11 ms·
Standard Ebooks: Free and liberated ebooks, carefully produced
- throwanem 9y ago> ...each Standard Ebook is lightly modernized to feature consistent and modern spelling and hyphenation, so old-fashioned ephemera doesn’t distract you from timeless content. I like old-fashioned ephemera...
- eplanit 9y agoExactly. And today's "consistent and modern" form is tomorrow's old-fashioned ephemera. The form used at the time of publishing is relevant, like the content from that time.
- int_19h 9y agoToday's typography is not going to change in the manner it did in the past, for the same reason why dialects are less pronounced: the prevalence of mass media and the Internet makes things converge rather than diverge.
- Freak_NL 9y agoYeah this is something I find a bit awkward. Good typography is definitely a boon, and fixing obvious errors (often mistakes that may not even have been present in each edition) like 'tne → the' is fine, but this modernisation step oversteps the boundary of keeping the original intent and content as the author envisioned it. If the text of an older work presents problems for a lot of modern readers, I would prefer an annotated version with a glossary or even full-blown explanations of antiquated customs, concepts, and words. And I agree, it also takes away some of the flavour of an older book. Not to sound too negative — the project itself looks interesting and of lasting value.
- derefr 9y ago> like 'tne → the' I know it's not what you meant, but one thing I'd genuinely love from a project of re-typesetting old public-domain works is to ensure that any "typewriter symbols" like "->" or "* * *" are turned into their proper dingbats ("→" and "⁂", respectively.) Also, ensuring the (double and single) quotation-mark characters are used, but that scare-quotes and actual measurements (6'1", etc.) don't use them. Just, general heavy-handed replacement of ASCIIisms with proper Unicode equivalents. Though, once you start down that road, it brings you to interesting places: if a book says "ye olde shoppe", do you want to keep the "ye", or do you want to consider it a typographical limitation for what should have been properly typeset as "þe"?
- syrrim 9y agoThe typographical equivalent for thorn is 'th'. You would therefore want to do "the" -> "þe".
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Also, ensuring the (double and single) quotation-mark characters are used, but that scare-quotes and actual measurements (6'1", etc.) don't use them Scare quotes are a adaptation of quotation marks for use/mention distinctions, and shoukd use proper quotation marks the same as anything else; measurements should use the prime and double prime characters.
- rst 9y agoI've seen 'ye' for 'the' on tombstones from the 1600s. The stone carvers weren't picking type out of a box.
- m-p-3 9y agoAgreed, maybe they could include some way of annotating the original content and display a modern version, to preserve the original work but also make it more accessible.
- pc2g4d 9y agoSince they're keeping everything in git, maybe the modernized version could just be a branch---commits rebased on top of a more conservative base.
- Crontab 9y agoI've often thought it would be interesting to see an ebook format that would allow one to toggle between versions of the text or display text inline as some kind of diff. I say this because there are some authors that I read who have revised their works many times, and sometimes I prefer an earlier version over a later revision.
- ivan_ah 9y agoI've been using this approach and it works amazingly well (for text-based formats like .tex and .md). I switched from mercurial to git because rebasing feels much more natural. I'm currently actively maintaining five different versions of a book in parallel as separate branches. The `master` branch sees the most fixes then I rebase the five branches. Anyway, it's great to see books stored in git. Mark my words, this will be a big thing for education!
- samtimalsina 9y agoThis little annoyance aside, I really appreciate the time and effort they put into this.
- panglott 9y agoMost people find it hard to read books with long s, for example, or even know what long s is or where it occurs. "Why are all the s's replaced with f's?" people will ask. It's fine if it's "ash-tray" instead of "ashtray", but the further you go back and the more of these archaicisms you encounter, the more of a barrier they become to ordinary readers (instead of English majors). I don't necessarily like this kind of textual modernization, but in general it's necessary to keep the text accessible to moderns.
- throwanem 9y agoI'm not sure I can agree–seeing 'ſ', where I'd ordinarily expect to see 's', was briefly confusing at first, but I quickly derived from context what it must mean, and found my surmise confirmed in further perusal of older texts. On the other hand–I'm not sure that someone, who has written an Emacs minor mode to perform automatic ſ-insertion where it is grammatical to do so, is necessarily best placed to speak to the general case here.
- derefr 9y agoI don't think the parent poster was talking about being confused as to the meaning; rather, they're talking about the presence of these characters impeding fluent reading speed even after one knows what they are. Enough of these changes and you feel like you have dyslexia, a bit: you have to consciously analyze each word on the page to extract its "reading", rather than just letting your visual cortex pass the words straight into your brain's audio loop.
- throwanem 9y agoSeems like it'd be just a matter of developing fluency, the same way as with any other orthography. Adding one new glyph isn't that big a problem for someone who's already likely to be reading texts where long-s is found - so, at least, has been my experience, and while I always hesitate to generalize therefrom, I don't know that it's so unreasonable to consider doing so here.
- Chaebixi 9y ago
- Animats 9y agoOne can way overdo the modernization. From "The Message", a modernized Christian Bible: "God, my shepherd! I don’t need a thing. You have bedded me down in lush meadows, you find me quiet pools to drink from. True to your word, you let me catch my breath and send me in the right direction. Even when the way goes through Death Valley, I’m not afraid when you walk at my side. Your trusty shepherd’s crook makes me feel secure." Don't go there.
- Avshalom 9y agoI dunno other than Death Valley... well bridal mysticism has a long tradition.
- 15charlimit 9y agoI thought I was reading an overtuned ELI5 machine translation for a minute. This is awful and significantly more difficult to read than even the KJV, which isn't exactly friendly for modern readers.
- Animats 9y agoIt's a tough translation. That section starts "The lord is my shepherd", and continues with a sheep metaphor, with "green pastures" and water, the things sheep need. Sheep draw confidence from the shepherd; they're herd animals and the shepherd is their alpha. Sheep are very herd-bound, far more than cattle or horses; a little bit of guidance and the whole flock follows. They've been bred for docility for millennia; the ones that were easy to herd were kept and bred. The people who wrote that were writing for an audience which knew that; today's audience has probably never seen sheep being herded. Modern versions face the question of how much explanatory material to attach, or whether to try to express that in the main text. Scholars prefer translator footnotes; preachers don't. Still, if you're not translating between languages, it's probably best to stay with the original. Compare, say, Kipling's "007".[1] This assumes some knowledge of railroading in the steam era. "Modernizing" Kipling would be a terrible mistake. It's probably best to leave anything post-1800 entirely as original. And don't even try to "clean up" Shakespeare. It's been done.[2] [1] https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/k/kipling/rudyard/days/chapter8.html https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/k/kipling/rudyard/days/chapte... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bowdler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bowdler
- jessaustin 9y agoI liked this note on Hodgson's The House on the Borderland: The original print edition of this novel contains a pathological number of commas—so much so that a modern reader would find them distracting at best and plainly ungrammatical at worst. The editors of this Standard Ebooks edition have made an effort to remove the most egregious cases of these ungrammatical commas, so that modern readers can better enjoy this unique tale.
- acabal 9y agoYeah that was a hard editorial decision :) I hope we did a good job, but if you disagree then all of the commas we removed were done in a single commit, that you can roll back: https://github.com/standardebooks/william-hope-hodgson_the-house-on-the-borderland/commit/ce0d1a836b85d7de568b4905fab59c089327750f https://github.com/standardebooks/william-hope-hodgson_the-h... You can also review the changes there to see if you agree with our judgment. This book was a unique case. I think the only other time we've done a big editorial change like this was for Pride and Prejudice, also to remove some crazy commas, but for P&P there is a lot of precedent--other editions of Austen very often make those same kinds of changes.
- jessaustin 9y agoIf it's acceptable to edit a "classic" like "P&P" in that fashion, then surely it's even more so for a weird book like this one. b^)
- icc97 9y agoI personally would see this as a disaster. I want the old language warts and all. I want to learn how words were expressed in a historical context. That teaches me more than just the words themselves, that transports you to their time. I did a search in the Google Groups about 'modernization' and you get quotes like this coming up [0] (about William Wollaston's "The Religion of Nature Delineated"): > I've got a first draft ready, after about a month's steady work. I could use some proofreading help, in three areas in particular: > 1. general typos (the use of the long-s in particular I'm sure has led to several) > 2. suggestions for improved use of commas. They did this weirdly in the 18th century, and I think a new edition could do well by bringing the practice up to date, but it isn't my strong suit ... and in reply ... > then it sounds like we'll have to do some significant spelling modernization So they've moved from just 'tasteful' to 'significant'. I don't see how you can draw a line for this kind of thing. But I guess I don't know very much about the painful process up digitising old books. [0]: https://groups.google.com/d/topic/standardebooks/etzVBgBo1VE/discussion https://groups.google.com/d/topic/standardebooks/etzVBgBo1VE...
- icc97 9y agoHere's the tasteful modernization script [0], it contains a ton of regexs (cause regexs never go wrong) with such tasteful changes as: # pease -> peas (but "pease pudding") # régime -> regime (but "ancien régime") The last section of the script gets more interesting # manœuvre -> maneuver (for the Americans) # manœuvre -> manoeuvre (for the British) # cosey -> cozy (for the Americans) # cosey -> cosy (for the British) I've never seen the word manœuvre and thought that I wanted it spelt any other way. Is it really just going to stop at cosy? What's so special about cosy that it needs converting but not other words. Further they have script to [1] > Try to convert British quote style to American quote style So this is not 'standardized', this is 'Americanized'. I was going to make a joke about how they'd probably try and get rid of the pesky 'e' at the end of Shakespeare, however it turns out, instead they actually have the opposite rule: Shakespear -> Shakespeare [0]: https://github.com/standardebooks/tools/blob/master/modernize-spelling https://github.com/standardebooks/tools/blob/master/moderniz... [1]: https://github.com/standardebooks/tools#british2american https://github.com/standardebooks/tools#british2american
- a3n 9y agoI agree, and I think it steps slightly and firmly over the line of changing the author's work. I really hope they "re-think" this. What will they do with Jane Austen's inconsistent spelling, which was common at the time? https://duckduckgo.com/?q=jane+austen+spelling&t=lm&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=jane+austen+spelling&t=lm&ia=web
- antognini 9y agoThese look nice! But I have to say, it is a little bit unexpected that the alphabetical sort by author name sorts by the author's first name.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoUnexpected is putting it mildly. And rather at odds with the claim that they are so careful.
- acabal 9y agoSorry, that's an oversight, the back-end setup is naive in how it does this. I'll have to work on it but I don't have much time today.
- Gackle_Murderer 9y agoYou should support Libgen if you want liberated ebooks. All books deserve to be read.
- timsayshey 9y agoThis really looks amazing! That is all -- I have nothing negative to say -- you guys are killing it with this project :) Curious, who is the founder of this project? Interested to hear more about it's background and the team behind getting this off the ground.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- acabal 9y agoGlad to hear you're liking things! I started the project and am the managing editor of sorts. We're just a small group of volunteers. Our process is very painstaking and specialized so we get much fewer contributors than larger, more easy-going projects like Gutenberg; but I'm just glad that we can contribute a little to free culture everywhere :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoubleCribble 9y ago"Who told you you might meddle with such hifalut'n foolishness, hey?" [1] Liberated? That ephemera might actually be integral to the story and you are NOT the arbiters of intent. Please keep your modernizing out of my lit'ratur. [1]Pap, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
- peller 9y agoTaken to an extreme, would you propose to altogether disallow translation from one language to another? To instead force readers to learn new languages in order to strictly preserve the original authors' intents? Personally, I would like to see our storage formats move towards more dynamic documents, so that the reader can literally flip between the original content and the "modernized" variation. Ebook readers already have integrated dictionaries, why not the discussions and interpretations integrated too? (I ask in a partially rhetorical sense; is fighting the inevitable changing of language really gaining anybody anything? Is it not possible that that "problem" is a red herring?)
- DoubleCribble 9y agoIMHO, modernization tip toes into the same category as translation. From my limited literature experience, the translator is always credited somewhere near the author as it is considered the translator's version. I can imagine a "Do-Gooder" helpfully going through Huck Finn and modernizing all that messy vernacular but that book ain't Mark Twain's and it ain't something I'd want to read. Some folks may have trouble understanding what is being said but modernizing the text would suck the life right out of the story. To your point, I think the ultimate prize is both the original and a modern/translated digital version. Anecdotally, I might have developed an appreciation of Shakespeare MUCH earlier in life had I known not just what the characters were saying but combined with how they were saying it.
- throwanem 9y ago> I can imagine a "Do-Gooder" helpfully going through Huck Finn and modernizing all that messy vernacular You needn't imagine it; it's happened, more than once. For example: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/07/books/07huck.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/07/books/07huck.html?pagewant...
- manojlds 9y agoSite seems to be taking a beating at the moment.
- madsbuch 9y agoI think it is a great project. An I really like the modernization. As a person not native to English, reading long prose is already energy consuming. For me, I like this kind of supply :-) I see that the page is a bit slow. If you need any help to port it to a static format (for performance), please let me know.
- suyash 9y agoEbooks need to become DRM free - full access to the buyer, unlike most books published on Kindle.
- hkmurakami 9y agoI'm telling all my friend about this, with shoddy quality public domain books flooding Amazon/Google. Thanks for all your work!
- acabal 9y agoHi folks, I'm the guy who started and runs Standard Ebooks. It looks like it's been given the hug of death at the moment, sorry about that! While I try to beef up the server you can see all of our productions on Github: https://github.com/standardebooks/ https://github.com/standardebooks/ You may also be interested in our toolset (GNU-compatible only at the moment, we're working on converting everything to Python but we're not there yet): https://github.com/standardebooks/tools https://github.com/standardebooks/tools I'm happy to answer any questions anyone has. We're also more than happy to have new contributors, if you're interested in working on and proofreading a public domain ebook that you've been meaning to get to. Some of you have mentioned concerns about the modernizations we do. The key word I think is "light modernization". Mostly that just means bringing spelling up to modern standards, and removing a lot of hyphens in words that are no longer hyphenated. A common one, for example, is to-morrow -> tomorrow. Another one we recently added was lacquey -> lackey. Generally we leave punctuation and grammar alone. I liken this to modern books replacing the "long s" character--it's just presentation that doesn't affect the meaning. Modern readers would rather see "successful" instead "ſucceſsful" even though the latter is what was originally printed. I struggled for a long time with my desire to see older books with modern spelling and typography, versus preserving the intent of the author and original publishers. Over time I've come to realize two things: 1. Many books back in the day were heavily edited by the printer and publisher without the author's input anyway, so you'll get various editions over time that look totally different. Jane Austen books are a good example of this--early editions often have a pathological overuse of commas, while later editions published after her death just remove a lot of them without comment. So when we're producing our own ebooks, we accept that there's a level of editorial discretion involved, and that "the author's intent" was a very fuzzy and often totally ignored topic hundreds of years ago anyway. How can we tell what the author's intent was in the first place, if various printers and publishers have meddled with the editions for hundreds of years already? 2. For those of you who want to read the originals in their totally unedited form, other projects like Project Gutenberg or Wikisource already have those faithful transcriptions for you, and places like Internet Archive, Hathi Trust, and Google Books have the page scans for you. By lightly modernizing our own productions, we in no way diminish your access to the painstakingly-preserved digital editions; we're just adding another option for you to read.
- intopieces 9y agoWhere can I learn to make carefully produced ebooks? I would like to do this for my own set of free books.
- acabal 9y agoCheck out our contributors page: https://standardebooks.org/contribute/ https://standardebooks.org/contribute/ Specifically, see our typography manual, semantics manual, and the step-by-step guide to producing an ebook (all linked from the contributors page) for details. You can also check out our toolset, which automates a lot of what we do: https://github.com/standardebooks/tools https://github.com/standardebooks/tools
- qrv3w 9y agoYour step-by-step guide is maybe the best step-by-step guide I've ever seen. Very nice work! I'm going to have to give it a try.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoHmm. I've just downloaded Algis Budrys' "Short Fiction" and Lewis Carroll's "Alice", I have to say I have mixed feelings about the files. Both render very badly in Calibre (on Debian Linux, latest stable), very uncomfortable to read with lots of unexpected spaces breaking up the words, yet they render perfectly in Ionic on my Nokia N9 and in FBReader on my Lenovo Android tablet. I've never seen this happen before so I'm not sure if this is a bug in Calibre or in the epub file. A couple of questions: - How come there is no search function? - Why are authors sorted by first name? - Do the results of the proof reading get fed back to Project Gutenberg, et al. - Will readers like FBReader be able to add this catalogue? So, sounds like a good idea and I hope it succeeds but it's not quite there yet.
- acabal 9y agoHave you tried downloading the compatible epub2 file, instead of the epub3 file? I don't think I've used Calibre to test our ebooks on, generally we test on eink devices and tablet reading software, all of which works more or less fine. Unfortunately the state of ereading software today looks a lot like the terrible IE6/Netscape days of yore, where there are no standards and everyone does their own thing differently. It's difficult/impossible to make one file that will render well across all devices. There is no search function because our catalog is so small. It's growing though, so maybe it's about time to add a search function too. Sort by first name is an oversight that I hope to be able to fix later this week. Our edits don't go back to Project Gutenberg, because our final files are so different from what PG produces merging would be impossible. We also introduce typographical and spelling changes that they might not want to accept. Yes, FBReader and other readers that use OPDS can add our catalog: https://standardebooks.org/opds/ https://standardebooks.org/opds/ Edit: Just tried reading the Alice compatible epub file using Calibre 2.55 on Ubuntu 16.04 and it seems to render fine. Maybe you can send a note to our mailing list and we can discuss this in more detail so I can get things fixed?
- kwhitefoot 9y agoBoth files were epub2 not epub3. Perhaps my I have a different calibre version, I'll check again. I opened the Budrys file in Calibre's editor and what I saw that a lot of perfectly correctly spelt words were highlighted as being misspelt. I copied some text from there to Emacs and then saw that there was a hyphen (actually I'm not sure exactly what character it is but it looks like a hyphen) at the point where the reader renders a space. > FBReader and other readers that use OPDS can add our catalog: https://standardebooks.org/opds/ https://standardebooks.org/opds/ Your site looks very pretty but I feel that it is hard to discover things. Sometimes fewer or smaller graphics can make it easier to find one's way around. Anyway, I do understand that it is tough to find time to make everything perfect (I'm a software developer and my to do list never gets shorter). Thanks for finding time to reply.
- geraldbauer 9y agoThat's a fantastic initiative to offer world literature. FYI: A while ago I've started the World Classics Bookshelf - http://worldclassics.github.io http://worldclassics.github.io The idea is to use plain text with markdown formatting conventions (for richer typography e.g. beautiful quotes, em-dashes, etc.). See The Trial by Franz Kafka as an example -> https://github.com/worldclassics/the-trial https://github.com/worldclassics/the-trial (in the Manuscripts plain text source format). The second idea is to use a (standard) static website builder (e.g. Jekyll) for building the online books (from markdown) and to offer different book / page designs (kind of like the Zen of CSS Garden e.g. the Zen of Book Designs). See https://github.com/bookdesigns https://github.com/bookdesigns for some examples incl. the "classic" GitBook style -> http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-git http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-git Anyways, keep up the great work and publishing public domain world classics. Cheers.
- fernly 9y agoYou like http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-git http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-git? I would call it nearly unreadable. Certainly those blocks of sans-serif are fatiguing to my eyes.
- geraldbauer 9y agoGood point. That's just one book design theme. Note: To change the typography e.g. the font used is just a single line in CSS ;-) Maybe you like the Rust theme better -> http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-rust http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-rust or the Epsilon theme - http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-epsilon http://bookdesigns.github.io/book-epsilon PS: And, of course ;-), the idea is to contribute your own designs! It's really just an HTML template with some CSS.
- accordionclown 9y agorather than a flock of templates with different fonts, i'd suggest some simple javascript that lets the users choose their preferred font from a generous assortment.
- kermittd 9y agoWow very cool this is awesome! Also similar to a project I've been working on for a few months.
- emilecantin 9y agoAmazing project! Any plans to port this to other languages? My main language is French, and I'm looking for good old books for my daughter. She read through the Comptess of Ségur's "Les malheurs de Sophie", and she loved it.
- acabal 9y agoUnfortunately, not at the moment. Producing our ebooks require some level of copyediting knowledge and none of us speak French :)
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoIf she's a bit technically inclined, Jules Verne is an obvious choice - though I didn't read them in French, his books absolutely fascinated me as a child. Based on your previous choice, I suspect she's much too young for Flaubert? His writing is marvellous. On the other hand, avoid Malot and his ilk - it's just depressing stuff.
- mkeeter 9y agoInteresting – seems like there's a bit of overlap with Project Gitenberg (https://www.gitenberg.org/ https://www.gitenberg.org/).
- robin_reala 9y agoNearly all of the books on SE use Gutenberg text as a starting point.
- fernly 9y agoI took a look at Gitenberg and just don't get it. They appear to have downloaded a shit-ton of books from Gutenberg into Github -- go to https://github.com/GITenberg https://github.com/GITenberg and note that there appear to be 1659 pages(!) in the list of repos -- and then basically sat on them. Possibly some number of the books have been vastly improved or cleaned up, but there is no way to tell them apart from the ones that are simply dups of the PG files.
- yadavrg 9y agothe website is perfect and host a plenty of good quality ebooks in different domain, but these are not categories. It should be categorized based on their domains like- Technology, Architecture, Literature, Management etc. If it will have subcategories as well then it will be perfect.
- chris_st 9y agoRun, don't walk :-) to download "Three Men in a Boat" by Jerome K. Jerome. It's hilarious, ignore the overly serious cover image: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jerome-k-jerome/three-men-in-a-boat https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jerome-k-jerome/three-men-...