6 ms·
"If you're in marketing or advertising" The government should apply a significant "sin tax" to advertising. Advertising imposes huge external costs on societ
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
"If you're in marketing or advertising"
The government should apply a significant "sin tax" to advertising. Advertising imposes huge external costs on society that aren't borne by the advertiser; a sin tax would help to properly align the incentives.
And it really wouldn't hurt the advertisers very much -- if advertising became more expensive they'd do less of it, but so would their competitors, making the ads they do run much more effective.
It would hurt Google, Facebook and other billboard-selling agencies. Not necessarily a bad thing.
- lend000 9y agoIf there's an externality, then it isn't a sin tax. But make sure you are able to pinpoint the externality so you know how much to tax. There's nothing that irks me more than people wanting to pin taxes on anything that they may not like (even though they can't point to an external aggression).
- bryanlarsen 9y agoSomething like a billboard is pure externality. It exists solely to influence the behaviour of a third party not involved in the transaction. A TV or web ad isn't pure externality -- viewers benefit by getting the content for free or reduced cost. I suspect the billboard effect dominates, though. I'm sure some smart economist could figure out a way to measure that.
- lend000 9y ago> It exists solely to influence the behaviour of a third party not involved in the transaction. And? So are speeches, and HN comments. As long as it isn't fraudulent, I don't see where the aggression/externality comes into play. Similarly, just because someone put up a building you don't like to look at on property that wasn't yours does NOT entitle you to reparations (or the building owner to taxes for the corresponding 'externality'), because in a practical society, it is ridiculous to claim that you were harmed.
- Spivak 9y agoThat would be a little silly, but an ugly building is nonetheless a negative externality not terribly different from existing rules. Constantly playing loud music is a punishable negative externality on your neighbors. The same is true for bright lights. And the raison d'etre for HOAs is practically to protect property values from being affected by dirty and poorly maintained homes. All these originate on someone else's property. Content is where I think the determination would be made -- if you painted an obscene mural on the side of your house I'm sure the courts would make you take it down, but even if your neighbor despised impressionism you would definitely get to keep it if it was Water Lilies. The question is where on the spectrum to advertisements fall: they're not obscene, but they also not harmless. They have a measurable effect on people, maybe informative, maybe harmful.
- lend000 9y ago> The question is where on the spectrum to advertisements fall: they're not obscene, but they also not harmless. They have a measurable effect on people, maybe informative, maybe harmful. Exactly. And the only ways our society could agree an advertisement is harmful is if it 1. was fraudulent, as I said or 2. was obscene/offensive/hateful (see: fighting words category of exceptions to first amendment). However, the OP seemed to think billboards are externalities in and of themselves just because he didn't want to be influenced by any information.
- opportune 9y agoAgreed. Advertising in many cases also isn't a net gain for society. One of its goal is to manufacture demand where there is none. A famous example is the DeBeers diamond company, which created expectations for diamonds to be used as a sign of love in proposals. We could just as well get along as a society without any diamonds in jewelry whatsoever, and might even be better off for it. They didn't realize increase enjoyment in society so much as create a new negative situation (spouse upset/insecure with jewelry) that only money could fix. There are benefits to advertising: it keeps consumers up to date on the current products on the market and can emphasize the positive traits of those products. But in practice it more often relies on psychological tricks and manipulation (look at any Budweiser commercial and tell me it isn't a subtle play to insecure masculinity) that don't necessarily benefit consumers.
- GauntletWizard 9y agoInsane spikes of demand happen. Fashion did not become an industry because of Advertising. Fidget Spinners did not require advertising to be a huge hit. Manufactured demand doesn't happen nearly as much as demand bubbles up and advertising provides the lightning rod by which it's grounded. Advertising can have a lot of really great effects on society, too. You think that conservation programs came out of nowhere? That people learned how to recycle because everyone was really interested? The entire "green" economy is hugely driven by advertising - Not as much the corporate style, but lifestyle advertising driven by conservation nonprofits (whose revenue, by the way, is almost entirely driven by advertising; Look up the rates that nonprofit fundraisers charge, and then realize that despite how insane they are, the nonprofits still find them profitable!)
- ethbro 9y agoCan fashion actually be separated from advertising at this point?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoNone the less it's pretty easy to see advertising and the subsequent consumption is a net loss to the environment.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]