3 ms·
What counts as "open source"? We often run (open-source) Linux on a (closed-source) Intel processor and even a lot of diehard FOSS warriors are okay with that.
by dheera 9y ago
What counts as "open source"?
We often run (open-source) Linux on a (closed-source) Intel processor and even a lot of diehard FOSS warriors are okay with that.
Arduino Unos are a bunch of (open-source) wiring and components plugged into a (closed-source) Atmel microcontroller and people seemed to be okay with that.
How does an ESP8266 differ from an ATMega in this regard? If we consider it a basic component just like the ATMega, it's not particularly any different.
- bildung 9y agoAccording to the mail, this is about board schematics and source code for pre-burned firmware.
- madez 9y agoI'm certainly not okay with having to use a closed processor to run my software. I'm longing for an alternative. Hopefully RISC-V will show some buyable results.
- jononor 9y agoThe ability to do a custom board with the microcontroller and your custom peripherals is key for doing a production run. Open source lisenced source files for the board makes this very easy. The times where making custom silicon is desirable is way more rare. But hopefully open-source will be standard there too, one day.
- thearn4 9y agoMy comment was less about FOSS actually. I think it has more to do with the branding of Arduino. When people think educational or approachable microcontrollers, they think Arduino. As soon as that gets muddied a bit, I think folks may see that there are much better alternatives, and will shift to that.
- chillingeffect 9y agoThis question comes up a lot. It doesn't mean "open source all the way to the materials mined." It means "open source to what I used to produce this.* Such that another person could replicate your work.
- dheera 9y agoSure. But just like one could source an ATMega, one could source an ESP8266 and replicate the work. It's an easily-available drop-in component. So I don't actually see anything inherently different about the new crop of Arduinos from what we had before.