4 ms·
First step back and consider the possibilities given no knowledge whatsoever: For each child the problem constrains to one of two possible sexes and one of sev
by ubernostrum 9y ago
First step back and consider the possibilities given no knowledge whatsoever:
For each child the problem constrains to one of two possible sexes and one of seven possible days of birth.
2 * 7 = 14 possible sex/day combinations for a single child.
(2 * 7) * (2 * 7) = 196 possible sex/day combinations for a pairing of two children. To see why, you could write a program to enumerate all of them, starting with the pairing "Boy/Monday + Boy/Monday", then "Boy/Monday + Boy/Tuesday" and so on until you exhaust all possible options at "Girl/Sunday + Girl/Sunday". You'll see there are 196 options.
Now start applying the facts given to us: one of the children is born on a Tuesday (eliminate all possibilities which don't have at least one Tuesday child), and that child is a boy (eliminate all possibilities in which there is not a Tuesday child who is also a boy).
This leaves exactly 27 possible cases:
Boy/Sunday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Monday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Wednesday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Thursday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Friday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Saturday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Sunday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Monday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Tuesday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Wednesday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Thursday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Friday + Boy/Tuesday,
Girl/Saturday + Boy/Tuesday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Sunday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Monday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Wednesday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Thursday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Friday,
Boy/Tuesday + Boy/Saturday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Sunday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Monday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Tuesday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Wednesday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Thursday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Friday,
Boy/Tuesday + Girl/Saturday
If you count, you'll see that of those 27, there are 13 with two boys and 14 with a boy and a girl. The probability of two boys, given that one child is a boy born on Tuesday, is thus 13/27.