4 ms·
Information "wants" to be gratis only in the sense that water "wants" to flow downhill. It turns out that devices that impede that flow (like a cup) are useful.
by webmaven 9y ago
Information "wants" to be gratis only in the sense that water "wants" to flow downhill. It turns out that devices that impede that flow (like a cup) are useful.
The corollary then to your particular analogy is that since anonymity on the internet was the default, it turned out that much of the commercial value eventually accrued to companies that correlated online activities with each other (searches, clicks, posts, likes, etc.) and tied the bundle to an identity.
- mirimir 9y agoThe Internet was never anonymous. Especially not at the start, when every computer had its own IP address.
- webmaven 9y agoFirst, IP address assignment for dial-up users was generally random from a pool, and ISPs usually only kept logs long enough to be useful for troubleshooting purposes. But ignoring the IP address assignment issues, do you remember what website log analysis tools (eg. http://www.webalizer.org/ http://www.webalizer.org/) were like back then? Most encouraged dumping the raw logs and just keeping the summarizing reports. As a result, for most intents and purposes the data on nearly all user information consumption and interaction was ephemeral. These New Yorker cartoons sum up the situation then and now: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Internet_dog.jpg#/media/File:Internet_dog.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Internet_dog.jpg#/media/F... http://68.media.tumblr.com/7a8daddf2030b685e5e776eb9af7a6ac/tumblr_njzlcpXjY91qav5oho1_500.jpg http://68.media.tumblr.com/7a8daddf2030b685e5e776eb9af7a6ac/...
- mirimir 9y agoAt the start, there were no ISPs. Assuming that logs are transient is dangerous. Remember how Kevin Mitnick got pwned?
- sethrin 9y agoAh, you're talking about the start of the web. The person you responded to was talking about the start of the Internet -- ARPANet or one of its later incarnations. When the traffic started exploding, yes, it became possible to be pseudonymous on the internet, but before then IP addresses were pretty much known and assigned in large blocks to particular universities/agencies/companies. It sounds like there may be some history you missed out on. I recommend reading 'The Cuckoo's Egg' by Cliff Stoll if you've not already done so.