of building a "self-sustaining technological civilization" on mars sounds quite ludicrous. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5Gppi-O3a8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5Gppi-O3a8
- obastani 9y agoJust because people collaborate from all over the planet to make the pencil, doesn't mean that's the way it has to be. This kind of collaboration simply enables economics of scale to kick in (and possibly improve quality as well).
- grondilu 9y ago"doesn't mean that's the way it has to be" Sure, but it does show how speculative Musk's plan for a "self-sustaining city" is. There is no such city on Earth. What makes him think it would work on mars?
- sqeaky 9y agoEvery group of people was self sufficient (or dead) at some point. We just want to keep improving our quality of life at rate that demands more division of labor. Scale that back a bit, of course colonists with have a lower quality of life, they are colonists. Then scale back from 100% self supporting and make a place on mars that is most self-supporting or self-supporting in an emergency. They don't need to be self sufficient from day 1, they need need to be self sufficient enough to eventually get by without constant injection of resources. At some point that can be part of this economy that makes it unprofitable to have self-sufficiency on Earth, but because of trade costs the economics will look different, but not impossible. Locally source will be 1% the cost so buying from Earth with done only for the most valuable items. Things like seeds or IP make perfect sense to buy across the gulf of space. Thing like bulk lumber and toilet paper do not and probably never will.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Just because people collaborate from all over the planet to make the pencil, doesn't mean that's the way it has to be" I agree. I think smaller cycles of dependency are possible (and for the sake of stability maybe better). But we probably have to figure that out, before we go to mars ...
- m-j-fox 9y agoDon't forget the 3 million acres of farmland you need to support your 1 million city folk. We might be able to breed radiation-resistant corn -- not so confident about radiation-resistant chickens. The martians will all be vegan. Good for them.
- hutzlibu 9y agoIf you can have radiation shelters for humans, then you can have them for chickens as well ... (not saying that it is worth the effort to go for it in the beginning, that would be up to the martians to decide I guess)
- mabbo 9y ago> sending robots first and let them build at least a rudimentary base first and mine resources and teleoperate the whole thing from a save distance The main problem is that robots (currently) suck without humans to guide them. And with an up-to 20-minute speed of light delay each way, it's really hard to guide robots on Mars. Curiosity, the most complex robot we've landed on Mars, is managing something like <5 km/year. Autonomous robots would be needed- multiple, very smart and very tough. We don't have that yet.
- sqeaky 9y agoCuriosity is also a unique tool of science. A business could approach this differently. A business doing this would drop several hundred of the same machine on mars. If they were semi-autonomous like Curiosity and controlled from earth each one might get a dedicated driver instead of a team of scientists. A command might include placing location markers, flattening the surface between two markers, pick up dust inside a region and filtering it for some material. The driver would determine what tasks he needed to get done (probably from a jira ticket :( ) then would coordinate with other nearby drivers and even with high latency they could get decent throughput. It might even be that one driver might get several construction machines if the tasks were simple enough. If a machine breaks, the simply move it out of the way until a manned mission. It might also be that there could be a small team on the surface and a slightly larger team in orbit. The surface team could do maintenance and the team in orbit could control a small army of machines. These people could be rotated around or semi-permanent depending on the details of the work and the economics of this situation.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Autonomous robots would be needed- multiple, very smart and very tough. We don't have that yet." We also don't have self-sustainable city's yet. But autonomous robots (or even self replicating ones) are very helpfull for reaching self-sustainable citys. So ... we should work on both ... while Elon Musk is doing the rockets ...