4 ms·
I feel that the folks that do this aren't working for big companies. In most big companies you can't really afford to do any email client shenanigans. You prob
by oblio 9y ago
I feel that the folks that do this aren't working for big companies.
In most big companies you can't really afford to do any email client shenanigans. You probably need to see HTML emails, handle calendar invites, etc.
- simias 9y agoCalendar invites are just attachments, you can handle them in external scripts and programs any way you like. Personally I just display them in plain text next to the email, but if you wanted to interface them with your calendar application I'm sure there are plenty of scripts doing that out there. As for HTML email, what I take from this entire thread is that I either I've been extremely lucky so far or people in general vastly overestimate the importance of it. For one thing, most decent services will send multipart/alternative emails that are suitable for plain text display. For instance Amazon's emails use rich HTML features, but they also have a text/plain alternative that works perfectly in a text client and carries the same informations. And when there's only HTML the vast majority of the time it's still mostly text with some light styling and it works just fine (sometimes better) in text mode. The main problem working in big companies and using mutt as my client is that most of the time those systems have a 2nd class non-compliant IMAP servers and you have to go through oops to reliably receive and send your email. I always managed to get it to work after some tweaking though.
- uiri 9y agoYou're right that most services do send a multipart message with a sane looking plain text version. The biggest issue with that is when the sender of the email doesn't actually check that the content was converted properly. Most notably, hyperlinks in the HTML get converted to the text of the link and the URL in question is no where to be found. Even if most HTML emails send perfectly created plaintext versions (and yes, Amazon is great at this), you'll remember the crappy unreadable HTML-only emails far more than the normal looking multipart ones with proper conversion of the HTML to plaintext. My first job in high school involved formatting and sending out email blasts. Even at that point, I was aware of potential formatting issues and I took care to make sure that the automatically generated plaintext version had all the same content. For that reason, I have no patience for HTML-only emails crafted by grown adults.
- phicoh 9y agoAges ago I set up my mail client to pipe HTML e-mail through 'lynx -force_html -dump'.
- joshka 9y agoTBH, I'm starting to think people that work in big companies need this the most. Outlook's filtering configuration is fairly limited compared to what you can do with a well setup procmail system.
- oblio 9y agoTrue, but good luck working without an operational calendar system.
- daxorid 9y agoPrior to circa 2005, people managed to get by just fine without companywide calendars clogged with irrelevant PTO days, etc. Modern shared calendars arguably provide negative value versus simply keeping a private calendar.
- LaSombra 9y agoThe company I work for is big-ish, ~10k, and many use mutt, emacs, Thunderbird and some even use a mailing-list<->nntp with slrn. I think it all depends on which area of work you are in. For software engineering folks it works just fine. I for one use mutt and handle calendar invites with gcalcli, I can use LDAP lookup and HTML mails are converted using elinks and read inside mutt. If I want to see all the fanciness I just open the text/html attachment in Firefox.
- Thaxll 9y agoI have hard time believing that more that 1% of a 10k employees company use Mutt.
- pyre 9y agoThe parent to you post was responding to this: > In most big companies you can't really afford to do any email client shenanigans. So... what does the percentage of employees using Mutt have to do with that?
- rayvd 9y agoThey probably also use Outlook. That's what I do (4K employees). Used to use Mutt almost exclusively, but just became too hard and people complained about my emails turning everything to Courier. :) I still use Mutt to quickly prune emails in the AM and for writing to mailing lists. I've (sadly) gotten pretty used to Outlook and like it quite a bit. I do miss using vim to edit emails though...
- Samon 9y agoI agree. I work in a large-ish company (~9k) who a few years back moved from Exchange/Outlook to GSuite (with POP and IMAP disabled) - so using anything but the Gmail web interface and/or the mobile apps is out of the question. Add in the obligatory (and yes, slightly annoying) corporate managed email signature (HTML), the fact that everyone is used to just copying images/screenshots inline with the text, and of course the very tight google mail/calendar/drive integration, and I don't think that even if I could use a text-only client outside the Google ecosystem, it would be a viable option.
- pyre 9y agoThere is a lot of software for working with Google services via the CLI. Your biggest hurdle is probably that POP/IMAP is disabled for email.
- zhengyi13 9y agoNaively, I could see wanting to disable POP given the potential for inadvertent mail loss, but what justification could there be for disabling IMAP?
- Samon 9y ago"Data Leakage Protection". The idea being that the everything that ever goes in or out of a mailbox is recorded, audited, etc. Yes, deleting an email/thread doesn't remove it from Vault, but this way, other than copying/pasting from the browser window into another client, there is always a trail of where an email went, and users can't "take home" a dump of their entire mailbox. When legal get involved and need a dump of "every email between employee X and external party Y", there is no question of whether a different SMTP server was used so we may not have a record of the sent messages, etc.
- mikegerwitz 9y ago> You probably need to see HTML emails, handle calendar invites, etc. At work I use Outlook only for the calendar.
- cmiles74 9y agoIt's probably pretty weak for me to admit, but I accept calendar invitations on my phone. As you say, accepting them in Emacs or Mutt doesn't seem worth the hassle (I get a handful a week). At this point, it's pretty rare for me to get an email that I need to read that I can't, mostly those are spam or sales messages. Where I work, the company uses the "G Suite" of products.