4 ms·
And this is based on what, exactly ? If you're going to make hyperbolic statements maybe some clarifications would be useful.
by threeseed 9y ago
And this is based on what, exactly ?
If you're going to make hyperbolic statements maybe some clarifications would be useful.
- clouddrover 9y ago> And this is based on what, exactly ? The NSA developed the exploits that WannaCry was based on. The NSA lost control of its weapon (EternalBlue) in the Shadow Brokers leak and the world suffered economic damage as a consequence. The NSA doesn't seem interested in switching to a more defensive role where they will inform software makers of the security problems they find. Instead they seem intent on maintaining offensive capability by seeking out, cataloging, exploiting, weaponizing, and keeping silent about the software security flaws they discover.
- jonnybgood 9y agoTo be fair, the NSA was never given the mission to take on that defensive role you state. Their mission includes the defense of classified systems. Defense of any other systems is not their responsibility. The offensive capability you state is part of their mission and is what NSA was created for.
- clouddrover 9y ago> The NSA was never given the mission to take on that defensive role you state. It's both. James Clapper (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Clapper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Clapper), former director of national intelligence, says the NSA has a review process to decide whether or not to disclose vulnerabilities to software vendors. Nothing in their mission prevents them from doing it. They're choosing not to do it. Look at the slogan on the NSA's website (https://www.nsa.gov/ https://www.nsa.gov/): "Defending our Nation. Securing the Future". It's difficult to say with a straight face that they are defending the nation when they are willingly leaving domestic networks open to attack from zero days. The NSA says (https://www.nsa.gov/what-we-do/ https://www.nsa.gov/what-we-do/) national decision makers "Must be able to outmaneuver those who would do us harm in cyberspace." How are you outmaneuvering anyone when you allow systems to remain open to harm?
- anigbrowl 9y agoStrategically there is sometimes advantage in not letting the enemy know what you know (how you define enemy is another question, but it's reasonable to observe that we have antagonistic relationships with some countries). The alternative is a siege mentality. If you systematically throw up defences ASAP every time you discover a vulnerability, and an enemy discovers a vulnerability but does observe any defensive preparations, the enemy now knows that they have an operational advantage over you and is incentivized to deploy it for maximum effect. Obviously this is only a thumbnail sketch rather than an exhaustive exploration of strategy. But it's a subject I read and think about a good deal. Pretty much every military thinker through history has emphasized the value of surprise and the ability to set the tempo of battle.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI just noticed that the last sentence in the first paragraph above should read "but does not observe any defensive preparations". sorry about that.
- bo1024 9y agoMaybe credibility is not the best choice of word, but you could make an argument for "trustworthiness". In other words, the question is not so much the NSA's competence as their good intentions.