3 ms·
At a minimum, the businesses should be paying the state the prevailing wage for the jobs being done (the business owner should not be a beneficiary of below mar
by maxerickson 9y ago
At a minimum, the businesses should be paying the state the prevailing wage for the jobs being done (the business owner should not be a beneficiary of below market labor).
Even better if the prisoners keep a substantial portion of that.
- gozur88 9y agoMoney is fungible. If companies weren't benefiting from low wage labor they'd be charging the state more to house the inmates.
- maxerickson 9y agoMany of the jobs are outside of the prison system. Inside the prison system I'd be fine with making them do the accounting based on prevailing wages even if the money is going in a circle.
- jstelly 9y agoA bunch of this is for the "transitional work program" which sounds more like a way for prisoners to get out of prison more smoothly: http://www.doc.louisiana.gov/transitional-work-program http://www.doc.louisiana.gov/transitional-work-program I don't know anything in particular about the program, but why do you think the business should pay the prevailing wage? How many prisoners would get hired with that requirement vs. without it? As a business owner why would I prefer to hire a prisoner instead of someone not in prison? Or am I thinking about it the wrong way? It sounds like hiring a prisoner benefits the prison system and the prisoner (and also the business as long as there is an incentive of some kind).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 9y agoBecause it puts the business owner ahead of their competitors and neighbors (they are gaining from the favor of the state). You make a fair point of incentives to hire prisoners rather than others though.
- jstelly 9y agoThere are going to be costs, but maybe this is actually a relatively low-cost option for helping to get prisoners back out into the world (and not back into prison). It is certainly cheaper than keeping them in prison. It says on that page that 10-20 percent of prisoners stay with their employer after being released. That seems low to me, but I haven't studied other solutions to this problem for comparison.
- SilasX 9y agoKind of a nitpick, but that would make it pointless since, if you're paying the prevailing wage, you might as well use free (as in freedom) labor[1], since you need a lot more compliance procedures and security for the prison labor. I think a better standard is that the labor should be competitively bid for with multiple buyers at any given time so there's actual competition for it. The prevailing wage would be lower than for free(..dom) labor, but not the pittance they're currently stuck with. [1] yes, which to some, is a feature not a bug