9 ms·
The financial crisis of 2008 really shattered my world view. Until then I thought there was a free market where the companies that do good business survive. Sin
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The financial crisis of 2008 really shattered my world view. Until then I thought there was a free market where the companies that do good business survive. Since then you almost hear every week how banks do stuff that would have killed pretty much any other company but banks get away with it. This is just unbelievable.
- lettergram 9y agoThat's what happens when you centralize banking...
- bobabooey02 9y agoNah, it's just the nature of capitalism. Industries that require a large amount of startup capital lead to natural monopolies or duopolies. Those who cheat, skirt the law, or lobby to make getting into the industry harder do better than those who follow the spirit of the law. Board of directors exist not to create a balanced society, but to maximize returns on investment for owners and shareholders, and so will always behave as sociopathically as they can get away with. The government is supposed to regulate those industries, but because they buy off the government in the US, the duopoly-forming pressures continue unabated.
- Chaebixi 9y ago>> That's what happens when you centralize banking... > Nah, it's just the nature of capitalism. Industries that require a large amount of startup capital lead to natural monopolies or duopolies. But is that true of banking? The nation has a long history of small banks. While they've had their crises too, I don't think there's any natural motivation for bank consolidation besides using scale to eek out efficiencies and to gain power and influence.
- bobabooey02 9y ago> I don't think there's any natural motivation for bank consolidation besides using scale to eek out efficiencies and to gain power and influence. Motivation has nothing to do with it. The development of power and influence through asymmetric growth in the industry is enough for this to emerge. There are still small banks today, but it's no coincidence that the largest (and thus overall best performing) banks cheat the system. The best performing become large and powerful on their own.
- Chaebixi 9y agoBut your assertion was that banking is an "industr[y] that require[s] a large amount of startup capital" such that it will "lead to natural monopolies or duopolies." The fact that you can have a small, profitable bank disproves that.
- bobabooey02 9y agoTwo things here: Capital is more than just money. It takes a lot to jump through the regulatory hoops, money requirements, and insurance costs while having competitive prices against other Banks and still make a profit. Even if it was just a money issue, new banks do still require a fair amount of money for relatively little profit in an industry that is well established. If someone is going to put their capital on the line, why wouldn't they put it in a higher growth industry? These don't make new bank creation impossible, just unlikely.
- zo1 9y agoIn the same thread you state "Nah, it's just the nature of capitalism. Industries that require a large amount of startup capital lead to natural monopolies or duopolies" as the cause of centralization of the banks. Then you go on and explain where the high-capital cost actually comes from: "It takes a lot to jump through the regulatory hoops, money requirements, and insurance costs while having competitive prices against other Banks and still make a profit." And yet you still blame capitalism?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI don't understand your point. I think it's apparent to almost anyone that you need a fair amount of startup capital to start a bank. And when you go on to say: >I don't think there's any natural motivation for bank consolidation besides using scale to eek out efficiencies and to gain power and influence. Are efficiencies and power-seeking somehow not enough? I mean let's look at Standard Oil. What did Rockefeller do other than eek out efficiencies and try to gain power and influence? Efficiences are what defines a natural monopoly, we can't just throw it out.
- pavpanchekha 9y agoStandard Oil is an interesting case. One of the things that made SO such a powerful monopoly (among many other things; I'm focusing only on business structure here) was the infrastructure it built up for transporting, refining, and selling oil. That is very capital-intensive, a situation a bit like (say) Comcast, whose businesses is protected by the large investments a competitor might need to make in laying fiber. A good comparison might be shale oil companies, which largely are pretty small; Chesapeake, one of the most famous, has a market cap of 4.3B (so about the size of a tech unicorn). Shale oil companies, of course, are largely using oil and gas infrastructure built by years ago, so there isn't a competitive advantage keeping large companies afloat. I think the parent is asking which of these examples banks are more like. Is there some sort of hidden infrastructure banks need to build before they're competitive—a total position database, or operating licenses in a bunch of markets, or an algorithmic trading platform—or can small banks largely compete with bigger banks? Like SO or CHK?
- notfromhere 9y agoSmall banks existed because anti-trust laws were enforced. After Reagan, anti-trust stopped looking at market share and only cared about consumer prices. Hence why we've seen a huge consolidation of capital resources in large firms and cities, because that's where the economies of scale are.
- cmurf 9y agoLocality is one aspect that helps incentivize a bank being a "good local citizen". Another might be a "benefit corporation" which is a kind of entity that can be created in 30 states. I'm not aware of any state dissolution of corporations or shareholder lawsuits to enforce such articles of incorporation. But at least in theory, the reason why a corporation is "for profit" or "not for profit" is because it's in their articles of incorporation, so any other purpose for the corporation set out ought to be enforcible as long as it's not vague nonsense. For example "make some people happy" might mean you can be an dick company, but if you make a really slick iphone app that people "like" then you've complied? This is something ethical startup founders would have to write into the articles of incorporation to bind future board of directors even once the founders aren't majority shareholders, is how I understand it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoMost people don't price check banking like they do e.g. groceries or mobile-phone plans. This is why Chase can pay a pittance of interest and charge for using others' ATMs while e.g. Ally pays 10 to 60 basis points on their checking account [1] while re-imbursing the ATM fees other ATM providers assess. [1] https://www.ally.com/bank/interest-checking-account/ https://www.ally.com/bank/interest-checking-account/
- bluGill 9y agoMost people don't have enough in bank accounts for it to matter. People do tend to price check loans rates. Those who keep more money in their bank account will price check CDs, but for a checking/savings account you are probably looking at around $20 a year if you find the best account - having a local bank close by is worth more than that.
- djohnston 9y agoI switched from BOA to ALLY for the satisfaction of asking BOA if they could give me 100X better interest rate.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoAnd how did they respond?
- djohnston 9y agoA surprisingly succinct "No."
- jdmichal 9y agoSo for the cost of keeping $15000 stuck in a checking account for say 10 years, you get a whopping $927.31. You'd get more money back dropping that into a high-efficiency AC system or solar panels. Meanwhile, most people don't even have $15000 lying around with nothing else to do. My understanding from surveys done by various companies is that 60% of Americans don't even have $1000 in savings. And those with beaucoup money are negotiating their own loan rates, because there's better places to park their money for long-term interest.
- refurb 9y agoBusinesses are run by human beings. Of course they take shortcuts and try and screw people over. Not sure that would really change regardless of the system we're under.
- castis 9y agoIts the perception we're talking about here. Not everyone starts out jaded.
- rndmwlk 9y ago"The forces interested in keeping a large company afloat, he argue, are far greater than those that wish to see it perish. He'd present the students with the following hypothetical situation. First, he'd say, let's locate our major factory in an earthquake zone. Then let's infuriate unions by paying executives large sums of money while cutting wages. Third, let's select a company on the brink of bankruptcy to supply us with an essential irreplaceable component in our production line. And fourth, just in case our government is tempted to bail us out when we get into trouble, let's bribe a few indiscreet foreign officials. That, Milken would conclude, is precisely what Lockheed had done in the late 1970s." This isn't something localized to banks. (The quote is from Liar's Poker, a really enjoyable read IMO)
- netcan 9y agoI had a related comment on another thread earlier today. Different context, similar point. "Free Market" is a big hairy term. But, the definition of free market that includes (or expects) all the emergent benefits attributed to free market is limited to a certain realm. Markets with barriers to entry (emergent or regulated, high fixed/marginal costs, any structure that lends to oligopoly, financialization, and bunch of other market characteristics (including interventionist policy) result in markets that are not free in that sense. There is no creative destruction, highly competitive dyanamics and such. The financial markets have never (and IMO will never) resemble the market for toiletries or music festivals. Neither will many other markets: transport infrastructure, for example, for different reasons. The free market is an abstract concept, a model. It explains some markets better than others.
- dforrestwilson1 9y agoThis. The real irony about the banks is that by heavily regulating banks and explicitly backing them, we also implicitly allow this sort of abusive behavior towards customers.
- Finnucane 9y agoWell, no, because the problem is not the regulation, but the lack of enforcement of the regulation. And that happens because the political appointees who runt the agencies are too close to the banks they are supposed to be monitoring. If Wells is making changes to the loans without properly getting the court's approval, that's fraud on the court and clearly illegal. Getting a criminal proceeding against Wells or any of its employees requires the DoJ to agree to take action, which seems highly unlikely. During the fallout from the housing bubble, it became apparent that many loans had not been properly transferred as they were sold from one investor to the next. The result of this was that many foreclosures were brought with essentially forged papers--servicers worked overtime trying to cover up broken paper trails. The courts in some states, esp. Florida, looked the other way as this bogus paper was passed in front of them.
- scarmig 9y ago
- payne92 9y agoFree markets work really well…except when there is fraud. No economic system works when people don't follow the rules. And the only way to manage that is to make sure the expected value of the fraud is significantly lower (ideally greatly negative) than the gains from the fraud. That means that the chances of getting caught times the costs of getting caught need to be quite high.
- specialist 9y agoFreedom Markets™ don't have rules.
- talmand 9y agoFree market doesn't necessarily mean anarchy market.
- krapp 9y agoA free market is commonly defined as one in which competition is unrestricted by anything but the natural forces of the market itself - voluntary contracts and supply and demand. A market which recognizes the legitimacy of government to regulate it must restrict competition to whatever that government declares legal, and as such any such market cannot be considered free. A free market, like free speech, must be anarchist, or in the weak case, must tend towards anarchy.
- specialist 9y agoOpen market means balancing capitalism vs democracy. Property rights, fair and impartial judiciary, regulations to promote competition, and so forth. Whereas free market means might makes right. AKA feudalism, corporatism, kleptocracy, neo-reactionary, fantasy land, etc. Basically whatever nonsense the Heritage Foundation stooges are paid to peddle. Even though I grew up listening to the Sex Pistols, I still have no idea what anarchy is, idealized or not. I just assume its more Lord of the Flies than some hippy free love commune.
- conanbatt 9y agoI felt unscathed in this regard, considering banks are so intertwined with government. In an organic way, it might have been better to let the banks fail hard in 2008, that would hve served as a cautionary tale to bank managers/owners not to rely on the state. On the other hand, that could have had tremendous economic short-term consequences. The problem is not that banks mismanaged and failed, but that the consequences of it were too grave to allow failure.
- curun1r 9y agoEven some of the legal stuff that Wells Fargo does boggles the mind. My parents had a Wells Fargo mortgage. It's now been sold twice and I've had to setup automatic monthly payments for them each time. I live in fear of two things... First, some enterprising fraudster will call/mail that they've acquired the loan and demand payment. Given how often loans are sold, it wouldn't take much conning to convince retirees that a payment is due and a check needs to be mailed to some P.O. Box. Second, these companies that buy up loans don't seem all that technically capable. I fear that, one day, my parents' loan will be bought by one without an automatic monthly payment system. Again, someone with shady morals could start a company that looks to buy mortgages on properties where the mortgage is a fraction of the cost of the home and then not offer a auto-pay feature. When people inevitably miss a couple of manual payments, they could aggressively try to foreclose. Both of these opportunities for abuse are made possible by banks with mostly positive reputations doing something that shouldn't be allowed. If a bank wants to offload debt that they've initiated, we should require them to continue to process customer payments on that debt and forward the money to whomever they sold to. Consumers should have the right to choose which companies they have business relationships with and we shouldn't have that relationship changed without our permission.
- yardie 9y agoMy bank, when it can't send payment through ACH, will cut and mail a papercheck to the address on record.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBut when happens if the mortgage services doesn't process that payment and you begin to incur late fees and head towards preforeclosure through no fault of your own?
- yardie 9y agoYou send it certified. Then fax them and their lawyer a copy of the air bill and say see you in court. Trust me, slumlords pull this shit everyday with renters.
- jpster 9y agoThe former attorney general Eric Holder basically admitted that some banks are too big to face any criminal charges they might deserve. So expect the crimes to continue. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/holder-concerned-megabanks-too-big-to-jail/2013/03/06/6fa2b07a-869e-11e2-999e-5f8e0410cb9d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/holder-conce...
- talmand 9y agoI've always felt the "too big to fail" is an excuse that covers for something else.
- ashark 9y agoIIRC 3-4 years after the financial crisis NPR ran a story the premise of which was basically "WTF is up with major white collar crime seemingly never being punished?" and they claimed the FBI's division devoted to financial crimes had been gutted to devote more resources to fighting terrorism after 2001, and that those resources had simply never been restored, leaving them only able to pursue a couple major cases at a time. Since these sorts of investigations/cases are against people and organizations with money and the laws in question are often nuanced and complex, the cases drag on for months to years. IOW as long as a dozen plus major violations are occurring every year they'll only be able to pursue a few percent of them, and only some smaller percentage will end in more than a slap on the wrist (because, again, these people have money). If that's true then ROI on corporate law-breaking is great right now, as long as you're not one of the one or two most egregious cases any given year.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's just nuts. He pretty much officially declared that some institutions are beyond the rule of law. That's simply not acceptable.
- fredgrott 9y agowait til you hear this.. There was a study recommendation to regulate unregulated securities and take them away from investment banks..Guess what Goldman Sacs in Trump admin is thee to do? Resist that recommendation