3 ms·
> How many millions of lives has this institution of liberal democracy destroyed? How is this an institution "of" liberal democracy? I can either interpret tha
by kbenson 9y ago
> How many millions of lives has this institution of liberal democracy destroyed?
How is this an institution "of" liberal democracy? I can either interpret that as liberal democracy as destroying lives, or that working while incarcerated is a feature of liberal democracy. I don't think either are true.
- vkou 9y agoLiberal democracies get extremely holier-then-thou about slavery - state-sponsored or otherwise. Yet, they have no natural means of preventing it from happening inside them! My point is that we turn a blind eye to it happening at home. People working in the GULAG were also paying their 'debt to society'. Not all of them were political prisoners, either.
- kbenson 9y agoSo is the "institution" the different perception of local incarceration vs incarceration in other countries, or the incarceration itself?
- vkou 9y agoIt's a difference in perception - cognitive dissonance. There are obviously differences in the incarceration (Our prisons ruin many lives - but Soviet ones ended them. Depending on the year, mortality rates were between 1 and 20% - the highest were during the war.)
- kbenson 9y agoAh. The original comment seemed to imply it was the prisons that were a feature of liberal democracies, which seemed a weird leap to take. I agree with you in general. The penal system is just one of many systems that's overly politicized in a national context. It's part of the general problem of the U.S. not being very good at relative comparisons with other countries without reverting to a nationalistic dick-measuring contest. It's the nasty downside to American Exceptionalism. On one end, it spurs people to attempt to be better because they expect they should be better, on the other it causes people to infer differences between our attributes and those of others that we don't particularly like, even when in practice those differences don't amount to all that much.
- anigbrowl 9y agoIt's clearly a product of liberal democracy, and it's liberal in the sense of allowing such business ventures to exist and to indeed to be voted for by the public (manipulated by advertising and ark money, of course, but nevertheless). The problem of liberalism is its failure to adequately guard against such institutional abuses, just as the problem of communism is its failure to guard against being hijacked by authoritarians. In the 25 years since the fall of the Soviet Union and the general consensus that communism was an ideological failure, western democracies own ideological limitations have been examined and found wanting in many respects. Chief among these are an incarceration rate that far exceeds that of the most stereotypically autocratic nations, and the deplorable conditions therein. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarceration_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera... Liberalism all too easily degenerates into mere license, and has demonstrably failed to result in liberation for those who suffer unjustly under the yoke of authority. To some extent the blame falls on a myopic utilitarianism that equates its quantitative capability with omniscience, and by assuming its own goodness as axiomatic has lost the ability to evaluate its own moral anchorings, instead drifting about aimlessly on the currents of its own desire.