4 ms·
Your dismissal of the problem with forks is missing a big danger to users. You say that market forces will control it, and people should just use what works bes
by cortesoft 9y ago
Your dismissal of the problem with forks is missing a big danger to users. You say that market forces will control it, and people should just use what works best for them.
The problem is that you might guess wrong; you might look at the two forks, make your best guess as to which side is going to win out via the network effect, and put your money there. If you are wrong, and your fork dies out, there goes all your money. The market forces did their thing, and they wiped you out.
Yes, the 'users' are the ones who decide how the system develops, but that doesn't mean you as an individual user have any say; your voice will be overwhelmed by the crowd.
Of course, these risks aren't any different from the risks we face in the rest of the world. You can lose money by making the wrong choices, and your choices often get forced because of the decision of the crowd. However, we don't really face that risk using a stable national currency BECAUSE of the very things bitcoin fans tout as reasons to use bitcoin.
The reason using a currency like the US dollar is so popular is BECAUSE of the fact that the government forces everyone to accept the currency 'for all debts, public and private'. People are FORCED to accept the currency, so you can have confidence that you aren't going to be left with useless money if you accept dollars in payment. You don't have to worry about some other currency winning out as the defacto payment system, and losing all your wealth.
Of course, you have to put faith in the US government to maintain the currency, but it has a pretty strong track record of doing a fairly good job at that. I can't imagine a cryptocurrency every being able to be as stable as the dollar for hundreds of years; I mean, just look at the price volatility for bitcoins.
- zilchers 9y agoYa, I was going to point out there's a lot of faith with normal currency too - I think bitcoin still is a grand experiment. So far, when there have been forks, a winner has emerged very quickly (see Ethereum), but the UASF is going to be an interesting test of this. I think it's in everyone's interest for the decision to happen quickly and stay sticky though, so it's hard to imagine a drawn out fork battle, but could be interesting. Also interesting, I suppose we're incentivized to get in before any forks, wonder if any of the run lately could be attributed to that.
- Taek 9y agoForks tend not to die out. See ethereum classic. As long as people are using the currency that you use, your currency will have value. Also, if your currency is losing traction, the value will decrease gradually, not evaporate to zero all at once. Well, highly speculative currencies can tumble dramatically, but as we've seen with Bitcoin, as the legitimate use cases grow, so to does the price stability.
- cortesoft 9y agoThe idea that a currency will never decrease at such a rapid rate is a bit naive. There is nothing so fundamentally different from bitcoin that it is immune to panics and a 'bank run'. If a panic starts, and people are trying to pull their money out, you could have the same effect as a bank run, as the transaction rate becomes higher and higher (the digital equivalent of a line at the bank). Bitcoin may or may not stay stable, but you can't know that any more than you can know it about any other currency, with the additional caveat that there is no central authority with a track record to base your decision on.
- snowwrestler 9y agoYou have to put your faith in something. I suppose it's not surprising that people with strong affinities for computing systems would rather put their trust in a computing system than a government of people. They understand computing, and so they feel more confident they can understand and mitigate its risks. They might not feel that way about the solvency of the Federal Reserve, or the fiscal health of the U.S. federal government. It doesn't mean they're right. Blockchains might be objectively riskier than central banking. It's just that we each see the world through the filter of our own experience.
- cortesoft 9y agoThe entire point of the article is that it might FEEL like you are putting faith in a computing system when you use bitcoin, but really you are still putting your faith in a group of people. It doesn't matter how well you understand the mechanics of how bitcoin works, what really matters is the mechanics of how the people involved with bitcoin works, and that is the same as people everywhere. You just can't escape human social politics.
- snowwrestler 9y agoI agree, and I think the article is essentially right. But again, not everyone is going to see it that way, depending on their inclination.