5 ms·
Can't some of these oil rigs be reused as artificial islands? Is the Seasteading institute looking into this already? They should be all over it.
by Tepix 9y ago
Can't some of these oil rigs be reused as artificial islands?
Is the Seasteading institute looking into this already? They should be all over it.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoA seasteader would have to pay more than the rig's value as scrap (less the cost of scrapping it). That might turn out to be quite a bit of money. Or, it might turn out to be zero. The article left it unclear whether they (the owners of the platforms) are making or losing money by doing this. But there are two other concerns that would have to be addressed: Plugging the oil well, and navigational hazards. Neither seems to me to be insurmountable. Plugging the hole and leaving the platform there is easier than plugging the hole and removing the platform. And the navigational hazard has been there for decades. Leaving it changes nothing; an existing risk merely continues.
- Tepix 9y agoSure, you'd have to pay for the scrap value. But it's never [1] going to be cheaper than that anyway. I'm not sure what environmental hazards the (former) oil rigs themselves are. -- [1] until we get self-assembling nanobots one day
- fnordfnordfnord 9y agoIf the platform weighs 100,000 ton and scrap iron is between $50 and $100/ton, then the rig's scrap value can't be more than $10,000,000, but it can be a lot less. Maybe it costs you a couple million dollars just to have it towed back, then maybe a couple million in labor and tools to cut it up, and a million in hazardous waste (asbestos) disposal, and so on. TBH, I don't know how much all of this really costs, but I can see where dismantling a rig could potentially cost quite a bit more than its scrap value, and thus the thing can have a negative value. In that case it might be quite attractive if the owner of the thing can transfer that responsibility to someone else. They might even pay you to take it.
- briffle 9y agoPlugging the hole and leaving the structure would also mean maintaining the structure. I can't imagine the costs of maintaining something that large.
- oh_sigh 9y agoEspecially in the middle of the sea, which is not a very forgiving environment.
- fnordfnordfnord 9y agoThese are production platforms, not drilling platforms. A production platform like the one mentioned in the article gathers oil and gas from dozens of wells connected by a system of piping laid on the sea floor. As such, they'd have no way to plug a well. Operators use mobile rigs to do a "P&A" (Plug and Abandon). There's no way that the permitting authority would allow the well operator to abandon any wellhead without plugging it, no matter who they'd sold the production platform to.
- gozur88 9y ago>A seasteader would have to pay more than the rig's value as scrap (less the cost of scrapping it). That might turn out to be quite a bit of money. I suspect that number is actually negative without the rig owner's input. Thus the bit about Shell "watching over" the process to make sure the breakers are dealing properly with chemicals and asbestos. On of the reasons the US Navy has taken to sinking decommissioned warships is the various hazardous materials make the cost of breaking them up more than the value of the materials. Rigs can't be that different.
- autokad 9y ago"The oil companies do not want a repeat of the mid-1990s. Back then, Shell’s plan to sink a piece of Brent equipment, called Brent Spar, in the ocean depths caused a bruising fight with environmental groups led by Greenpeace and prompted stricter regulation."
- luhn 9y agoI don't see how that's relevant. Repurposing an old oil rig is a far cry from scuttling it.
- theoh 9y agoAny arrangement of an afterlife for a rig became a liability...
- cynicalbastard 9y agoit's relevant because the people who write the billion dollar checks don't want to bother with the risk.
- mpweiher 9y agoThe irony was that after all that, Greenpeace had to finally admit that the original plan of sinking the Brent Spar was actually the most environmentally friendly option. Turns out that bacteria at the bottom of the ocean love the sludge that's so toxic on land. So a big "yay" for PR and feelings over facts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brent_Spar#Deep_sea_disposal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brent_Spar#Deep_sea_disposal
- kevhito 9y agoCan you provide a citation for your claims here. The link you provided doesn't seem to back up your claim at all. Actually, it seems to contradict your claim. Also, assuming what you say is true, was this known at the time? Because that would seem to make a big difference -- opposing dumping "sludge that's so toxic on land" into an environment where you don't know the effects seems to be more than "PR and feelings", but rather caution and prudence.
- dflock 9y agoI don't think that the cold, grim, gray & very rough North Sea would be anyone's first choice to start a Seasteading habitat.
- Tepix 9y agoSome of the oil rigs get transported to southeast asia before they are dismantled. Check out the south Atlantic for a possible location, west of the Namibian coast. There are some shallow spots there like the Zubov Seamount, less than 50m deep and more than 200 miles from the coast.
- chrisseaton 9y agoLiving on an isolated platform off the Namibian coast sounds like a deliberate plan to get kidnapped by pirates.
- fnordfnordfnord 9y agoYou'd have to be producing something valuable, but then again, that's one of the economic models behind seasteading is production of high value goods which are forbidden to produce on land. ie: drugs, dangerous materials, etc.
- chrisseaton 9y agoIs the idea that you're in international water so you can do what you want? What stops a navy coming and confiscating your equipment then? They stop drug smugglers and pirates in international waters all the time. And you'll be static!
- fnordfnordfnord 9y ago>Is the idea that you're in international water so you can do what you want? Pretty much as I understand it, but I don't think they're under the illusion that they don't have to maintain some sort of relationship with land-based nations. >What stops a navy coming and confiscating your equipment then? Nothing? Some form of diplomacy? >They stop drug smugglers and pirates in international waters all the time. And you'll be static! They never stop them all. I don't think I will be static. I'll be on the beach.
- rolltack 9y agoI didn't know there was a seasteading institute. That's pretty neat. Getting stuck on one of these decrepit beasts in gnarly weather could be fun. I figure those guys would have more fun on a sailboat surfing through waves. Plus the mainland is always within reach and there are so many places to visit.
- jacquesm 9y ago> Plus the mainland is always within reach If you have a fleet of helicopters or suppliers. The North Sea can be pretty rough, there are times when the mainland might as well be on the moon.
- hristov 9y agoI don't think so. These rigs look massive and permanent, but in reality they are constantly deteriorating. Thus, they should not be compared to an island. Salt water is very bad for steel. And the ocean waves and winds constantly put stress on said steel. If they get left without being dismantled for a while, they will get into a very dangerous state where they are about to fall apart and it is too dangerous to even approach them. Then dismantling them will be much more expensive.
- Ntrails 9y ago>If they get left without being dismantled for a while, they will get into a very dangerous state where they are about to fall apart and it is too dangerous to even approach them. Then dismantling them will be much more expensive. Once the Well itself is plugged, what are the realistic consequences of just letting the things rust into oblivion?
- dx034 9y agoI guess they could crash, start floating around and hit ships.
- mason240 9y agoThe value of scrap metal is so high I'm guessing the recovery will pay for itself.
- gideonparanoid 9y agoThat depends on how environmentally friendly you want to be in reclaiming that steel [0]: > A secondhand vessel is currently worth about $190 per tonne to a shipbreaking yard in Turkey, a price established by the local market in reclaimed steel. Sail on to China and a different market, and the same metal is worth $210 per tonne. At breakers’ yards in Alang in India, Chittagong in Bangladesh and Gadani in Pakistan, they will pay around $280 per tonne. Meanwhile, at the EU-approved shipbreaking sites, which are bound to conform to continental waste laws, and where vessels are dismantled in closed-off quays or dry docks, rates are less competitive: European yards offer zero dollars per tonne, and, in fact, tend to ask a fee to take a shipowners’ junk. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/may/02/where-oil-rigs-go-to-die https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/may/02/where-oil-r...