4 ms·
I too am wondering about this. I thought entanglement couldn't be used for communication because observing both particles simultaneously will reveal that they h
by djsumdog 9y ago
I too am wondering about this. I thought entanglement couldn't be used for communication because observing both particles simultaneously will reveal that they have opposite spins. It's a conformation after observation, based on what the quantum superposition collapses into once you observe the state. But the actual state is also unknown until you observe it.
I'm not a physicist, but I'm sure there're be one on HN that will tell us what this study really means.
- yorwba 9y agoNot a physicist either, but as I understand it, entanglement is not useful for communication on its own, but allows for tamper-proof key exchange. Basically, you generate a pair of entangled particles. Keep one of the pair and send the other away. Now both you and your partner randomly select a basis to measure the particle in. After a few repetitions, you tell each other (over a classic channel) how you measured and discard measurements made in different bases. The remaining results will be strongly correlated, depending on the quality of the entanglement. By comparing a small part, you can find out exactly how much. If the correlation is lower than expected, you might have some dust in your measurement apparatus, or an eavesdropper has intercepted a few quanta. If the correlation is good enough, you now both have a value that is secret to anyone who did not measure the particles. The secret value can then be used as a key to encrypt your communication over the classic channel. If this description is not satisfying, maybe the Wikipedia article explains it better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_key_distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_key_distribution
- RugnirViking 9y agoIsn't that no better than a one-time pad if you need a classic channel?
- yorwba 9y agoQuantum key-exchange solves the distribution problem for one-time pads. And a one-time pad is the best security you could possibly get, so I'm not sure what you mean by "no better", since that's a given.
- RugnirViking 9y agoIf you need a classical channel doesn't that just create another distribution problem though? And yeah, but im considering one time pad as good as the security of its key in transfer
- EGreg 9y agoWell, if there is one, you will only know for sure after they reply. It's a conformation after observation too.
- Kroniker 9y agoI am a physicist. I only glossed the article, but from what I gathered, this didn't prove anything about QM, rather it was a technical achievement. One of the biggest problems with entangled pair distribution is actually separating the particles over some distance, because when the entangled particles interact with something ("observed") their state collapses and the entanglement may end. This is what the achievement was, they managed to not destroy entanglement of a pair over a very long distance.