7 ms·
Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory of Music (2014)
- michaf 9y agoThere is a newer version 2 from 2014: https://arxiv.org/html/1202.4212v2 https://arxiv.org/html/1202.4212v2
- sctb 9y agoThanks! We've updated the link from https://arxiv.org/html/1202.4212v1 https://arxiv.org/html/1202.4212v1.
- lyra_comms 9y agoReads as a working lit review (huge collection of ideas the author has come across) rather than a compact synthesis. Discuss on Lyra: https://hellolyra.com/c/382 https://hellolyra.com/c/382
- anigbrowl 9y agoYes. I've read this before, and if you go through it you see it's a less than half-baked theory where anything that doesn't fit isn is dismissed as degenerate music that people are wrong to like. It's egotistical to the point of self-parody. I'm really into the geometric structure of music but this guy isn't even half-way there. We did not take up rhythm in depth in this article, however I think it is quite likely that rhythm can be explained in a manner similar to harmony. - Wile E. Coyote, Super Genius Look, it's true that music theorists aren't scientists and the most innovative musicians are often terrible at explaining the underlying structures or musical strange attractors that shape what they do. I'm a terrible musician and I've been asking and groping towards a scientific theory of music for years. But at every music tech trade show, there are a couple of people like this guy showing off their automatic music composition system. They're very very proud of the theoretical abstractions they've been able to identify and automate, and they should be, it's impressive work. But the music is always terrible, boring stuff that doesn't evoke any emotion. And I say that as someone who listens to tons of techno and 'difficult' electronic music from artists like Autechre. Theory gives you a framework on which you can build your composition, where that's musical, paint or whatever. There is lots of bad art produced without such a framework that typically has a short half-life, and lots of bad art that merely decorates the framework and is thus pleasing but formulaic, also having a short half-life. Enduring art can develop and even comment upon the framework, but it's not primarily about the framework. The choice of subject is one of the most difficult and hard to teach or communicate aspects of art, and the problem with theoretical exegeses like this is that they attempt to eliminate the subjective altogether and thus kill the very thing that attracts people to art in the first place, the ability to project themselves into it.
- acjohnson55 9y agoWhat is Lyra?
- mrkgnao 9y agoFrom the homepage: > Lyra is a non-profit, non-invasive communication service which aims to enable deep and meaningful conversations. Seems like a Slack/wiki hybrid.
- stfwn 9y ago> You can't start a science textbook like that. 'Music theory books' make no claim to be scientific. Western music is a cultural construct and there are books that explain how to practice this particular field. For insiders, the three initial statements the author attempts to burn down make perfect sense. What it means to locate a (part of) a music piece in a 'harmonic system' makes just as much sense to musicians as the rest of us calling a lollypop 'sweet'. I wouldn't criticise cooks for not describing taste by the molecular contents of their ingredients. While it's interesting to dissect music differently from how musicians may analyse it, completely rejecting local experts' understanding of a phenomenon runs counter to finding out more. Is a farmer a complete fail whale for knowing when to plant his crops based on when a certain type of flower first blooms, rather than the precise position of the earth relative to the sun? If I would only read music theory by this author, I would still not have a clue how to play the piano. He/she wastes a lot of words on what could otherwise be described as the difference between Metis and Techne, or local knowledge and technical knowledge. I pasted two long quotes about the distinction between Metis and Techne here: https://pastebin.com/ZYKJDFRN https://pastebin.com/ZYKJDFRN
- metalliqaz 9y ago"fail whale", nice
- treehau5 9y ago> I wouldn't criticise cooks for not describing taste by the molecular contents of their ingredients. Now theres a good analogy.
- unholiness 9y agoBy "music theory books", I believe the author means "Literature which attempts to explain biologically why harmonies sound pleasant". My experience with this is that 1) Much of this literature is indeed in inside books which also discuss the "cookbook" parts of music theory, and 2) It's shocking how much incorrect, unscientific nonsense there is in these texts, and 3) There's nothing close to a scientific consensus about why humans and animals nearly universally feel good when hearing harmonious sounds. The author is attempting to answer that question, and I think his initial complaints are perfectly valid.
- jimsmart 9y agoDupe? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12085844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12085844
- laretluval 9y agoDoes this work address the fact that people raised in non-Western musical cultures don't experience pleasure/displeasure based on harmony? https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/07/your-culture-not-your-biology-shapes-your-musical-taste https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/07/your-culture-not-you...
- whiddershins 9y agoYes, well, sort of, and also perhaps you have a citation for your claim?
- theabacus 9y agoThe author is correct in saying that music theory is not a "theory" the scientific sense. But as a musician/producer/composer I'd never want that anyway. Having studied many forms of music, I know that there is no "right" and so a proscriptive/predictive "theory" of music is not at all what we want. On the contrary, what is "right" in music comes from a long line of collective cultural reasoning. This is much more evident in the distinctions between the development of eastern and western music, each having their own "theory". Notably, eastern music has a lot lower emphasis on harmonic progression and tends to use different tuning, sometimes "perfect" tuning (something which western music must eschew to support flexible harmonic motion). This leads me to my thesis, that music theory is primarily descriptive in nature and there are many theories of music, driven by historical-cultural development. Music "theory" should lie outside of the domain and concern of science. There are fields which address the human response and other scientific natures of this such as psychoacoustics, electrical engineering and signal processing, and mathematics. Music "theory" has in its view aesthetics which lie outside of the domain of science and is a tool for use in describing things which have been found pleasing aurally and culturally.
- _red 9y agoI think what many miss is that Music Theory is designed to be after the fact. It seeks to explain - after a piece has already been written - why something works harmonically / rhythmically / etc. It has no prescriptive power, it was never intended to be a set of formulas that can then be used to generate "good music". Only to create a language to explain whats already there...
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoso glad to hear someone else say this! i always feel compelled to point this out. fist bumps you
- rhizome 9y agoI think another aspect is that music theory is absolutely not required for appreciation nor composition.
- unholiness 9y agoThe author starts out by complaining that current music theory is not scientific. I completely agree. The field is astoundingly full of technical-seeming, well-accepted textbooks containing a biological "explanation" of harmony that is either totally unproven or trivially false. But then he precedes to dive into a mountain of unsubstantiated conjecture, saying: 1. Our brains are just computers 2. Evolution motivates less computation 3. Finding the fundamental frequency of a sound is worthwhile 4. Doing that is computationally easier if all other frequencies are in harmony 5. That is what has lead to harmony giving us pleasure (The rest is essentially fluff around this core argument) It's a nice theory, but there's nothing to substantively back up any of these points. He comes the closest on point #4, but only by making strong assumptions about the flavor of #1. The whole thrust of his argument is just totally tangential to addressing his initial complaints about the lack of science and rigor within the subject of biological harmony. - One thing he does get right is avoiding most common mistake that textbooks and laymen alike think about hearing: Our ears do not perceive the waveform of sound directly (for the most part[1]). Rather, we perceive sympathy vibrations at different parts our cochlea, rather directly sending nerve signals according to the Fourier transform of the original waveform. This can be measured (scientifically)! This Vi Hart video does a remarkably good job at giving a layman's tour of our some of the phenomena in our ears: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_0DXxNeaQ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_0DXxNeaQ0 [1] If this were totally true, we wouldn't be able to perceive phase at all! But it is the case that these sympathy vibrations are perceived with much more sensitivity than our perception of phase, and are linked more closely to peoples' idea of harmony.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoWe don't even perceive the Fourier transform. What we perceive is pre-processed by complex "sonic object" recognition systems we barely understand. Obvious example: you don't hear formants and spectral distributions when someone is speaking. You hear words, which are parsed into sentences, which are processed into meaning. Along the way a lot of redundant elements - background noises, breath sounds, ums and ahs, and even distortion from electronic transmission systems - are all eliminated. Music is similar but even more complicated, because while there are stylistic conventions, there doesn't seem to any single consistent grammar. There's a superficial listening level which parses a mix of sounds into the sounds of different instruments, a "theory" level which listens for horizontal and vertical groupings and structures, an "emotional" level which reacts to implied emotion and mood, and sometimes a "metaphorical" level which listens poetically and associatively. It's not a simple process.
- acjohnson55 9y agoI don't have time to thoroughly read this before commenting, but upon scanning it, I echo the disdain of many of the other commenters. The lack of humility seems to reflect the lack of important prior work cited in the paper. Most glaringly, the author assaults Helmholtz without acknowledging the fact that people who study this topic in academia are way past that. It's like if I were to tell you that I've got an amazing new theory of physics and justify it by referencing Newtonian mechanics -- every academic knew it to be incomplete a century ago. Pointing that out is not a novel idea. If you're interested in understanding how music works on a psychological level, "music theory" is the wrong thing to search for. The fields you're interested in are psychoacoustics and music perception. Music theory is the study of compositional practice. It's a field that collects a whole bunch of descriptive theories on how composers in different periods and genres tend to work. You can use it to help yourself compose pieces in a given paradigm. Psychoacoustics and music perception are the study of how we actually understand sound and music. The theories therein are what gave us things like lossy compression (e.g. "exactly what raw sound data can we discard and still preserve a perceptually identical recording?"). This is an incredible achievement in that it only works if we have a thorough understanding of how the brain processes sound and music. Psychoacoustics has little to say about what makes something qualitatively musical, but that's where study of music perception picks up. In the overlap between these two fields, there are a bunch of people working on unified theories of harmonic/Western/tonal music. The author fails to reference the most interesting work done in this area. The ones I've found most convincing are: - Dmitri Tymoczko's Geometry of Music: http://dmitri.tymoczko.com/geometry-of-music.html http://dmitri.tymoczko.com/geometry-of-music.html - Bill Sethares's Tuning Timbre Spectrum Scale approach: http://sethares.engr.wisc.edu/ttss.html http://sethares.engr.wisc.edu/ttss.html - Andrew Duncan's Combinatorial Music Theory: http://andrewduncan.net/cmt/ http://andrewduncan.net/cmt/ Some of this work is pretty old at this point. Granted, it's surprisingly difficult to do a full literature review in this area. I know from experience, because I studied this topic in grad school. Someone could probably earn a Ph.D. by properly synthesizing all of these idea into a music theory that combines the analytical power of Tymoczko's approach with the first-principle work of Setheres.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agogreat post. drawing the distinction between music perception, music theory and psychoacoustics is very helpful for me. i just finished writing a kind of dumb rant about this article, and your post seems to address some of my complaints perfectly. thanks!
- kaonashi 9y agoMusic is language. Music 'theory' is somewhat akin to linguistics (or language subjects). It can help you dissect and understand how things work in an abstract sense, but when it comes to actually talking (or playing music), you're operating in a different mindset. The people who rely on music theory are non-experts in the same way that the people who rely on language class to speak are non-native speakers.
- rhizome 9y agoMusic is like a language, but unlike languages you don't need to be familiar with it in order to understand it.
- kaonashi 9y agoThat depends entirely on the level of understanding. Recognizing the harmony underneath a line isn't something a casual listener is going to do, but is essential for a musician who is trying to communicate with other musicians in real-time.
- rhizome 9y agoRecognizing the harmony underneath a line isn't something a casual listener is going to do, but is essential for a musician who is trying to communicate with other musicians in real-time My point is that none of that is essential to recognizing it as music and getting meaning from it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pjdorrell 9y agoMusic is not language and it is not "a language". It is something that _seems_ like language. This is because music has evolved as a mutated copy of part of the human language acquisition instinct. The mood change caused by music is a mutated copy of the mood change that accompanies initial language acquisition, and it serves a different purpose. The mood change that accompanies initial language acquisition helps to focus the infant's mind on language as a separate important thing that has its own (somewhat arbitrary) rules that need to be understood separately from everything else. The mood change that accompanies music serves to intensify emotions that accompany daydreaming - this helps us to "better" daydream, in a manner that does not cause us to confuse daydreamed emotions with real emotions (because we are always consciously aware that the mood change is directly caused by listening to music). (More details at http://whatismusic.info/. http://whatismusic.info/.)
- the_cat_kittles 9y agohey guess what, western classical harmony that bach kind of codified, is but one harmonic system. its accidentally super arrogant to ignore the insanely deep musical traditions that are not present in western classical music, since they have different ideas about harmony. one of the great things about music is that it has really opened my eyes to this kind of of cultural myopia. its so obviously implicit in pretentious analyses like these, even if their content is interesting and correct, that the writers believe that western music is the real music. its trained into alot of us that that is the case. well, its not. its not superior, nor inferior. someone is going to read this and think im being an sjw, but i assure you! i once implicitly thought this way too, but i studied other music besides my first love, which was the music of bach, and its true! the musical traditions of roma people, indian classical music, american jazz, bluegrass, flamenco, romanian folk music, turkish music (just whatever is coming to me in this moment) etc etc these things are so deep, and have such rich traditions of insane dedication. so, dispose of this idea that bach's music is the only real music. the same kind of weird cultural narcissism / racism / whatever it is happens in language, with "correct" usage of words. its the same damn thing. and can i just add, for all the overly left brained harmonic analysers out there- it would be nice to see someone address the fact that harmony, even in the restricted western classical sense, i guess "diatonic", depends greatly on timbre and range as well. of course i didnt read this paper, and instead ranted somewhat incoherently about topics which might not even apply to the paper, but hey, i had a good time!
- phlakaton 9y agoThe author did attempt to address this, by complaining that you "aren't really paying attention": * He notes that octaves are common across cultures (per Levitin, "This is Your Brain On Music") * He asserts that 12 tones represent a practical limit to harmony; more than 12 tones is more complex than the brain can handle in its "note-expectation engine". * He thinks other cultures could be working within his theory, but simply not taking advantage of _all_ of the universal harmonic features that Western music offers. He cites pentatonic scales as an example. * He is baffled by the Nasca Indians of Peru, who apparently form their pitches by linear steps in frequency rather than logarithmic (I won't even attempt to use the word "harmony" in this sense), but he asserts that 1) their tuning system was probably derived because it was mechanically easier to produce a set of pipes to that tuning system, 2) they're a weird case because they were isolated. * To finish that reasoning off, he suggests there's a "musical sophistication" of a culture which develops from linear scales (easy to carve) on the simple end to equal temperament on the sophisticated side (because arbitrary key changes without wolf intervals is the ne plus ultra, right?). So, yeah: I'd say there's some serious cultural narcissism going on. It would be OK if he confined his analysis to Western harmony and simply tried to explain what was going on there, but by trying to derive universal musical principles from barbershop quartets, his project was pretty much doomed from the get-go. :-)
- mtdewcmu 9y agoI came up with something of a theory of rhythm. I don't know anything about music theory, so, for all I know, the theory is not new or a better theory already exists. But it's simple, so I'll share the main idea. I think that rhythms are perceived like echos. So, in 4/4 time with beats on quarter notes, beat #2 is an echo of beat #1 (the main beat), beat #3 is an echo of beat #2, and beat #4 is an echo of beat #3. Then, the main beat sounds again and the whole thing repeats. Now, if that makes sense, you can forget about echos. What matters is that there is a chain of causation. The listener perceives that Beat #1 causes beat #2, which causes beat #3, and so on. The listener unconsciously creats a theory of causation that explains the rhythm. Now set aside music for a second. Imagine that you hear a sequence of sounds: 1. "Oops!" 2. (Crash!) 3. (Baby crying) Since they occur together, they are perceived as being causally related. Now, back to music. Within each repeating unit (usually a measure), the listener always has a working theory of causation to explain the rhythm. The theory has the form of a tree, with child nodes caused by the parent node. When rhythms mutate over time, the change will sound small if the change only affects a leaf. The change will sound bigger if the change affects a complete branch. And, the change will sound jarring if it violates the theory of causation, i.e. by removing the cause without removing the effect. Multiple rhythms can be superposed over each other, so the theory of causation can be a tree with multiple branches. For ex.: Main beat -> rhythm1 AND ALSO Main beat -> rhythm2. If rhythm2 is added to rhythm1 after rhythm1 has been playing already, rhythm2 is perceived as a distinct chain, which is caused by the main beat. Hence, rhythm2 can be removed as a unit without violating causation.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoive tried reading this a couple times now. im not sure what you are trying to explain. it almost reads like a markov chain.
- mtdewcmu 9y agoIt's not really a Markov chain, because Markov chains are random. It could be a degenerate Markov chain where probabilities are either 1 or 0, so that the same pattern repeats over and over. The pattern can change, say, every 4 bars. Then you are manipulating the chain.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoFor a more professional and thoughtful look at music and combinatorial math I suggest: http://dmitri.mycpanel.princeton.edu/geometry-of-music.html http://dmitri.mycpanel.princeton.edu/geometry-of-music.html There's also https://www.amazon.co.uk/Topos-Music-Geometric-Concepts-Performance/dp/3764357312 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Topos-Music-Geometric-Concepts-Perf... Although IMO it's mostly blather - unlike Tymoczko, who's worth reading. There are no complete scientific theories of music and there never will be, because music is a huge and semi-random collection of cultural experiments and stylistic conventions built only very loosely on perceptual psychology. Academic theory books define an alphabet of terms, but the rest is learned by practice and experiment, oral teaching, and by listening, copying, and varying.
- elihu 9y ago> There are no complete scientific theories of music and there never will be, because music is a huge and semi-random collection of cultural experiments and stylistic conventions built only very loosely on perceptual psychology. You could say much the same thing about architecture. In that domain, I find Christopher Alexander's book A Pattern Language to be a very good reference for describing many concrete reasons why certain buildings feel better than others that seem to be pretty universal. (And we could reasonably expect to be able to test that if we were in doubt.) It's not a complete theory of architecture and can't be, but partial theories are still tremendously useful and more likely to produce good results than blindly following stylistic rules without knowing what purpose they serve. I've been hoping for awhile that someone will write a good music theory book in the same format.
- jancsika 9y agoDoes the author acknowledge the field of music cognition, and that it is a scientific field that produces verifiable/falsifiable results?
- slaymaker1907 9y agoI think a key challenge with music theory is that it is tackling some of the same problems as in linguistics. You have a somewhat formal system that follows some sort of methodology. However, while there is a system, it seems nearly impossible to actually describe the axioms of this system formally. With language or music, how do you determine some bases from which all other concepts are composed? I suspect that there is probably no such bases since new concepts seem to be able to be spontaneously created from human experience and often have circular relations.
- xamuel 9y agoAuthors who claim to understand music scientifically should be judged by the music they produce. If an author really does have some deep understanding of what makes music work, it should be fairly easy for the author to get a record deal, get a bunch of #1 pop hits, etc. Until then, it's alchemy.