6 ms·
Most startups are pitched with a problem statement: our users want X, and here's how we're going to give it to them. This article talks about how lawyers don't
by gnicholas 9y ago
Most startups are pitched with a problem statement: our users want X, and here's how we're going to give it to them. This article talks about how lawyers don't do X and how Justin thinks they should — but not necessarily that they want to.
As someone who spent 7 years working in biglaw, I can attest that there are many technology-related things that would make lawyers more efficient. For example, the large law firm I worked for ran Windows XP until 2011. This lag is due to (1) the fact that senior lawyers are generally very resistant to new technologies; and (2) the fact that law firms run custom/old software (to do things like format legal briefs to meet the standards of the relevant jurisdiction), which is mission-critical and may not be compatible with software updates.
I'm curious to see what Justin is building here, and hopefully some of the other news coverage with elucidate where the demand is going to come from for his new product/services.
Perhaps they're envisioning their "user" as corporate legal clients, who are going to pressure their law firm to use his project management software? An indirect model like this might make sense, but it sounds like a tough slog to me.
Anyone else know more?
- baus 9y agoConsidering the list of investors, maybe the idea is to drive change from the client side. Basically, "if you don't do business this way, I will take my business elsewhere." Law seems like one of the last hold out professions where business practices are not driven by customer demand or expectations
- gnicholas 9y agoYeah, this was my suspicion. I wish them well — especially now that I see that one of their co-founders was a summer associate with me back in 2006! I'm guessing they have his former firm (Orrick) as a committed beta customer. This would help jump-start demand at other firms, for sure.
- rayiner 9y ago> I can attest that there are many technology-related things that would make lawyers more efficient. I think that's true, but I also think that these "technology-related things" are things that do not exist. Take your example: Windows has not improved in any way that is relevant to lawyers since Windows 2000. What is the point of upgrading? I see many things in my practice where I could see technology making things more efficient. But almost never do I see legal technology that actually addresses that need. For example, the entire legal world runs on PDFs. Court opinions are in PDF form, documents are produced as PDFs, case filings are in PDFs, signed contracts are circulated as PDFs. But for some reason everyone wants to build web-based tools that cannot deal natively with PDFs, or by some miracle manages to be worse than Acrobat at handling them. In another example, client confidentiality is a big deal in law firms. But everyone wants to build web-based tools that upload unencrypted documents god-only-knows where. In a final example: web technology is built on getting good answers to questions everyone is asking. That's the premise underlying Google: if a website is popular as a link target, it's probably a good result. Law is often about exactly the opposite: how do I distinguish my case from all the other ones that go in a way that's bad for my client? In other words, what are the parameters that create the exception to the rule? The techniques used everywhere else on the web are awful for that.
- gnicholas 9y ago> Windows has not improved in any way that is relevant to lawyers since Windows 2000. What is the point of upgrading? Security, for one thing. I agree that others have missed the mark (lacking encryption, not compatible with heavily-used formats like PDF). My point is that this article does not demonstrate why lawyers will actually adopt use this startup's new technology.
- pnmahoney 9y agoI can vouch for the fact that legal technology as a category does not address the needs of lawyers. And which is obvious to most practicing attorneys. As an example: > "spend less time [billing] on research" is not, and never will be, an effective value proposition; and which would be obvious to anyone in anything but the most niche putt-putt fields of practice. Rayiner is of course authority enough on this subject qua the intended market. But I'm here to confirm further that legal technology startups which ignore these central things -- PDFs are essential, confidentiality is maintained on in-house systems with their own vendors, and depth and specificity is critically more important than survey-like breadth -- will probably fail to address any real needs. Source: I worked at a highly atypical IP litigation boutique (where drafts were written in LaTex and we scripted common ediscovery stuff), and later in relevance ranking at a legal tech startup.
- rayiner 9y ago> "spend less time [billing] on research" is not, and never will be, an effective value proposition; and which would be obvious to anyone in anything but the most niche putt-putt fields of practice. I'll note that for many cases these days, there is an incentive to enhance efficiency. Alternative fee arrangements, e.g. fixed monthly fee irrespective of hours, are getting more and more common, particularly with regard to big corps that get sued regularly over the same sorts of cases. Not even commodity work even--these are complex cases for Fortune 100 companies handled by well-regarded firms.
- pnmahoney 9y agoReally?? The move away from standard billing had always felt like it would "always be in the future"; but I take that back if that's now A Thing in lit heavy on case research. Still assuming that ^ research is better facilitated by pagerank+semantic centrality, as opposed to the boolean features that the attorneys who do the most motion drafting work are already most well-versed in. The most valuable usage I'd heard of this type of product (the adoption of which I'd had reasons to keep asking extensively around about) was from my pal in international arbitration whose colleague wanted to do a search across courts in one screen. So maybe that was it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThis article is written for a particular audience. The people selling it to law firms are going to pitch efficiency.
- gnicholas 9y agoYes, but the audience it's written for generally cares about questions like "what is the pain point you are solving for your customer?" That is one of the first questions a funder asks — and given how many funders they have lined up, presumably there is an answer. As for pitching law firms on efficiency, that's actually an uphill battle in many ways. Lawyers bill by the hour, which means that there is not a natural demand for tools that increase efficiency. Post-recession, there is an increasing amount of fixed-fee work, which helps on this front. But the bread-and-butter for many firms (especially prestigious ones, who don't have to accommodate fixed-fee arrangements) is hourly work.
- PatentTroll 9y agoAnd lawyers are still ethically expected (by many state bars) to measure and log hours worked, even under fixed fees. Same with contingency fees. So let's say that a client is paying a fixed fee for work, then discovers that it's now taking half the time to do the same work. They're going to demand a lowering of their fixed fee in proportion. So even under alternative fees, there's still an incentive to keep high "hours" on the bill
- cdiamand 9y agoI've done a few interviews with junior lawyers for my newsletter OppsDaily. I've encountered several individuals who want better technology but don't have the pull at their firms to actually get it implemented. Here's one, but there are 2-3 more that fit this pattern: "My job industry is Law. We are still using paper files for cases. Software would make it easier to file and search for case information. I personally would Pay $1500 for a business license for this type of software, but I can't speak further with a developer because my boss is old-fashioned."