3 ms·
Philosophers often contradict themselves, or at least apparently contradict themselves. It's also quite possible to misinterpret what a philosopher is actually
by pmoriarty 9y ago
Philosophers often contradict themselves, or at least apparently contradict themselves. It's also quite possible to misinterpret what a philosopher is actually saying (as you point out people do with respect to Nietzsche). Picking out such contradictions and correcting misunderstandings of other philosophers has been a mainstay of philosophy for a very long time. So to claim that something "obvious" about Plato's teachings is actually not what it at first appears is really par for the course.
In fact, the author seems to address your complaint when he says, "It may well seem that Plato does suggest techne is the best model for moral knowledge. In other words, it may seem that his goal is to establish an expert or authority in the field of the good-bad, just-unjust. Many scholars think this ideal is embodied in the famous "philosopher-rulers" of the Republic. I think these scholars are all wrong, and I wrote a book trying to explain why."