5 ms·
This is awesome. Every other assistant AI type product seems to be designed primarily as a pretext for invading its users' privacy. Thanks for building somethin
by taneq 9y ago
This is awesome. Every other assistant AI type product seems to be designed primarily as a pretext for invading its users' privacy. Thanks for building something that might be both useful and trustworthy at the same time!
- oulipo 9y agoThanks! And we take privacy very seriously, as should most companies now because the people will ask for this in the future. No reason Google should know what you ask your Voice Assistant to buy, or to remind you of!
- _jal 9y agoDitto. I still have no idea if I'm actually interested in voice UI, but I'd actually experiment with this one, unlike any existing implementation. Edit - any other existing implementation.
- natch 9y agoYou should take a look at what Apple is doing if you think that. Especially the developments announced last week. Going forward I would expect to see a vast number of products on that platform both from Apple, and from third party developers, that are doing on-device and privacy-focused implementations of AI applications.
- oulipo 9y agoAt Snips we are serious about privacy and happy to see so many people taking it as seriously as us!
- natch 9y agoI'm sure Apple is happy to see you join their long existing efforts to support user privacy.
- CaptSpify 9y agoWithout source code that seems like all smoke and mirrors to me. I'd love it if they released it, and I'd start buying their stuff immediately. But until they put their money where there mouth is... meh
- natch 9y agoNo need to be snide about it. Of course they aren't going to open source the entire OS. Just like Google hasn't open sourced all of Android. They always hold something back. And you're commenting on an article where the maintainer has said that open source is "coming in the future." In the meantime: https://opensource.apple.com https://opensource.apple.com https://github.com/apple https://github.com/apple http://llvm.org http://llvm.org https://swift.org https://swift.org https://developer.apple.com/opensource/ https://developer.apple.com/opensource/ I think it's safe to say they are betting the company on this, and putting plenty of money into it. And far from being smoke and mirrors vaporware, this is hardware and software that you can hold in your hand and use and rely on, and millions of people do, every day.
- CaptSpify 9y agoI'm not sure how my comment is "snide". It's just a fact: I don't trust them. And I don't see how Google is relevant to the conversation. They don't release source, so I'm not really interested in their products either. Just because one company is does things in a way I don't like doesn't mean I have to accept it when others do it that way. "coming in the future" is nice, but I've heard that speech before, and I'm not holding my breath. If they are betting the company on this, then great! I'll put a lot of money into their products. But until they do, meh, I'm not interested. And by smoke and mirrors I don't mean vapor-ware, I mean distracting from the real issues, and hiding their flaws instead of fixing them.
- natch 9y agoWell, you are making assumptions from ignorance. You don't have to hold your breath. I gave you the links. The open source is already there. Breathe. And you seriously think Apple is not fixing flaws? Watch their WWDC sessions. They have fixed tons of flaws. Your hate is showing through. Maybe set aside your feelings once in a while and look at the facts.
- taneq 9y agoDo you have a good link for technical info? I found the Wired article but all that says is: > The HomePod uses local recognition to hear the Hey Siri command, and encrypts all your communication. That's great as far as it goes (at least it's not streaming all audio) but it doesn't rule out the rest of the command from being sent upstream, and encryption just stops third parties from intercepting it - if I don't want the vendor listening in either, it doesn't really solve my problem. Happy to be proven wrong by some more in-depth info from Apple though!