2 ms·
A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else f
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from. It doesn't help anything to have the government hold its own bonds; then your children inherit the debt instead of the unfunded program. It's the same number of dollars no matter what you call it.
And you don't want governments holding other investment assets because the government choosing what to invest the money in would be the world's strongest corruption magnet.
> Rather than reducing high borrowing levels, policy makers use financial engineering, such as quantitative easing and ultra-low or negative interest rates, to maintain them, hoping that a return to growth and just the right amount of inflation will lead to a recovery and allow the debt to be reduced.
This is a misapprehension of the relationship between debt and inflation. Inflation is how you reduce the real value of the debt. It's effectively a tax on dollars, and it reduces the debt on both ends: If the government creates new money then it can spend that instead of borrowed money, and if the value of the dollar goes down then the value of each outstanding dollar of debt goes down.
But none of that changes the problem with retirement benefits because, again, the government holding its own bonds is self-canceling. The only thing inflation might "help" there is to allow a reduction in real (inflation-adjusted) retirement payments without a nominal cut.
If you want the same real benefits then you need to collect that number of real tax dollars, and if you won't or can't collect that number of tax dollars then you have to pay lower benefits.
- pmontra 9y ago> A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from. Not a big deal: those people helped their parents, their children will help them. It's fair and it's what happened for tens of thousand of years: people knew they must have children because without children they'll be pretty much without any support when old. However it works when the number of children is substantial. It can't work with 2 or 1 children per couple and that's where most of the western world is now.
- mjevans 9y agoYet increasing the population will also lead to either war, or the destruction of the environment to the point where none can survive.
- pmontra 9y agoYes. That's one of the many reasons why we're at those levels of natality now and why that kind of hand waving problems to future generations is becoming a problem. I was not advocating for having 4+ children.
- majewsky 9y agoNot only the Western world. Countries like India, Indonesia and Iran all report about 2 children per woman already. https://ourworldindata.org/fertility/ https://ourworldindata.org/fertility/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- omegaworks 9y ago> A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from. I'm frankly surprised at the level of ignorance in these comments. Debt is not zero sum in every regard. Debt in the service of investing in something that will provide a return is not bad debt. For example: Investing $1 into things like preschool programs returns benefit to society of $3-$7. [1] Programs like universal preschool access are no-brainers yet they meet intense resistance from austerity-pushers on both sides of the aisle. 1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2015/04/20/obamas-claim-that-every-dollar-spent-on-pre-kindergarten-education-earns-7-back/?utm_term=.89f8ddbcc200 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2015/04/...
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThe point isn't that the government should never borrow money, it's that it can't lend money to itself. It could easily be that there is a net benefit to society of collecting tax dollars and spending them on preschool, but you aren't adding anything by pretending the tax was to fund a retirement program even though the money was immediately spent on preschool. The preschool program is independent of the retirement program and could exist without it with no change to anything except for the fiction that the tax revenue was for retirement and the debt for preschool instead of the other way around.
- crdoconnor 9y ago"A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from." If you die in 25 years and pass that wealth to your children then it becomes a promise to take resources from somebody else's children and give it to yours. It's simply cementing wealth divisions across generations.
- ajdlinux 9y ago> And you don't want governments holding other investment assets because the government choosing what to invest the money in would be the world's strongest corruption magnet. IDK, sovereign wealth funds seem to work for quite a few countries
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoMostly countries with a positive balance of trade, minimal or no public debt and minimal regulatory capture, none of which is true in the US. And if you actually wanted to do that, it would require deep cuts to other government programs, because the social security administration wouldn't be there to soak up government debt anymore, which would raise interest rates. The same tax dollar can't both be invested in stocks and "borrowed" by the general fund to pay for education or the military.