3 ms·
" Why are collective agreements intrinsically bad?" Because I should be able to do what I want, instead of being forced to go along with whatever stupid ideas
by stale2002 9y ago
" Why are collective agreements intrinsically bad?"
Because I should be able to do what I want, instead of being forced to go along with whatever stupid ideas the union chooses to do. It is called freedom of choice.
What if I want to negotiate for myself?
What if I want to wear multiple hats?
What if I want to work without getting a BS certification?
If I negotiate, and convince someone to hire me, then I can get all of these things.
We can agree and disagree about what makes a work environment good or bad. And thats fine. Just you do your thing, and I will do mine. If you don't like these things, then you can try to get a job that doesn't make you do them.
My relationship should be between me and my employer. I will negotiate all the things that I mentioned, and if the situation doesn't work out then I will vote with my feet and go somewhere else. Do not take away my right to free association.
Sure, fine, if you don't like doing those things, then you are free to join your own private organization and decide for yourself on how to do collective bargaining, and all that.
The problem with pro-union people is that they assume that their needs are the same as everyone else's needs. Different people want different things, and this whole "fight for the people" BS gets thrown out the window the moment you try and force me to join your org and force me to go along with stuff I don't agree with.
"And, of course, if you really don't want to work for a unionized workplace you can go and work at a non-unionized workplace."
Well, instead of doing this thing, I could just use the law to protect me. Forcing people to join unions is, thankfully, illegal in many states.
And, thankfully, unions are very unpopular among techies. So I am doing precisely that, and I will continue to fight against them in tech, precisely because I do not want our industry to be turned into one that does not value freedom of choice among employees, and forces different people into associations that they don't agree with.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Sure, fine, if you don't like doing those things, then you are free to join your own private organization and decide for yourself on how to do collective bargaining, and all that. I'm struggling to see what your problem is. If you don't like the idea of democratic control over your workplace and the commensurately higher pay that goes with it you've always been free to go and work somewhere else where they let you "wear many hats". It seems more like that you want to prevent others from doing it: >Forcing people to join unions is, thankfully, illegal in many states. i.e. you're thankful groups of people who negotiate with other groups of people and form voluntary agreements are prevented from doing so.
- stale2002 9y agoNo, others can do all those things all they want. They can get together with their groups of friends and bargain collectively. They just shouldn't be able to force me to bargain collectively along with them. They can get together and form voluntary agreements. They just can't make me join their voluntary agreements or stop me from making my own agreements with anyone. And we can see who gets the better deal.