5 ms·
> But it's nothing, nothing compared to the crime against humanity that is the Snapchat UX. Every time Snapchat's UI/UX is brought up on Hacker News it's prais
by minimaxir 9y ago
> But it's nothing, nothing compared to the crime against humanity that is the Snapchat UX.
Every time Snapchat's UI/UX is brought up on Hacker News it's praised as "it facilitates the joy of feature discovery!" (example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10859860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10859860)
It's a post-hoc rationalization that I am still not happy with. (even moreso 2 years later with more apps like Facebook/Skype copying Snapchat verbatim)
- Karunamon 9y agoDevil's advocate: Instagram is not a "serious" photo app. It's strictly for fun. if you want to shoot serious pictures, you use a purpose built app, or heck, even the built-in app on your phone. Making the UI a hide-and-seek game, or at least abandoning traditional UI design for something that puts form over function makes sense in that context. There's an actual game on Steam called "Please, don't touch anything" where this kind of random discovery is the whole point. Not sure I'd prejudicially dismiss it as "millennial smugness" though.
- simonh 9y ago> There's an actual game on Steam called "Please, don't touch anything" The original was a web game way back in the day called "Don't shoot the puppy". When I realised what was going on I nearly died laughing. My flat mates thought I was having a seizure.
- askafriend 9y agoInstagram is not just a camera app anymore. It’s strong point is distribution and discovery. There is a huge pro photography community on there. They all shoot with serious DSLR/Mirrorless setups, edit shots in Adobe Lightroom and then post the resulting photos on Instagram for their following to see and engage with. Do not dismiss the pro use case for Instagram because it is massive.
- komali2 9y agoYup, this is exactly what I do, though as a hobbyist. My instagram "feed" has very few pictures not taken on a DSLR and edited in lightroom. My stories, on the other hand...
- htormey 9y agoYep, this is me. 90% of my photos are shot with a sony a7 and zeiss lenses, then posted to Instagram for fun.
- klodolph 9y agoInstagram is a serious photo app in the same sense that the Holga is a serious camera.
- rhizome 9y agoWould you agree that the Kodak Instamatic was a serious camera? That is, technology isn't serious, it's the use that it's put to that determines.
- ansible 9y agoLink for the lazy: http://store.steampowered.com/app/354240/Please_Dont_Touch_Anything/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/354240/Please_Dont_Touch_A... It is a funny sort of opposite of games the "The Room" where you are indeed supposed to touch everything.
- kbenson 9y agoThat sounds suspiciously like the addiction specialists got bored with the real games they were tweaking, and decided to move on the the UI instead, and gamify that. "Hmm, my friends are all using this weird effect, I wonder how they are doing that? I guess I'll have to spend some time and figure it out so I'm one of the elite users too..." Mix one part neglect and abuse with one part intense pleasure from finally getting what you were looking for. Enjoy your Stockholm Syndrome cocktail, rinse and repeat.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- subterfudge44 9y agoSnap's UI is a bit like that of Pinterest. I am not really sure why either of them are a hit.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoI think maybe you have to be 12 to actually even successfully use that UI.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoI think maybe you have to be 12 to actually even understand that UI.
- Fricken 9y agoOnce you know the Snap UI it works very well. Kind of like a DSLR camera, it takes forever to learn all those buttons and functions and become habitual with them, but once you know how to find all the functions and operate the camera properly it's apparent that everything has been beautifully placed and carefully thought about. An easy to learn UI isn't necessarily the most efficient or versatile to use. Old people wonder 'WTF is this Snapchat?', they download the app, dick around with it for a few minutes and dismiss it as incomprehensible. It's a feature, not a bug.
- williamscales 9y agoNo, digital cameras map an incredible amount of functionality onto a limited amount of user interface (there's only so many buttons you can physically put on a camera). Snapchat takes an incredibly simple single function of taking a picture and sending it to a friend and renders it horribly complicated for no good reason.
- CaptainZapp 9y agoAdd to this that modern digital cameras have fantastic defaults. You can more or less click away like on a good old Kodak Instamatic while retaining full control of every aspect of your picture if you wish.
- havetocharge 9y agoTurning users away is a feature? Genuine question -- I really don't understand your point.
- narrowrail 9y agoThe idea, I believe, is building camaraderie among your users as they teach each other how to use it. IMO, Snapchat should be the easiest to decentralize and federate b/c the ephemeral nature allows expectations to be set for simple hosting like Digital Ocean. Who cares if data gets deleted?