3 ms·
> I think that the basic interface for the iPhone was fairly inevitable I hear that a lot, and I'm not convinced. I think people needed to have a strong motiv
by macintux 9y ago
> I think that the basic interface for the iPhone was fairly inevitable
I hear that a lot, and I'm not convinced.
I think people needed to have a strong motivation to get used to software keyboards. I think most companies implementing one would have screwed it up (see: RIM).
So you'd need a compelling use case and compelling software to force that sea change. I find it plausible that, absent Apple's existence, we'd be using clunky GUIs on desktop computers and even clunkier GUIs with physical keyboards on smartphones.
- macintux 9y agoI also think it required a manufacturer to completely sell out to the concept. If there are 5 similar phones by the same company, only one of which has a software-only keyboard, you won't get sales, development, and engineering support you need to drive a successful change. Much like laptops still being shipped with floppy drives and VGA ports years after those technologies were effectively dead.
- CommieBobDole 9y agoLaptops ship with VGA ports because the business world is full of conference rooms where the projector only has a VGA cable.
- macintux 9y agoAnd if PC manufacturers forced the issue they'd sell more dongles and/or drag businesses into the 21st century.
- Eridrus 9y agoYeah, I'm not convinced either. Android was still getting built with a Blackberry-style physical keyboard at that point. It feels like if it wasn't for a few researchers in the interaction lab we wouldn't have gotten software keyboards for a while.
- Animats 9y agoI think that the basic interface for the iPhone was fairly inevitable. We could have had a long detour through Blackberry-like devices with keyboards. But comprehensive smartphones in some form were to be expected as the electronics got cheap enough. I find it plausible that, absent Apple's existence, we'd be using clunky GUIs on desktop computers Without Apple, we probably would have had something like lower-priced Sun or Apollo workstations on the desktop. For most of the 1980s and 1990s, people at well-funded companies did have Sun workstations on the desktop. With, though, crappy GUIs. XWindows is from that era. It would never have occurred to Sun to hire Susan Kare. Sun didn't have the volume to support software companies. Interleaf had something better than Microsoft Word by 1983, before the Mac had even shipped. But their business model was to bundle a few Sun workstations and a laser printer with the software, for about $60K. Software for Sun machines tended to cost a few thousand dollars per seat.
- mozumder 9y agoJust because the hardware would improve doesn't mean the UI would improve. Digital cameras have killer hardware, but they still have the same crappy menu systems they had when they were first introduced in the 90's. You absolutely need extremely rare talent to produce original & creative ideas like what was used in the iPhone, and the digital camera makers have absolutely none of that talent. Yes, the world would continue to use clunky desktop-oriented WindowsCE/Blackberry/Treo phones today without Apple. They really were original and unique to the industry in how they completely changed its course. Also, never take advice from Phil Schiller.
- Inconel 9y agoI'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, but what in your opinion makes the menu systems in digital cameras so crappy? I have an older Canon digital SLR, and while the rear LCD isn't as big, bright, or high res as newer cameras, and it lacks touch support, I generally find the menu system pretty nice. It's fairly information dense and has dedicated buttons for a whole host of features so that you don't have to go digging through a bunch of hamburger menus.
- mtdewcmu 9y agoNone of that disagrees with my point, I don't think. >>I think most companies implementing one would have screwed it up (see: RIM). Little keyboards were a dead end (I think I remember reading contemporaneous articles noting the fundamental problem of "little keyboard -> little screen" and the little screen being just too small. The real issue wasn't the little keyboard per se, it was the little screen). I think Apple had the advantage in creating software keyboards, because they had the ability to tightly coordinate the hardware and software development. They also the capital to take the risk. I suppose RIM also did hardware and software, but their software was less sophisticated than Apple's. >>I find it plausible that, absent Apple's existence, we'd be using clunky GUIs on desktop computers and even clunkier GUIs with physical keyboards on smartphones. Wasn't that sort of my point? My point was that only Apple was positioned to do the iPhone in the mid-2000s.
- macintux 9y agoGiven the difficulty of entering the mobile handset market, and the inertia of most players, I'm just not sure we would have broken out of the rut. I think the player who might have made the leap was Google, who was experimenting with touchscreen devices, but they aren't the boldest company when it comes to hardware.
- mtdewcmu 9y ago>>Given the difficulty of entering the mobile handset market, and the inertia of most players, I'm just not sure we would have broken out of the rut. I think we might agree on that? I guess my main thesis rests on the idea that an iPhone is more like a tiny computer than it's like a circa-2007 cell phone. It was easier for Apple to make a tiny Mac with phone capabilities than it would have been for a handset manufacturer to retrofit PC-like functionality onto their handsets. Apple was already the master of the Mac ecosystem, which they could leverage however they wanted. Handset manufacturers would have had to acquire a computer platform or partner with a computer company (which, I guess, is the story of Android).
- digi_owl 9y agohttp://www.gsmarena.com/sony_ericsson_p800-326.php http://www.gsmarena.com/sony_ericsson_p800-326.php the "keyboard" were simply a bunch of pins that prodded the screen in the appropriate places. If you wanted to you could simply remove the cover and just poke the screen directly.