4 ms·
It's awesome that there are so many trees, but don't discount the part about old growth forests. Many replanted 'forests' (at least in Australia) are monocultur
by taneq 9y ago
It's awesome that there are so many trees, but don't discount the part about old growth forests. Many replanted 'forests' (at least in Australia) are monocultures of fast growing softwoods, and not remotely comparable with old growth forest.
- bluGill 9y agoIt isn't necessarily awesome that the US has so many trees. Forests can get overcrowded which is bad for the forest overall even though there are a lot of trees. It isn't just quantity that is important it is the whole ecosystem, those trees that are overcrowded shade out helpful plants on the lower forest floor. Forests in the US generally depend on regular forest fires for health. The US has mostly been putting out those fires and the result is we have a lot more trees than is ideal.
- snerbles 9y agoWhich is where we come in the loop, logging for wood instead of burning. It's when we suppress fires and don't thin the forest that there's dangerous fuel accumulation.
- wavefunction 9y agoPeriodic forest fires definitely seem more healthy for forest ecologies than logging, since they reduce potential fuel and return nutrients to the area. Logging or large forest-fires means significant deforestation/defloration leading to erosion. We should be managing our lands with more controlled burns to periodically reduce the fuel load so a huge unmanageable natural forest fire doesn't break out. Plus some species require forest fires, like ponderosa pine whose pine cones will only open to release their seeds from the heat of a forest fire.
- snerbles 9y agoSure, if the area is clear-cut and not replanted. It wouldn't be good for business if there weren't any more trees to log a few decades from now. Believe it or not, we do think long-term in the timber industry ;) Controlled burns often accompany harvest operations to return nutrients to the soil. > Plus some species require forest fires, like ponderosa pine whose pine cones will only open to release their seeds from the heat of a forest fire. Not the Ponderosa Pine. You are probably thinking of the Lodgepole Pine and Knobcone Pine.
- soperj 9y agoWhy do you say not the Ponderosa?
- snerbles 9y agoI asked a forester. Admittedly this is not the best response for a pseudonymous internet forum. Further searching for links on serotinous (externally triggered) cones turn up sources that almost all refer to the Lodgepole Pine [0]. Also note that these trees have both serotinous and non-serotinous cones - they can still reproduce without the presence of fire, albeit at a lesser rate. That being said, the Ponderosa is fire-resistant, and will survive typical non-crowning fires. [0] https://www.fs.fed.us/database/feis/plants/tree/pinconl/all.html#REGENERATION%20PROCESSES https://www.fs.fed.us/database/feis/plants/tree/pinconl/all....
- bluGill 9y agoWe can do both. You log the large valuable trees, and burn the underbrush. A healthy tree will survive a small forest file without problems and it makes it easier for the loggers to get in to cut the valuable trees they want. This assumes you are doing selective logging and not clear cutting.
- cowpewter 9y agoHere in Florida, those forest fires are required for some of the tree species in the endangered Florida scrub[1] and sandhill[2] ecosystems to germinate, in addition to clearing out space for smaller plants to thrive. Florida has a pretty regular controlled burn system though, developed over the years of trying to protect these habitats. I've never lived on the west coast, but I wonder sometimes if the out-of-control wildfires that happen out there so often would be better if there were more controlled burns happening? Or is it just too dry out there for even that? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_scrub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_scrub http://myfwc.com/conservation/special-initiatives/fwli/archive/taking-action/scrub/ http://myfwc.com/conservation/special-initiatives/fwli/archi... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_longleaf_pine_sandhill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_longleaf_pine_sandhill http://myfwc.com/conservation/special-initiatives/fwli/archive/taking-action/sandhill/ http://myfwc.com/conservation/special-initiatives/fwli/archi...
- germinalphrase 9y agoI've been told that yes - more frequent, smaller burns would be all around better; however, these areas are largely populated and there is zero political will to voluntarily threaten the properties - even if it reduces the risk of catastrophic fires.
- cowpewter 9y agoThat sucks. Around here at least most of the areas that need controlled burns are sparsely populated due to it mostly being federal parkland[1]. Anyway, I guess we have sufficient political will here in Florida, or at least we do after we saw what happens when we don't - the wildfires we had in 1998 [2]. Which were terrifying. The fires got within a few miles of our house at one point, and the sky looked like the scene from Fantasia where all the dinosaurs are dying, with an orange sun that was so dimmed by smoke you could look directly at it without even getting an afterimage on your retina. Ash fell from the sky like snow, and everything smelled like woodsmoke for months. [1] The Ocala National Forest https://www.fs.usda.gov/ocala https://www.fs.usda.gov/ocala [2] https://www.thefreelibrary.com/The+1998+wildfires+in+Central+Florida%3A+Volusia+County's+own...-a054250752 https://www.thefreelibrary.com/The+1998+wildfires+in+Central...
- saalweachter 9y agoIn the northeastern US, this is primarily "natural" regrowth. It's still probably a different mix of trees, but it is a mix, of soft and hard woods. The northeastern US wasn't just logged, it was cleared, primarily for pastureland, and that primarily for sheep. Between cotton, synthetic fabrics, and cheap grazing land out west, it stopped being economically viable, so a lot of northeastern farmland was just abandoned. Over the next ~century, trees took over the once-clear pastures. Now you've got great swaths of woodlots with laboriously constructed stone fences throughout them.