5 ms·
10x doesn't have to mean producing 10x more code - just 10x more effective than the average developer. In my experience, clever (usually simple) architecture i
by j45 9y ago
10x doesn't have to mean producing 10x more code - just 10x more effective than the average developer.
In my experience, clever (usually simple) architecture in solving a problem will always beat clever code, and volumes of code.
- thehardsphere 9y ago10x is 10x the least skilled developer who is still employed, not 10x the average (median) developer.
- pawadu 9y agoYou obviously haven't met the 0.1x developer ... ... or the infamous -10x developer. Count your blessings.
- thehardsphere 9y agoI actually read some of the research that produced the 10x number. The 0.1x developer, if they're actually competent enough to remain employed for more than a probationary period, probably isn't at 0.1x; you're probably underrating them because you're better than average and are thus overrating what average is. (This is part of the Dunning-Kruger effect). -10x developers should be fired fairly quickly if they're actually that negative and the business is being managed competently. I've worked with a few; they were fired within months or weeks.
- whatnotests 9y agoI've always considered the Dunning-Kruger effect from the perspective of "too dumb to know I'm dumb" not "too smart to know I'm smart". Interesting to think it goes in both directions!
- tdeck 9y agoIt's a common misconception that the Dunning-Kruger effect is just about dumb people not knowing they're dumb. In fact, it's about something we all do - overestimating our knowledge and competence in areas where we have little of both. It's worth recognizing the distinction because everyone is subject to the Dunning-Kruger effect when we're out of our depth in some area and there are a lot of "unknown unknowns".
- thehardsphere 9y agoYeah, most people know "too dumb to know I'm dumb." The "too smart to know I'm smart" is less well known but it has a lot of implications. For instance, highly skilled people will often underestimate the difficulty of a task for average skilled people, because they complete it with relative ease. It's effectively an overestimation of what "average" is, because they think of themselves as average when they're really not. "Relative" is the key word here. Your natural high skill performer may think a task is difficult, but they don't necessarily find the same sources of difficulty as average people.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoI've always heard the "too smart to know I'm smart" as manifesting differently. Getting better improves two distinct sub-skills: excution, and perception of performance flaws. Dunning-Krugar effect, to me, just says that flaw perception grows faster with skill than execution does. At a concrete level, I remember watching a lecture from a Jazz instructor by the name of Hal Galper, who said something like "Not liking the music you're playing is a sign that you're getting better, since it means you can now hear the mistakes you've always been making". It's really stuck with me through learning other creative pursuits (dance, in particular).
- thehardsphere 9y agoI have heard someone else say a similar thing about writing, and I believe it. They described it as "having or developing taste", and were encouraging people to keep writing through those feelings because as they got better it would help them know what to write and what not to write. Dunno if I've seen it in software development, but I also don't have any real objective estimation of how good I am at software development.
- kbaldor 9y agoIt does, and has since its original discovery. Though the effect is not as pronounced as its popular conception would have you believe. The poor performers overrated their performance, but did not rate it higher than the high performers did. It is more like the grandparent observed that everyone tends to think of themselves as close to average.
- rurban 9y agoNo. The negative ones usually form crowds and alliances, and with a lot of backpadding and self management it leads to your typical failed projects. Many of them are very high-profile, and they would never have the insight that they are actually more destructive than useful. That's why forks do exist.
- sp332 9y agoIt's 10x more productive than the least productive, which means about 3x more productive than average. http://www.ybrikman.com/writing/2013/09/29/the-10x-developer-is-not-myth/ http://www.ybrikman.com/writing/2013/09/29/the-10x-developer...
- jblow 9y agoI don't understand why HN readers are so eager to debunk the idea of 10x developer when it's obvious they exist. For example, in this post you seem to be setting the upper bound around 3x. But actually, it is trivial to be 3x more productive than average: (a) Don't browse the internet while at work; (b) Sit there and spend your time working on the actual problem, not ratholing on programmer fixations that have nothing to do with the end result. Done. Congratulations, you are now 3x, before any consideration is made of experience level or talent or smartness or unique instinct or whatever else.
- sp332 9y agoAre you specifically disagreeing with the original post, about working less hours in a week etc?
- jblow 9y agoI posted my general thoughts on this topic yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14538761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14538761
- mattmanser 9y agoYou make it sound so trivial to do, but in fact if you did that you'd burn out. All that ratholing and reading is in fact resting. You can only concentrate so many hours a day. Without that resting your productivity drops. The most productive/best programmer I knew used to piss around flying virtual helicopters for half the afternoon, would throw together prototypes no-one asked him to because he was bored, and went home at 5:30 every day.
- 9y ago
- gdulli 9y agoYes, and it's also about inflection points, like avoiding choosing the wrong technology that could make a project 10x less successful than it might have been. Or making the wrong build vs. buy decision. Decisions that require experience and insight, that you have to make early and will be impactful and can't be easily reversed when they turn out to be mistakes.
- QuantumGravy 9y agoThe wonderful thing about 10x developers is that you can keep redefining what 10x means to make your point. The 10x developer is a mythical beast that changes with every retelling. There's only one definition with any experimental weight behind it—10x the worst and 2.5x average—which isn't quite terrifying enough to keep telling stories about 'round the campfire.
- j45 9y agoHaha, or they just have a highly unusual track record of delivering entire projects that would take longer or larger teams to complete. They are forces of nature, prolific creators that deliver when they have to, and lift up entire teams to be better when they work with others. The right kind of compounding experience goes a long way.
- QuantumGravy 9y agoThat's a perfect illustration of what I'm getting at. You can just keep redefining whatever 10x means to make your point. In your example, minus the the initial "Haha", this might as well be lifted from a cover letter or a consultant's sales pitch: "I have a highly unique track record of delivering entire projects that would take longer schedules or larger teams to complete. Clients have called me a force of nature, a prolific creator that delivers when the job must get done and one who lifts up entire teams to be better when they work beside me. I provide the right kind of compounding experience that goes a long way." Such confidence. The hiring managers are swooning over here. But that's beside the point. Where's the study that meaningfully quantified that type of performance? Especially at an individual, repeatable level? If we can't answer those questions, I must conclude that the current usage of 10x developer is about as meaningful as "passionate ninja rockstar".
- rudyrigot 9y agoAuthor here. You're basically summarizing my entire article in a much (MUCH!) more digest and straightforward way. So, yeah, absolutely +1000 and thanks for that!