3 ms·
The way that you restore balance is that you make it illegal to force people to join them, as it is in many right to work states. If unions are so great, then
by stale2002 9y ago
The way that you restore balance is that you make it illegal to force people to join them, as it is in many right to work states.
If unions are so great, then they can stand on their own.
If they end up sucking, then people will leave them.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoExcept right-to-work laws allow non-union members to freeride. If we truly wanted to restore balance then people opting out of the union wouldn't be able to benefit from any of the union's negotiations. Of course then everyone would join the union so...
- obstinate 9y agoAnd it's quite hard to do that. Companies tend not to want to negotiate with a union and have a separate compensation structure for non-union employees in the same job families. It's hard to have or benefit from one set of working conditions for union members and one for non-members. IMO, both employees and employers should be free to form what groups they please and negotiate what contracts they will. This includes contracts that forbid an employer from hiring non-union workers. But there should also be no law mandating such a provision. Of course subject to government regulation that supersedes contracts (health and safety, human rights provisions, others).
- stale2002 9y agoI don't want your union negotiation benefits, though. I don't want to be covered by the union contract. You should be able to negotiate with your own group of people to get certain benefits, and I should be able to negotiate on my own. And then we could see who really gets the better deal. Personally I am confident that my own deal would be better, but I have no problem with other people deciding for themselves that they would prefer whatever deal that a union was able to negotiate.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI see the exception that proves the rule has showed up. You know it's obvious to me that you're in a privileged position and can leverage this to do quite well in the job market with or without worker collective action. One thing I would say is that even someone like you benefits from unions. Unions have negotiated many benefits we take for granted today and can even benefit workers not in the union. For example, my mother did not go to college and started working straight out of high-school. She was able to get a job that paid her really well considering the time and her inexperience. And she didn't even have to join a union to get it. Instead her employer always kept wages a little above the other unionized shops in town, in order to keep the union at bay. Which is all to say that if common workers in your industry unionize you will probably be able to negotiate an even higher premium in exchange for not joining the union. Also keep in mind unionization is a freedom which is currently being infringed! I firmly believe that organizations should be able to draw up agreements with another! If a union and a company mutually agree that all the company's workers must join the union, I don't see a problem with that. The fact that our lawmakers are going in and writing backdoors so that this is serious government overreach.
- home_boi 9y ago> Which is all to say that if common workers in your industry unionize you will probably be able to negotiate an even higher premium in exchange for not joining the union. Or the union can force you out of your job by forcing the employer to hire unionized employees only.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThat sentence was about joining a firm which doesn't use a unionized workforce (like my mom). That should have been more clear, my bad.
- stale2002 9y ago
- elicash 9y agoThis is like making taxes optional.
- stale2002 9y agoI am not suggesting that I should be covered under the union contract, without paying union due. Far from it! I do not want the union contract, because I believe that I can get a better deal for myself. The unioners can have their contract, and I can have mine. In the same way that I negotiate for myself right now, in a fully union free industry.
- wcummings 9y agoRight-to-work hobbles unions, not exactly "restoring the balance", if there ever was one.