19 ms·
> back when fat was evil Not fat (the replacement was also fat) but rather saturated fat was the evil one.
by ars 9y ago
> back when fat was evil
Not fat (the replacement was also fat) but rather saturated fat was the evil one.
- markdown 9y agoIs it no longer so? Is saturated fat now considered OK?
- cowmoo728 9y agoThe tl;dr of it is that large amounts of saturated fat may not be exactly good for you, but the dangers were grossly over exaggerated. You should probably still eat mostly vegetables, but you can put some butter and lard on things and not feel guilty.
- tcoff91 9y agoIt's complicated. According to what I heard from Dr. Rhonda Patrick, it's not inherently bad on its own, but when eaten with sugar it causes the formation of small dense LDL particles, which contribute to the clogging of arteries.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Not fat (the replacement was also fat) but rather saturated fat was the evil one. Shortening is vegetable oil that's been treated to transform it into (in part) saturated fat. So it's not even about that, either.
- ars 9y agoNo, partially hydrogenated oil is not saturated, it's unsaturated. Today we give is a separate category of "trans", but back then it was listed with the unsaturated fats. They made sure not to let it run far enough that any of it was saturated. Which is exactly why it was made! Specifically to look good on food labels. (And because it was cheap.) Such a huge mistake. (Fully hydrogenated fat is saturated.)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> No, partially hydrogenated oil is not saturated, it's unsaturated. Shortening made with partially hydrogenated oil contains saturated fat, at, IIRC, about the same levels (1/4 of the total far content) as modern, trans-racialism free shortening. It has somewhat less saturated fat than butter or lard, but the main reason for the texture that makes it even remotely suitable as a lard replacement is the saturated fat. > Which is exactly why it was made! Specifically to look good on food labels. Nope, it was made first (with the intent of being a feedstock for soap production), it's ability to serve as a lard substitute identified and marketing in that role began, then it became popular industrially for cost reasons, then the health myths came later. The health myths did not motivate it's development, if anything the reverse is true.