4 ms·
> Sex is an instinct too -- but how many do it badly? Nature has a different definition of 'good' sex. Something like 'productive', as opposed to 'enjoyable'.
by Chris2048 9y ago
> Sex is an instinct too -- but how many do it badly?
Nature has a different definition of 'good' sex. Something like 'productive', as opposed to 'enjoyable'.
- coldtea 9y agoThat's my point too. Nature has a different definition of good language too. A human ape barely being able to communicate is enough, eloquence is not necessary.
- Chris2048 9y agoHmmm, I suppose it depends on whether 'eloquence' contributes to intent / being understood. I'd also argue that a second form of evolution now exists - "memetic" evolution, of which language is the medium.
- coldtea 9y ago>Hmmm, I suppose it depends on whether 'eloquence' contributes to intent / being understood. It might, but it probably goes beyond the mere "understood", so it's more cultural than necessary for evolution beyond a point. (Same with sex though: as parent commenter noted, being good at it is not any great evolutionary advantage. Just being able to do it to reproduce is enough).