4 ms·
What's the actual difference? As far as I can see, they're both poor text editors with bad interfaces, built on top of the horrible mess that is Electron. They'
by Hamuko 9y ago
What's the actual difference? As far as I can see, they're both poor text editors with bad interfaces, built on top of the horrible mess that is Electron. They're also both massive. VS Code takes up 235 MB and Atom takes a whopping 530 MB. Sublime Text is like 30 MB.
- drej 9y agoIs the editor size an issue? For quick startup, sure, but when the tool is actually running? (Which at least on my machine, it's on most of the day anyway.) I used to prefer lean editors (vim, Sublime), but then intellisense and plugins of VS Code won me over. That and git support and other niceties working out of the box.
- oblio 9y ago> they're both poor text editors with bad interfaces I can see why you might call them "poor text editors", probably based on real or perceived performance issues. But I don't see why "bad interfaces"...
- edraferi 9y ago> What's the actual difference? I believe Intellisense is VScode's best differentiator. It provides very good autocomplete.
- rspeer 9y agoI use VScode currently (for Python) but I'm not entirely satisfied with it. How do you set up this very good autocomplete? The official Python plugin (by Don Jayamanne) seems kind of bad at autocomplete and related features. I get autocomplete that: - Autocompletes random stuff because I pressed "enter" or "down" - Tries to autocomplete comments - If I tell it to autocomplete only on tab, then it will sometimes autocomplete and sometimes insert spaces; the faster I type, the more I get spaces - Pops up enormous tooltips for function docstrings that are taller than my entire code window
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- petre 9y ago> they're both poor text editors with bad interfaces They're not poor editors. They're okay. And the interface is fine, I've actually grown to like Atom after having used it for a month. They are they're at least an order a magnitude bigger and slower than Sublime Text, yet pretty usable on a modern desktop computer. I've also used Sublime Text for three or four years on a daily basis.
- jordache 9y agoit's funny to complain about absolute program size on the disk...
- endorphone 9y agoThe whole Atom / VS Code thing is fascinating to me. Don't most denizens of HN already use far superior editors? My day is spent in Visual Studio (the real one) and IntelliJ IDEA, both of which annihilate those other options. And both of them are freely available, the latter available on everything. VS Code in particular seems to have a massive astroturfing campaign behind it. Every benign post that tangentially mentions it yields dozens of ridiculously adulatory posts. It is incredibly fishy.
- Guillaume86 9y agoIf you never enjoyed the experience of a lightweight editor or was never bothered by the sluggishness of heavy weight IDEs, fine but don't blame any praise you don't understand on astroturfing. I use both VS and VSCode and I prefer using VSCode by far.
- endorphone 9y agoIf you never enjoyed the experience of a lightweight editor or was never bothered by the sluggishness of heavy weight IDEs Neither Atom or VS Code are lightweight. Both feel absolutely glacial compared to those other IDEs (including even IDEA that is atop Java). This mythology that they're "light" isn't remotely founded in reality. Regarding astroturfing, your claim is exactly the sort of claim that seems suspicious. If Visual Studio or IDEA is scary (if I was setting my son up with something simple to play around with web development), sure use something superficially simpler, but the claims of lightness are outrageously detached from reality. Another comment mentioned a negative association with Microsoft, and I'm going to say it's that association that yields the pseudo-astroturfing -- lots of developers who threw their hat into the Microsoft stack, and now that they have something that is open source-y and cross platform, they advocate it for legitimacy. It's an option, sure, but the over the top gushing for another Electron-based editor is surreal.
- allover 9y agoSeems fairly obvious to me why VS Code would be popular with web devs like myself. It has a built in JS debugger and lots of web-related stuff works out of the box (TypeScript, JSX etc). Also the fact it is built in JS means it's easy to extend in JS, so the plugin community is already very healthy. The Vim mode is pretty damn good too (first editor to tempt me away from Vim since I learnt Vim). I don't think there's any astroturfing/fishiness at all. If anything the opposite, they've had to overcome the negative association with MS, and to some small degree Electron. They seem to have done that by 'making a good thing', that everyone who tries is somewhat impressed with. You mention Visual Studio and IntelliJ. Two obvious downsides with those - former is only on Windows, the other is relatively expensive. I tried IntelliJ Webstorm once, seemed good but I never really got a good enough feel for it before my trial ran out, so never tried again shrug.
- SippinLean 9y ago>with bad interfaces VS Code's interface is nearly identical to Sublime's, with some nice sugar in places that are helpful (optional GUI for keybindings and extensions). For debugging and version control VS Code's interface OOTB is leaps and bounds above Sublime's. >VS Code takes up 235 MB Meh I have 16GB of RAM on my old computer. Or do you actually just mean HDD space? Who cares about 200MB in that regard?
- Hamuko 9y agoVS Code's interface is a garbage Metro (or whatever Microsoft is calling it today) implementation with sidebar hell from Office. >Who cares about 200MB in that regard? Who cares about anything? Just use everything you have. CPU, RAM, battery life and so on. These things are free for the developer. Is VS Code actually seven times better and/or complex compared to Sublime Text that it actually needs to use the additional disk space. Electron is garbage and just an exercise in providing a bad user experience to people for the sake of making front-end developers happy since they're the ones making them. The end result is bloated applications that are slow and use way too much system resources. VS Code used to use a significant portion (>10%) of the CPU just to draw a blinking cursor.
- LiquidFlux 9y agoElectron is the reason you're getting these kind of desktop applications built in the first place, it's opened up an entire portal of developers to catering to your needs. It may not be the ultimate solution to the problem with regards to things such as performance, but these are irrelevant if the application were to never be built in the alternative.
- swozey 9y agoCheers to that. Maybe now with Electron the developers at 1Password will give us a Linux port........
- SippinLean 9y agoAll vague overly general misrepresentations of the very specific points I made. I think the other "DAE Electron is bad?" comments can suffice without you adding.