3 ms·
Every time software patents come up we have the same conversation here. Someone will look at the title, e.g. in this case "Unlocking a device by performing gest
by ZeroGravitas 16y ago
Every time software patents come up we have the same conversation here. Someone will look at the title, e.g. in this case "Unlocking a device by performing gestures on an unlock image" and say what!?, how can that be patentable.
Then someone will come along and say, that bit of text is totally meaningless, it's the actual claims that count.
But fundamentally, how could anything under that heading no matter how tenuously connected or complex actually be worth a patent.
edit: link to patent http://www.google.com/patents?id=dUnKAAAAEBAJ http://www.google.com/patents?id=dUnKAAAAEBAJ
Can someone give valid argument as to why that isn't total BS, cause I'm not seeing anything but standard phone unlock, now with a touchscreen.
- kiba 16y agoWell, it's nothing new, really. Patent shenanigans has been happening since before James Watt got into patent wars with various steam engine inventors. You see, all those who think patent problems are a recent phenomena of our time are clearly mistaken. It's a disaster that stretches centuries. Nobody wants to think about abolishing it of course. It's unthinkable and so obviously wrong. We should reform it. We should fix it! We should do anything but abolish it! But you know what? If those crazy libertarians believe in those clearly outrageous ideas, maybe they do have some merits. It would seem to be so opposite to the idea of property right and ownership, but yet those crazy ideologue believe IP to be incompatible with property rights. I mean, we even got Eric Raymond being afraid of IP abolitionists being right. But clearly, I will be dismissed as someone with no entrepreneurial experience or just some kid who only want free musics. A nut-case who only considers short-term interest. I guess I'll have to crush you all in the business arena and show you how wrong you clearly are.
- jacksoncarter 16y agoPerhaps we should abolish all property rights? What exactly are property rights anyway? The government can use eminent domain to take them. The white people can take them from the aboriginals. Property rights really only apply if you are powerful enough to ignore them or defend them yourself. Those home owners in Connecticut weren't powerful enough to stop the corporations from using their property to build an apartment. The same is true of patents. You can get the patent and own it legitimately, but if a more powerful corporation has better lawyers, they'll take it. It's like laws don't really exist. Laws are written to those in power as we go along. As the power shifts, the laws shift toward the powerful. I read this morning that states are reducing pensions for people who have paid into them for years. Isn't that pension, essentially their property as well? That's been taken away. Do property rights really exist? I was also thinking about it from another perspective. Say you create a park and want to charge people to enter it. You only want to let 5 people enter the park, but 10 people who didn't pay to enter, enter anyway. They don't take anything from other people. The park is still there just as the movie is still there if it is pirated. Nothing is lost except revenue for tickets to enter.
- kiba 16y agoThinks of correct property rights as being a sort of rule of laws. Now the rule of laws might be a legal fiction, but it does have utilitarian benefits. People can predict and know what's going to happen to them if they transgress and plan their life around that. Moreover, it give them incentive to invest and increase our overall wealth in the long term. However, some people likes to make the rules of law a quasi ethical principle. That what some people called, "justice".
- 10ren 16y agoBTW: I'm not in the slightest bit interested in complaining about or arguing for patents - it's the opposite of intellectually interesting to me: it's boring and emotional. Thanks for the link. My reading: Claim one is that dragging an icon to a drop location unlocks the device. It's like dragging to the recycle bin, except that: 1. the drop location is a "region", not an icon (a bit more general); 2. the action isn't to move a file, but to unlock the device (ie. trigger this specific global event) This doesn't seem sensational to me, but it does sound like a good idea: simulating a slider for unlocking. "Pocket unlocking" would be less likely to happen, and it would look cool. Although drag-n-drop is well known, it's never been used to trigger a global event (TMK). The subsequent claims refine this: the icon must be dragged along a displayed route; or within channels; or the direction of dragging is given by arrows or text (presumably randomized). These aren't purely "gestures" because they involve interaction with elements on the screen. The last one - text directions - is probably the one most likely to be upheld by the court. (for completeness, the other claims are just alternate language for the same thing - to circumvent seemingly irrelevant syntactic distinctions between eg. "system" and "method") Just because someone claims something doesn't mean it's true. Like any other claim - in a thesis, in an advertisement, by a politician - it may be true or false. You need to check out the evidence and the criteria used to evaluate it. What is interesting will be to hear the court's opinion. That's what counts, as far as "patent law" is concerned, not what the inventor claims. [nb: I've used "claims" with two distinct meanings here: the claims are claimed]