4 ms·
Being anti-housing in urban areas doesn't just hurt the poor and middle class. It's also definitively anti-environment. The people who would've ended up in new
by TulliusCicero 9y ago
Being anti-housing in urban areas doesn't just hurt the poor and middle class. It's also definitively anti-environment.
The people who would've ended up in new housing don't just disappear into the ether; they end up living in some further out suburb, where they contribute to encroaching on nature, and where they have longer, more energy-intensive commutes.
To be an environmentalist and a NIMBY is a contradiction in terms. The bay area, unfortunately, is chock full of hypocrites of this sort.
- ScottBurson 9y agoSomeone else posted this link in response to another comment, but I think it's more relevant to yours: http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-liberal-aspirations-and-liberal-housing-policy-is-killing-coastal-u-s-cities/ http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-... Here's a quote: In many metro areas, household emissions in the suburbs are roughly double those of city households.
- santaclaus 9y ago> The bay area, unfortunately, is chock full of hypocrites of this sort. Cough San Francisco Sierra Club Cough
- davidw 9y agoRelevant links about SF Sierra Club: https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/05/31/san-franciscos-sierra-club-is-a-bastion-of-faux-environmentalism/#4e52b1527c34 https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/05/31/san-franc... They're fighting to preserve a.... car garage. http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-fights-to-savea-parking-garage http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-f...
- Spooky23 9y agoGeorge Washington had his oil changed there!
- kevinburke 9y agoIf fixing this interests you, please consider signing up for a membership and voting for better executives in the local elections, or writing the national chapter and asking them to decertify the local group; I have several friends doing both.
- Medaber 9y agoAnother very common hypocrisy: obese environmentalists. You can't eat more food than a human being needs and call yourself "green". Yet many do!
- e_hup 9y agoHere is a summary of basically exactly what you're talking about, happening just a few miles away from Berkeley: http://www.oaklandmagazine.com/June-2017/Dealing-with-the-Sprawl-Devil/ http://www.oaklandmagazine.com/June-2017/Dealing-with-the-Sp...
- exclusiv 9y agoI've never thought of it that way but it definitely makes sense. Apart from the anti-housing issues that you outlined, the city loses out on new property tax revenue that would be levied at the current market rate. Staying in office is always the #1 goal.
- maxsilver 9y agoI wish urbanists / "urban planners" would learn that same lesson too. They seem to think gentrification / "YIMBYism" is "good" because it "invests in" or "cleans up" the neighborhood, not realizing that all the poorer people they "cleaned up" don't disappear -- they too end up living in some further out area, with all the same problems that causes. Edit: This isn't an anti-construction argument. This is a pro-appropriate-construction argument. Not just any new building works towards a solution. Not just any units actually help the supply side of this problem.
- closeparen 9y agoWhere do you think existing residents go when migrants take over the existing housing stock? Like many in this debate, you seem to think that preventing housing construction prevents population change. But it only preserves the size of the population, not the composition There is more than enough demand already to unseat every long-time renter by outbidding them at lease renewal time, and this is happening. No developer intervention required.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Like many in this debate, you seem to think that preventing housing construction prevents population change. But it only preserves the size of the population, not the composition It doesn't preserve size, either. Existing units can be occupied more densely, units not intended (or legally permitted) for residential use can be occupied, and population can grow that isn't housed.
- maxsilver 9y ago> Like many in this debate, you seem to think that preventing housing construction prevents population change. Not at all. That's a claim you've invented entirely on your own, not something I said. -- My claim is that YIMBYism is often an attempt to replicate the housing problems seen in places like Berkley, not an attempt to fix them. YIMBYism is often an attempt to inflate property just like NIMBYism is. If 1,000 people are slowly dying of thirst in the desert, and PepsiCo offers to build a Pepsi distribution plant in your desert, some people will say "no" and some will say "yes", and neither will be addressing the water shortage problem because Pepsi isn't water. That's essentially how housing works today. No one builds housing for residents, which is the problem. If you oppose the construction of buildings that are not housing for residents (like say, luxury condos), you get slandered with a "NIMBY" label, despite being pro-housing, because the construction makes the existing problem worse (the act of constructing that luxury condo will inflate all nearby property values too, displacing more people than the new building itself will hold)