4 ms·
Is it really causing polarization, or is it causing more groups of people who were previously separated to become less separated and thus bringing the already-e
by jerf 9y ago
Is it really causing polarization, or is it causing more groups of people who were previously separated to become less separated and thus bringing the already-existing differences into a context where they can't be ignored?
I think if you ground yourself in history, and look around the world, you will see that there were plenty of very real differences between people and groups of people in both spatial and temporal directions, and anybody who had the idea that "everybody in the world is mostly the same and generally agrees with each other (and me)" was simply unaware of how deeply false that has always been.
If you look at it that way, a reflexive closing of the ranks after these decades of increasing contact with others is quite predictable, and I'm pretty sure you can expect it to continue apace for the next couple of decades at a minimum, and there's basically nothing you can do about it except somehow manage to restore the communication environment back to around the 1950s or earlier.
(After that, I expect another wave of internationalism similar to the one that currently exists (albeit sputtering and fading) between the elites of the US and the EU, but much more widely spread. But before that can happen, a lot more countries need to get much, much wealthier.)
- dredmorbius 9y agoIsn't one pretty much the other? I look at the overall dynamic as epidemiological. You need both the disease agent and the transmission vector. But if you've got a latent agent, and a suitable host, then providing the vector will trigger the pandemic. If you look back at history, you can view the Inquisition and 30 Years War both as attempts to retain ideological purity in an environment where the spread of undesireable agents (ideologies) was promoted by a new reproduction and transmission system (mostly: printing, also increasing literacy rates). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inquisition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inquisition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/30_years_war https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/30_years_war
- jerf 9y ago"Isn't one pretty much the other?" In terms of the "polarization", no. Either it was mostly pre-existing and unrealized, or increased communication created the polarization. I'm saying that the communication revealed already-existing polarization rather than is creating it. Give people 1000 years ago a sudden total Facebook and I have no reason whatsoever to believe that they'd all discover their one true unity of belief; I daresay they'd find even greater polarization. Of course it isn't 100% one or the other, and theoretically some sort of 50/50 situation could be the case, but I'm not particularly convinced the Internet is creating polarization to speak of. As I said, I think the idea that people were non-polarized and basically agreed with each other has always been false, even in something as specific as the US. Parents have voted Republican while their children have voted Democrat for a long time. Which also means, don't expect it to stop anytime soon. Generally when people say they want the polarization to decrease, they really mean "I want everybody to acknowledge the intrinsic and obvious rightness of my position and agree to share it"; I mean, nobody who decries polarization ever seems to volunteer to switch their personal beliefs that I've seen. But it turns out that while that was always a fantasy, we can now all see up close and personal just how much that's a total fantasy that isn't going to happen.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIf you change one element of a system and the result of that change is a sudden and significant change in system dynamics, I'd say you're splitting hairs in allocating causality. Communications created manifested polarisation, if you will. The previous state didn't have that. Comms created the new situation.
- jerf 9y agoBut I'd say in return that's a serious goal-post hike. When people write these sorts of articles and decry modern social media for "polarization", they are clearly claiming that it is creating it where it didn't exist before. It is a totally different problem if it is revealing something that has always existed in a way that is harder to ignore. The moral responsibility for Facebook et al creating polarization is much greater than for Facebook discovering the already-existing polarization. Also, if one believes this is a problem to be solved, the solutions for "Facebook is creating polarization" and "Facebook is revealing already-existing polarization" are totally different. And wildly different in feasibility. There are absolutely real differences that emerge from the two possibilities. One situation could be solved by just basically shutting down the social Internet, albeit at great cost. (And other possibilities, but all at great cost.) The other... well... there hasn't been a lot of success at fundamentally changing human nature, and most serious attempts lately have caused more problems than they've solved.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIn the case of FB, the question to me is whether or not the introduction of FB changes the dynamic. If, say, phone and SMS-based activities simply shifted to FB, without any significant change in scope, scale, speed, use, or outcomes ... there's a case to be made for "the medium changed, but the behaviour didn't". If the behaviour itself changes, in scope, scale, speed, use, adoption by specific groups, or outcomes, then that out becomes far smaller. Put another way, if there's some extant potential, say a charge differential, or a water reservoir at elevation, and you provide a conductor or remove the barrier keeping it from flowing -- I'd call that a causal relationship. Or are you saying that a dam failure resulting in a valley being flooded out is simple a realisation of the existing potential and polarisation of high and low elevations? I'm not buying that. Media enables. And if costs are reduced, it enables that which was simply not previously possible.