4 ms·
> I fundamentally object to the notion that the government gives you a right to a monopoly on an idea, for what looks like perpetuity -- nothing has gone out of
by nailer 16y ago
> I fundamentally object to the notion that the government gives you a right to a monopoly on an idea, for what looks like perpetuity -- nothing has gone out of copyright since 1923.
Copyright reform has nothing to do with advocating piracy. By advocating piracy, you are harming copyright reform.
TPB steal from:
* OReilly
* Red Hat
* Novell
* IBM
* The World of Goo people
* Trent Reznor
and other artists most people on HN agree are doing interesting things with copyright. Red Hat maintain a fucking list of patents they use to defend OSS against proprietary patent trolls! Yet TPB steals from them. You have no reason to buy an OReilly book if you can get it on TPB.
> Stealing means you've lost something i.e. no longer have it.
The common definition of stealing means you're taking something that isn't yours. I understand you disagree, but I don't care.
> Third, the comparison to slavery was only to disprove your assertion "Doing something wrong to someone else who did something wrong is still wrong."
Do you think you disproved that assertion?
> I'm not trying to encourage piracy
But you are encouraging piracy. You're defending The Pirate Bay. Which is a pirate site. Hence the name 'The Pirate Bay, the pictures of pirates, the jolly roger, and the stealing.
TPB, and TPP harm copyright reform. People who make stuff, and people who don't like stealing